451 U.S. 100 (1981)
In 1973, residents of the Hein Park subdivision in Memphis filed an application with the Memphis and Shelby County Planning Commission to close the northern end of West Drive for twenty-five feet south of its intersection with Jackson Avenue.1
West Drive is a two-lane street about a half mile long passing through the center of Hein Park, a small residential community bounded on three sides by thoroughfares and on the west by the campus of Southwestern University.2 The application was signed by the two property owners abutting both Jackson Avenue and West Drive and all but one of the other West Drive homeowners on that block.3 The stated reasons were to reduce through traffic, increase safety for children walking to Snowden Junior High School, and reduce noise, litter, and interruption of community living.4
After review by municipal departments, the Planning Commission recommended approval subject to conditions for utility easements and fire-department clearance.5 The City Council held hearings, adopted a resolution authorizing the closure, reconsidered the matter at later hearings, and never rescinded the resolution.6 The area immediately north of Hein Park is predominantly black, while all homes in Hein Park were owned by whites at the time of the decision.7
Prior to the closure, a significant volume of southbound traffic on Springdale Street continued onto West Drive through Hein Park before turning near Overton Park.8 The closure would divert that traffic, which the District Court found to be overwhelmingly black, around the subdivision at the Jackson Avenue intersection instead.9 The physical barrier would be a curb with a gap allowing municipal vehicles to pass.10 The closure would add only minimal distance and inconvenience to trips by black motorists while providing greater privacy and less traffic for white residents of West Drive.11
On April 1, 1974, three individuals and two civic associations representing a class of black residents north of Jackson Avenue and west of Springdale Street filed suit in the United States District Court for the Western District of Tennessee against the city and various officials.12 The complaint alleged that the closing was unconstitutional and sought an injunction requiring the city to keep West Drive open for through traffic.13 The District Court granted a motion to dismiss.14 The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reversed and remanded.15
After remand, the case was transferred for trial before Judge McRae.16 Respondents amended their pleadings and conducted discovery on all street closings in Memphis over the prior decade and the full record of the West Drive closing.17 They proceeded to trial on three contested factual issues identified in the pretrial order.18 After a full trial, Judge McRae found against respondents on each issue.19 The Court of Appeals did not reject any of the District Court's findings of fact but reversed on the ground that respondents could demonstrate a violation of § 1982 without showing denial of equal treatment to black neighborhoods.20 The Court of Appeals relied instead on the closure's benefit to a white area, its location at the point of neighborhood separation, its character as a unique step rather than part of a citywide plan, and evidence of economic depreciation in black property values.21
Whether the City of Memphis's decision to close the north end of West Drive violated 42 U.S.C. § 1982?22
Section 1982 provides that all citizens of the United States shall have the same right as white citizens to inherit, purchase, lease, sell, hold, and convey real and personal property.23 The statute protects not only the enforceability of property interests acquired by black citizens but also their right to acquire and use property on an equal basis with white citizens.24
No. The District Court found after full trial that the closure conferred no benefit on white citizens denied to black citizens, that no racially discriminatory intent or purpose had been proved, and that the city had not departed significantly from normal procedures.25 The record shows the closure caused only minimal inconvenience to black motorists without depreciating property values in the black area or severely restricting access to black homes.26 Because the action did not impair the kind of property interests protected by the statute, it did not violate § 1982.27
The City of Memphis's decision to close the north end of West Drive did not violate 42 U.S.C. § 1982.28
Related opinions on this issue
Justice White concurred in the judgment.29 He concluded that a violation of § 1982 requires proof of discriminatory intent or racial animus.30 The legislative history of the Civil Rights Act of 1866 demonstrates that Congress targeted direct, intentional abuses against former slaves rather than facially neutral measures with only incidental impact.31
Because the District Court found no discriminatory purpose and the Court of Appeals did not disturb that finding, reversal of the judgment below was required.32
Joined by Justices Brennan And Blackmun
Justice Marshall dissented.33 He concluded that the record demonstrated substantial harm to black property rights from the street closing.34 The barrier sent a clear message that black residents were to stay out of the white enclave.35
Residents testified that the closure would inflict psychological damage by extending prior insults and humiliations.36 Expert testimony from a real estate agent established that the action would create a demoralizing effect on black property owners north of Hein Park, leading to reduced upkeep and eventual depreciation in property values.37 Dr. Feit testified that the barrier would increase hostility, vandalism, and police harassment.38
These impairments to enjoyment and value of property violated the broad remedial purpose of § 1982 to prevent any racial impairment of property interests, not merely formal denials of equal treatment.39
Whether the street closing violated the Thirteenth Amendment?40
The Thirteenth Amendment declares that neither slavery nor involuntary servitude shall exist within the United States.41 Although the Amendment is self-executing and prohibits badges and incidents of slavery, Congress possesses authority under Section 2 to enact legislation eradicating those conditions.42
No. The record discloses no racially discriminatory motive on the part of the City Council.43 The closure was motivated by legitimate interests in traffic safety for children and residential tranquility.44 The resulting inconvenience to black motorists is a routine burden of citizenship.45 It cannot fairly be characterized as a badge or incident of slavery, especially where the physical barrier is minimal and access to homes remains available by other routes.46
The street closing did not violate the Thirteenth Amendment.47
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justices Brennan And Blackmun
Justice Marshall dissented. He concluded that the closing erected a barrier at the precise point of racial separation between an all-white enclave and a predominantly black area.48 The action inflicted a badge of slavery by stigmatizing black citizens and impairing their property enjoyment.49
Residents perceived the barrier as a humiliating directive to stay out of the white neighborhood.50 Expert testimony confirmed that the closure would reinforce feelings of racial favoritism and serve as a monument to hostility.51 The resulting psychological injury, combined with risks of increased harassment and depressed property values, carried forward the historical pattern of racial exclusion that the Thirteenth Amendment was intended to eliminate.52
The city's stated safety rationale could not justify carving out a racial enclave under the Amendment.53