192 F.2d 974 (3d Cir. 1951)
In 1947 the plaintiff, then a child of ten, was involved in a street accident in the city of Birmingham, Alabama. A motor car nearly ran over her. A newspaper photographer who happened to be on the spot took a photograph of the child being lifted to her feet by a woman bystander. The picture was dramatic and its effect was heightened by the fact that it was an action picture, not one posed for the camera.1
The photograph appeared in a Birmingham newspaper the day following. Twenty months later it was used by the Curtis Publishing Company as an illustration for an article on traffic accidents, with emphasis on pedestrian carelessness, under the title “They Ask To Be Killed” by David G. Wittels. The print was purchased by Curtis from a supplier of illustration material.2
The plaintiff brought suit against the Curtis Publishing Company in federal district court on the basis of diversity of citizenship. Plaintiff had a judgment in the District Court following a jury verdict that awarded her five thousand dollars. The defendant appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, challenging both the right to recover and the amount awarded.3
The suit was brought in the federal court on diversity of citizenship only.4 The original publication in the Birmingham newspaper the day after the accident was conceded not to constitute an actionable invasion.5
Whether the privilege attached to the original publication of the plaintiff's photograph was lost by the passage of twenty months before its republication?6
The right of privacy is an established part of tort law.7 Its outlines and the privilege to invade it are still dimly marked.8 The general criterion for liability is that the defendant’s conduct was such that he should have realized that it would be offensive to persons of ordinary sensibilities.9 A person who is the subject of a striking catastrophe is the object of legitimate public interest during a period of time after the misfortune has brought them to the public attention.10 They remain so until they have reverted to the lawful and unexciting life led by the great bulk of the community.11
No. The established facts indicate that the photograph of the plaintiff was taken at the time of her 1947 accident and first published the following day in a Birmingham newspaper.12 Twenty months later the Curtis Publishing Company republished the photograph as an illustration in the Saturday Evening Post.13
The court determined that the immunity from liability for the original publication was not lost through lapse of time when the same picture was again published.14 This conclusion drew support from the Sidis case in which a similar article appeared nearly thirty years after the events that made the subject newsworthy.15
The privilege attached to the original publication was not lost by the passage of twenty months before republication.16
Whether the privilege was lost by the use of the photograph as an illustration for an article on pedestrian carelessness rather than as part of a news report of the accident?17
Yes. Although the plaintiff was newsworthy with regard to her traffic accident, the use of her picture had nothing to do with her accident but instead related to the general subject of traffic accidents and pedestrian carelessness.20
The heading of the article and the caption under the picture tended to say that the plaintiff narrowly escaped death because she was careless of her own safety.21 This exceeded the bounds of privilege even though it was not libelous.22
The privilege was lost by the use of the photograph as an illustration for an article on pedestrian carelessness.23