477 U.S. 299, 106 S.Ct. 2537, 91 L.Ed.2d 249 (1986)
Edward Stachura is a tenured teacher in the Memphis, Michigan, public schools.1 During the 1978-1979 school year he taught seventh-grade life science using a textbook approved by the School Board.2 He devoted six weeks to a chapter on human reproduction.3 Students were shown pictures of his wife during her pregnancy.4 He also showed two films on human growth and sexuality.5 These films were provided by the County Health Department and approved by the school principal.6 Both films had been shown in previous years without incident.7
After these lessons, parents complained to school officials.8 The complaints were based largely on inaccurate rumors about the sexually explicit nature of the materials.9 These complaints were discussed at an open School Board meeting on April 23, 1979.10 Stachura did not attend the meeting on the advice of the School Superintendent.11 At the meeting, parents expressed the view that Stachura should not teach in the system.12
The day after the meeting, Stachura was suspended with pay.13 The School Board later confirmed the suspension.14 It notified him that an administration evaluation of his teaching methods was underway.15 No such evaluation was ever made.16 He was reinstated the following fall after filing suit.17 He sued the School District, the Board of Education, Board members and school administrators, and two parents who participated in the meeting.18 The complaint alleged violations of due process and First Amendment rights.19 He sought compensatory and punitive damages under 42 U.S.C. § 1983.20
At trial, the District Court instructed the jury on damages.21 The instructions included standard compensatory elements like lost earnings and mental anguish.22 They also covered punitive damages.23 Additionally, the instructions authorized damages based on the value or importance of the constitutional rights violated.24 The jury could consider the right's importance in the system of government and its historical role.25
The jury found liability on both due process and First Amendment grounds.26 It awarded $275,000 in compensatory damages and $46,000 in punitive damages.27 The District Court reduced the award to $266,750 in compensatory damages and $36,000 in punitive damages.28
The Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed the judgment in an opinion devoted primarily to liability issues.29 The Supreme Court granted certiorari limited to the question whether the Court of Appeals erred in affirming the damages award in light of the District Court's instructions authorizing damages for the deprivation of any constitutional right.30
Whether 42 U.S.C. § 1983 authorizes an award of compensatory damages based on the factfinder's assessment of the value or importance of a substantive constitutional right?31
Section 1983 creates a species of tort liability in favor of persons who are deprived of rights, privileges, or immunities secured to them by the Constitution.32 When § 1983 plaintiffs seek damages for violations of constitutional rights, the level of damages is ordinarily determined according to principles derived from the common law of torts.33 The basic purpose of § 1983 damages is to compensate persons for injuries that are caused by the deprivation of constitutional rights.34 Damages based on the abstract value or importance of constitutional rights are not a permissible element of compensatory damages in such cases.35
No.36 The District Court instructed the jury that if it found the Plaintiff had been deprived of a Constitutional right, it could award damages to compensate him for the deprivation.37 The instruction allowed placing a monetary value on the right based on its importance in the system of government and its role in the history of the republic.38
After parents complained at the April 23, 1979 School Board meeting about Stachura's teaching methods involving pictures and films on human reproduction, he was suspended with pay.39 He was later reinstated after filing the lawsuit alleging due process and First Amendment violations.40 The jury found petitioners liable and awarded substantial compensatory damages.41
These instructions cannot be squared with the principle that damages must compensate for actual injury caused by the deprivation rather than the abstract value of the rights.42 The facts demonstrate the award was not limited to provable harms such as mental anguish or lost earnings.43
The jury instructions authorizing damages based on the abstract value of constitutional rights were erroneous, requiring reversal of the Court of Appeals judgment and remand for a new trial on compensatory damages.44
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Marshall agrees with the Court that this case must be remanded for a new trial on damages.45 He writes separately to emphasize that the violation of a constitutional right, in proper cases, may itself constitute a compensable injury.46
He explains that the instructions were improper because they did not require the jury to focus on the loss actually sustained by respondent.47 The instructions invited the jury to base its award on speculation about the importance of the right in the system of government rather than on the actual loss sustained.48
Marshall notes that following the principles in Carey, the rules governing compensation should be tailored to the interests protected by the particular right.49 Following Carey, the Courts of Appeals have recognized that invasions of constitutional rights sometimes cause injuries that cannot be redressed by a wooden application of common-law damages rules.50
For example, when a plaintiff is deprived of the opportunity to engage in a demonstration to express his political views, that loss constitutes compensable injury.51 At the same time, however, the award must be proportional to the actual loss sustained.52