394 Mass. 131, 475 N.E.2d 65 (1985)
In September 1973, Carole D. MacDonald, then twenty-six years old, obtained a prescription for Ortho-Novum contraceptive pills manufactured by Ortho Pharmaceutical Corporation from her gynecologist.1
The pill dispenser included a warning required by FDA regulations.2 It stated that oral contraceptives are powerful drugs that can cause side effects.3 It also stated that the most serious known side effect is abnormal blood clotting which can be fatal.4 MacDonald also received a booklet from Ortho.5 The booklet detailed information about the pill, including the increased risk that vital organs such as the brain may be damaged by abnormal blood clotting.6 The word stroke did not appear in either the dispenser warning or the booklet.7
MacDonald's prescription was renewed at annual visits to her gynecologist.8 She used the pills for approximately three years.9 On July 24, 1976, MacDonald suffered an occlusion of a cerebral artery by a blood clot, commonly known as a stroke.10 The stroke caused the death of about twenty percent of her brain tissue and left her permanently disabled.11 She and her husband initiated an action in the Superior Court against Ortho seeking recovery for her personal injuries and his consequential damages and loss of consortium.12
At trial, MacDonald testified that she was unaware the risk of abnormal blood clotting included the risk of stroke.13 She also testified that she would not have used the pills if warned of that risk.14 The jury returned a special verdict.15 It found that Ortho adequately advised the gynecologist of the risks but failed to give MacDonald sufficient warning.16 It found that the pills caused her injury and that the inadequate warnings were the proximate cause.17 The verdict rendered Ortho liable to the plaintiffs.18 The trial judge granted Ortho's motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict.19 The judge concluded that the manufacturer had no duty to warn the consumer directly.20 The plaintiffs appealed.21 The case was transferred to the Supreme Judicial Court on its own motion.22
Whether a manufacturer of oral contraceptives owes a direct duty to warn consumers of the dangers inherent in the use of the pill?23
Ordinarily, a manufacturer of a product which the manufacturer knows or should know is dangerous by nature or is in a dangerous condition is under a duty to give warning of those dangers to persons who it is foreseeable will come in contact with and consequently be endangered by that product.24 For prescription drugs the prescribing physician acts as a learned intermediary between the manufacturer and the patient.25 The duty of the ethical drug manufacturer is to warn the doctor rather than the patient.26 Oral contraceptives bear peculiar characteristics which warrant the imposition of a common law duty on the manufacturer to warn users directly of associated risks.27 The healthy young consumer is actively involved in the decision to use the pill.28 The prescribing physician is relegated to a relatively passive role with only annual examinations.29 The product is subject to extensive federal regulation requiring direct written warnings to users.30
Yes. Ortho manufactured the Ortho-Novum pills obtained by MacDonald in September 1973 and used until her July 1976 stroke.31 The patient MacDonald was a healthy young consumer actively involved in choosing the pill rather than other birth control methods.32 Her gynecologist played a passive role limited to annual visits.33 These characteristics along with FDA regulations requiring direct information to users mean Ortho could not reasonably rely on warnings to the physician alone.34
Therefore Ortho owed MacDonald a direct duty to provide written warnings of the nature, gravity, and likelihood of known side effects such as stroke.35
A manufacturer of oral contraceptives owes a direct duty to warn consumers of the dangers inherent in the use of the pill.36
Related opinions on this issue
Justice O'Connor would hold that as a matter of law by adequately informing physicians of the risks and complying with FDA regulations a contraceptive pill manufacturer fulfils the duty to warn that it owes consumers.37 He reasoned that the prescription drug rule should apply uniformly because before a consumer uses a prescription drug there must be interaction with a doctor who exercises professional judgment.38 O'Connor concluded that Ortho fulfilled its duty by adequately informing the physician as found by the jury and by complying with FDA regulations.39
Imposing direct liability based on jury determinations of consumer warnings places an unfair burden on manufacturers and is not essential to consumer protection.40
Whether the evidence was sufficient to support the jury's finding that the manufacturer's warnings to the consumer were inadequate?41
The common law duty to warn necessitates a warning comprehensible to the average user and conveying a fair indication of the nature and extent of the danger to the mind of a reasonably prudent person.42 Compliance with FDA labeling requirements is admissible to demonstrate lack of negligence but is not conclusive because a trier of fact could reasonably conclude that such compliance did not adequately apprise users of inherent risks.43
Yes. The dispenser warning stated that the most serious known side effect is abnormal blood clotting which can be fatal.44 The booklet warned of damage to vital organs such as the brain from abnormal blood clotting.45 Neither used the word stroke.46
The jury could reasonably conclude from MacDonald's testimony and common experience that the absence of any reference to stroke unduly minimized the warning's impact or failed to make the nature of the risk reasonably comprehensible to the average consumer.47 Mention of the risk of death did not suffice to apprise an average consumer of the material risks of permanent disablement.48
The evidence was sufficient to support the jury's finding that the manufacturer's warnings to the consumer were inadequate.49
Whether the evidence was sufficient to support a finding that the inadequacy of the warnings proximately caused the plaintiff's injury?50
To prove causation the plaintiff must show that had the proper information been provided neither she nor a reasonable person in similar circumstances would have accepted the pills as a contraceptive method.51 The jury is free to credit the plaintiff's testimony that she would not have used the pills if advised of the danger of stroke and to infer that an explicit reference to the risk of stroke might tip the balance in a reasonable person's choice of a contraceptive method.52
Yes. MacDonald testified that she was unaware the risk of abnormal blood clotting encompassed the risk of stroke.53 She also testified that she would not have used the pills had she been warned of that risk.54 The jury was free to credit that testimony.55
It could infer that an explicit reference to stroke might have affected MacDonald's decision or the decision of a reasonable person in similar circumstances.56 This established that the inadequacy of the warnings was the proximate cause of her injury.57
The evidence was sufficient to support a finding that the inadequacy of the warnings proximately caused the plaintiff's injury.58