302 F.3d 1291 (Fed. Cir. 2002)
Monsanto Company developed genetically modified soybean plants that are resistant to glyphosate herbicides such as Roundup brand herbicide.1 Monsanto obtained United States Patents Nos. 5,633,435 and 5,352,605 claiming the glyphosate-tolerant plants, the genetically modified seeds for such plants, the specific modified genes, and the method of producing the genetically modified plants.2
Monsanto authorized various companies to manufacture the patented seeds, which were then sold to farmers.3 Farmers paid a license fee of $6.50 per 50-pound bag of soybean seed to Monsanto.4 The agreements required that the seeds be used for planting a commercial crop only in a single season and prohibited saving any crop produced from the seed for replanting or supplying saved seeds to anyone.5
Homan McFarling, a farmer in Mississippi, purchased Roundup Ready soybean seed in 1997 and 1998.6 He signed the Technology Agreement and paid the license fee for each purchase.7 McFarling saved 1,500 bushels of the patented soybeans from his harvest during one season and planted them as seed in the next season without paying any license fee.8 He repeated this activity in the following growing season and stated that unless enjoined he intended to plant soybeans saved from the 2000 harvest in 2001.9
Monsanto filed suit in the Eastern District of Missouri charging patent infringement and breach of contract and seeking a preliminary injunction.10 McFarling challenged the court's jurisdiction and raised counterclaims including antitrust violation, patent misuse, and violation of the Plant Variety Protection Act.11 The district court stayed the proceeding pending Supreme Court review in J.E.M. AG Supply, then denied the motion to dismiss and granted the preliminary injunction.12
McFarling appealed to the Federal Circuit.13
Whether the forum selection clause in the Technology Agreement conferred personal jurisdiction over McFarling in the Eastern District of Missouri?14
Forum selection clauses are valid and enforceable unless the party challenging it clearly demonstrates that it is invalid or that enforcement would be unreasonable and unjust.15
Yes. McFarling signed the Technology Agreement containing the clause printed in all capital letters on the reverse side and acknowledged that he had read and understood the terms and conditions.16 Under Missouri and Mississippi contract law a signer is bound by the terms absent fraudulent inducement not to read the document.17 McFarling's voluntary failure to read the clause does not exempt him from its effect.18
He failed to show that selection of Missouri as the forum was unreasonable given Monsanto's interest in a common venue for Technology Agreement disputes.19
The forum selection clause conferred personal jurisdiction over McFarling in the Eastern District of Missouri.20
Related opinions on this issue
Clevenger dissented on the ground that the Technology Agreement constituted a contract of adhesion marked by unequal bargaining power, one-sided terms, and practical necessity for farmers to accept the form contract.21 He argued that McFarling's signature did not constitute a voluntary intelligent and knowing waiver of due process rights.22 This was because the forum selection clause appeared on the reverse without notice on the face and McFarling testified he was unaware of it.23
Clevenger concluded that enforcement of such a clause in an adhesion contract against a defendant exceeds the bounds approved in Carnival Cruise Lines and violates the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment.24
Whether the district court abused its discretion in granting Monsanto a preliminary injunction based on the likelihood of success on the merits of its patent infringement and contract claims?25
A preliminary injunction requires a showing of reasonable likelihood of success on the merits, irreparable harm, balance of hardships favoring the movant, and service to the public interest with the factors balanced in the interest of justice.26
No. McFarling conceded that he saved approximately 1,500 bushels of patented soybeans and replanted them without paying the license fee in violation of the Technology Agreement terms limiting use to a single season.27 The patents cover the seeds, plants, genes, and production method and the new seeds grown from purchased seed had never been sold so the first sale doctrine did not apply.28 McFarling presented no evidence raising a substantial question on the infringement or contract claims.29
The district court did not abuse its discretion in granting the preliminary injunction.30
Whether McFarling's antitrust, patent misuse, first sale, and Plant Variety Protection Act arguments raised a substantial question defeating the preliminary injunction?31
To defeat a preliminary injunction on the likelihood of success factor the accused infringer must raise a substantial question that the patents are unenforceable due to antitrust violation, patent misuse, or other defenses or that the contractual restrictions fall outside the scope of the patent grant.32
No. The Technology Agreements did not require purchase of future seed as a condition of buying present seed.33 Over two hundred commercial sources of soybean seed existed including competing herbicide-resistant varieties so no tying arrangement or illegal restraint was shown. The first sale doctrine did not apply because the new seeds had never been sold by the patentee.34 The Supreme Court in J.E.M. AG Supply established that the PVPA seed-saving exemption does not apply to utility patents under the Patent Act.35
McFarling's antitrust, patent misuse, first sale, and Plant Variety Protection Act arguments did not raise a substantial question defeating the preliminary injunction.36