498 F.2d 821 (9th Cir. 1974)
Lothar Motschenbacher is a professional driver of racing cars who is internationally known and recognized in racing circles and by racing fans.1 He derives part of his income from manufacturers of commercial products who pay him for endorsing their products.2
Since 1966, each of his cars has displayed a distinctive narrow white pinstripe appearing on no other car.3 This decoration has adorned the leading edges of the cars' bodies, which have uniformly been solid red.4 In addition, the white background for his racing number "11" has always been oval, in contrast to the circular backgrounds of all other cars.5
In 1970, defendants R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Company and William Esty Company produced and caused to be televised a commercial which utilized a stock color photograph depicting several racing cars on a racetrack.6 Plaintiff's car appears in the foreground, and although plaintiff is the driver, his facial features are not visible.7
In producing the commercial, defendants altered the photograph by changing the numbers on all racing cars depicted, transforming plaintiff's number "11" into "71".8 They attached a wing-like device known as a spoiler to plaintiff's car, added the word "Winston" to that spoiler, and removed advertisements for other products from the spoilers of other cars.9 However, they made no other changes, and the white pinstriping, the oval medallion, and the red color of plaintiff's car were retained.10
Defendants then made a motion picture from the altered photograph, adding a series of comic strip-type balloons containing written messages of an advertising nature.11 One such balloon message, appearing to emanate from plaintiff, was: "Did you know that Winston tastes good, like a cigarette should?"12 They also added a sound track consisting in part of voices coordinated with, and echoing, the written messages.13 The commercial was subsequently broadcast nationally on network television and in color.14
Several of plaintiff's affiants who had seen the commercial on television had immediately recognized plaintiff's car and had inferred that it was sponsored by Winston cigarettes.15 The district court, characterizing plaintiff's action as one for damages for invasion of privacy, granted summary judgment for defendants.16 Motschenbacher appealed from the district court's order granting summary judgment in favor of defendants.17
Whether California local law governs the claim in this diversity action?18
In a diversity case, a federal court must follow the substantive law of the state in which it sits.19 This includes the conflict of laws rules of that state.20 Under the approach of Reich v. Purcell, California courts would apply California local law when the plaintiff is a California resident because that state has the greatest interest in compensating its residents for the alleged injury.21
Yes. The district court sat in California and jurisdiction rested on diversity of citizenship under 28 U.S.C. § 1332.22 The commercial was broadcast throughout the United States.23 Yet California, as the state of plaintiff's residency, possesses the predominant interest in providing compensation for injuries to its residents arising from commercial appropriation of identity.24 California also has an interest in convenience as the forum, and its Uniform Single Publication Act advances the interest in avoiding multiplicity of suits.25
California local law governs the claim in this diversity action.26
Whether California courts would recognize a protectable proprietary interest in an individual's identity?27
California courts would recognize and protect an individual's proprietary interest in his own identity.28 This protection may be afforded whether under the rubric of privacy, property, or publicity.29 The appropriation decisions recognize an exclusive right in the plaintiff to a species of trade name and a kind of trademark in his likeness.30 It is proprietary in nature and upon which the plaintiff can capitalize by selling licenses.31
Yes. Although prior California appropriation cases have focused on injury to personal feelings, the court determines from review of relevant authorities that California appellate courts would afford legal protection to the commercial value of an individual's identity.32 Plaintiff's identity has commercial value because he is paid for endorsements.33 The defendants used distinctive features of his car to create an inference of sponsorship in a national advertising campaign for Winston cigarettes.34
California courts would recognize a protectable proprietary interest in an individual's identity.35
Whether the plaintiff is identifiable in the defendants' commercial as a matter of law?36
If the plaintiff is not identifiable in the commercial, then in no sense has plaintiff's identity been misappropriated.37 However, the distinctive decorations on the car that are peculiar to plaintiff's vehicles caused some persons to recognize the car and infer that plaintiff was the driver.38 This precludes a determination of non-identifiability as a matter of law.39
No. Although the likeness of plaintiff himself is unrecognizable, the white pinstriping, the oval medallion, and the red color of the car were retained after alteration of the number and addition of the Winston spoiler.40 Several of plaintiff's affiants who viewed the broadcast immediately recognized the car as plaintiff's and inferred Winston sponsorship.41 This creates a genuine issue of material fact on identifiability that precludes summary judgment.42
The plaintiff is not non-identifiable in the defendants' commercial as a matter of law.43