110 Conn. 184, 147 A. 762 (1929)
On July 31, 1926, the automobiles of the plaintiff Mahoney and the defendant Beatman collided on a highway.1 The trial court found that the collision between the automobiles of plaintiff and defendant was the result of defendant’s negligence.2 The plaintiff's car was being driven at an unreasonable speed both before and after the collision, although this speed did not contribute to cause the collision.3
After the collision the car struck a tree and stonewall and rolled over because the driver was unable to control or stop the car owing to the speed at which he was proceeding.4 The damage to the plaintiff’s car was $5,850 at the time of the collision on July 31st, 1926.5 The trial court awarded the plaintiff $200 nominal damages on the theory that the speed materially hampered the driver in controlling the car after the collision.6
The appeal does not question the existence of the negligence but the extent of the responsibility resulting in consequence of the negligence.7 The court reviewed the trial court's findings and the evidence attached to the record.8
Whether the trial court correctly limited the plaintiff's recovery to nominal damages on the ground that the plaintiff's unreasonable speed after the collision prevented avoiding further damage to the vehicle?9
No. The established facts show that the collision was the result of defendant’s negligence and the plaintiff's speed did not contribute to cause the collision.13 After the collision the car struck a tree and stonewall and rolled over because the driver was unable to control or stop the car owing to the speed at which he was proceeding. The damage to the plaintiff’s car was $5,850 at the time of the collision on July 31st, 1926. The trial court awarded the plaintiff $200 nominal damages on the theory that the speed materially hampered the driver in controlling the car after the collision.
There was no new cause intervening after the collision wholly independent of it which itself caused the further injury.14 The impact of the collision remained a substantial factor in producing the subsequent injuries.15
The trial court did not correctly limit the plaintiff's recovery to nominal damages.16
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Maltbie dissented. He argued that the trial court rested its decision on the established principle that negligent conduct by the plaintiff which merely increases the extent of damage without proximately contributing to the accident itself may still reduce recovery.17 He maintained that it is unjust to require the defendant to answer for harm resulting from the plaintiff's own wrongdoing.18 Maltbie drew an analogy to the plaintiff's duty to mitigate damages after injury.19
He concluded that the case should be remanded for further proceedings rather than directing entry of judgment for the full amount of damages.20
Whether the defendant's negligence caused the full extent of the damage to the plaintiff's automobile under the facts found by the trial court?21
Yes. The established facts show that the collision between the automobiles of plaintiff and defendant was the result of defendant’s negligence.24 The plaintiff's car was being driven at an unreasonable speed both before and after the collision although this speed did not contribute to cause the collision.25 The damage after the collision occurred when the car struck a tree and stonewall and rolled over because the driver was unable to control or stop the car owing to the speed.26
No intervening agency diverted the force of the impact or rendered the original negligent act spent.27 The defendant's negligence remained a substantial factor in producing the entire $5,850 in damage.28
The defendant's negligence caused the full extent of the damage to the plaintiff's automobile.29