348 N.E.2d 571 (N.Y. 1976)
Paul Micallef worked as a printing-press operator for Lincoln Graphic Arts at its Farmingdale plant. For eight months he operated a photo-offset press, model RU 1, that had been manufactured and sold by Miehle-Goss Dexter, Inc. The machine was 150 feet long, 15 feet high and 5 feet wide and could print at least 20,000 sheets an hour.1
On January 22, 1969, Micallef found a foreign object known as a hickie on the printing plate. After notifying his foreman, he attempted to remove it by lightly applying an eight-inch-wide piece of plastic to the spinning plate cylinder. The plastic and his hand were pulled into the nip point between the plate cylinder and an ink-form roller. The press had no safety guards at that location.2
Micallef knew the risk of being caught while chasing hickies on a running machine.3 Industry custom called for performing the task without stopping the press because restarting required at least three hours.4 Defendant's representatives had watched the machine operate and knew the method Lincoln employees used to chase hickies.5 It was also possible to chase the hickie from another side of the machine, though that position increased the chance of scratching the plate.6
After the accident, engineer Samuel Aidlin examined the press. He concluded that guards could have been installed near the rollers, that suitable guards had existed for more than thirty years, and that they would not have interfered with chasing hickies.7 Both a negligence claim and a breach of warranty claim were presented to the jury.8
The jury found the defendant negligent but also found Micallef contributorily negligent. It returned a verdict for Micallef on the warranty claim. Following post-trial motions in May and September 1973, the trial court set aside the entire verdict and ordered a new trial. The Appellate Division reversed that order, reinstated the negligence verdict for the defendant, and directed judgment for the defendant on the warranty claim.9 The Court of Appeals then took the case.10
Whether the patent-danger doctrine of Campo v. Scofield remains valid?11
A manufacturer is obligated to exercise that degree of care in his plan or design so as to avoid any unreasonable risk of harm to anyone who is likely to be exposed to the danger when the product is used in the manner for which the product was intended. This duty extends to an unintended yet reasonably foreseeable use.12 The openness and obviousness of the danger should be available to the defendant on the issue of whether plaintiff exercised that degree of reasonable care as was required under the circumstances.13
No. The court rejected the rigid patent-danger doctrine of Campo. It produces harsh results and is inconsistent with modern products liability principles that place responsibility on the manufacturer who stands in a superior position to recognize and cure defects.14 In this case the printing press lacked guards at the nip point even though suitable guards had existed for over thirty years. Those guards would not have impeded chasing hickies. The defendant knew the industry practice of chasing hickies on the run.15
Therefore the question whether reasonable care was exercised in the design was for the jury.16
The patent-danger doctrine of Campo v. Scofield does not remain valid.17
Whether errors in the trial court's jury instructions on assumption of risk and contributory negligence required a new trial on all issues?18
Erroneous jury instructions on assumption of risk, which is an affirmative defense that must be pleaded, and on contributory negligence using a mere factor standard rather than substantial factor, require reversal and a new trial on all issues in the interest of justice.19
Yes. The trial court erroneously charged that the plaintiff knew of the risk and assumed it without further explanation. It used an incorrect substantial-factor standard for contributory negligence. It also gave a now-doubtful instruction that contributory negligence was not a defense to warranty.20 Therefore the Appellate Division order must be reversed and a new trial granted on all issues.21
The errors in the trial court's jury instructions required a new trial on all issues.22
Whether a breach of implied warranty claim arising from a product injury should be treated under strict products liability principles?23
A claim based on breach of implied warranty arising from a product injury is more correctly treated under the theory of strict products liability as set forth in Codling v. Paglia.24
Yes. Since the time of trial the court has recognized strict products liability as a separate cause of action independent from negligence and warranty. The majority applies the Codling standards to the warranty claim without reconsidering that decision.25 The breach of implied warranty claim is treated under strict products liability principles because it is based on tortious behavior in product injury cases.26
The breach of implied warranty claim should be treated under strict products liability principles.27