585 U.S., 138 S. Ct. 2361, 201 L. Ed. 2d 835 (2018)
In 2015 the California Legislature enacted the Reproductive Freedom, Accountability, Comprehensive Care, and Transparency Act, known as the FACT Act.1 The statute applies to licensed covered facilities.2 These are state-licensed primary care or specialty clinics whose primary purpose is providing family planning or pregnancy-related services.3 They must also satisfy at least two of six listed criteria such as offering obstetric ultrasounds, pregnancy testing, or advertising pregnancy options counseling.4
These facilities must post in their waiting rooms a government-drafted notice.5 They must also print the notice in client materials.6 In some counties the notice must be translated into as many as thirteen languages.7 The notice states that California provides immediate free or low-cost access to comprehensive family planning services.8 This includes all FDA-approved methods of contraception, prenatal care, and abortion for eligible women, together with the county social services telephone number.9 The Act exempts clinics operated by the United States or a federal agency.10 It also exempts clinics enrolled as Medi-Cal providers that participate in the Family PACT program.11
The FACT Act also regulates unlicensed covered facilities.12 These are facilities not licensed by the State.13 They lack a licensed medical provider on staff or under contract.14 They have a primary purpose of providing pregnancy-related services while meeting at least two of four listed criteria.15 These facilities must display at their entrance an eight-and-a-half by eleven inch sign.16 The sign must be in at least forty-eight-point type.17 It must state that the facility is not licensed as a medical facility by the State of California and has no licensed medical provider who provides or directly supervises services.18 The same statement must appear in all print and digital advertising.19 It must also be recited in any recorded telephone message, again in English and any additional languages required by state law.20
The National Institute of Family and Life Advocates, a pro-life organization composed of crisis pregnancy centers, together with one licensed and one unlicensed crisis pregnancy center, filed suit in the United States District Court for the Southern District of California against Attorney General Xavier Becerra and other state officials.21 The petitioners provide pregnancy-related services but do not offer or refer for abortions.22 They alleged that both notice requirements abridge the freedom of speech protected by the First Amendment and moved for a preliminary injunction.23 The district court denied the motion.24 The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed, holding that petitioners had not shown a likelihood of success on the merits.25 The Supreme Court granted certiorari.26
Whether the FACT Act's licensed notice requirement violates the First Amendment?27
Content-based regulations of speech are presumptively unconstitutional and subject to strict scrutiny. The government may regulate professional conduct that incidentally burdens speech or require disclosure of purely factual and uncontroversial information in commercial speech under Zauderer, but these exceptions do not apply to the licensed notice.28
Yes. The licensed notice is a content-based regulation because it compels facilities to speak a government-drafted message about the availability of state-sponsored abortion services.29 The National Institute of Family and Life Advocates and the licensed crisis pregnancy center provide pregnancy-related services but do not offer or refer for abortions yet must post the notice in waiting rooms and print materials.30 The notice does not fall under Zauderer because the information is not purely factual and uncontroversial about the terms of services the facilities provide.31
It is not a regulation of professional conduct because it applies to all interactions regardless of whether a medical procedure is sought or performed and exempts many other clinics serving the same population.32 The notice cannot survive strict scrutiny or even intermediate scrutiny because it is underinclusive and the state could use a public advertising campaign instead.33
The licensed notice requirement likely violates the First Amendment.34
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Chief Justice Roberts And Justices Alito And Gorsuch
Justice Kennedy joined the majority but wrote separately to emphasize that the licensed notice requirement is a content-based regulation that compels speech.35 He stressed that the State cannot compel individuals to speak messages with which they disagree.36 The licensed notice requires facilities to inform women that the State provides free or low-cost abortions.37
This is a message many licensed facilities find morally objectionable.38 Kennedy noted that the informed-consent provision in Casey was part of a regulation of the practice of medicine tied to a medical procedure.39 In contrast, the licensed notice here is a regulation of speech outside that context.40
He concluded that the requirement imperils the liberties secured by the First Amendment.41
Joined by Justices Ginsburg, Sotomayor, And Kagan
Justice Breyer dissented and argued that the licensed notice is a regulation of professional conduct that only incidentally burdens speech.42 He maintained that the notice requires licensed facilities to provide purely factual and uncontroversial information about state-sponsored services.43 The notice is reasonably related to the State's interest in ensuring women have access to accurate information about reproductive health options.44
Breyer compared the notice to other disclosure requirements upheld under Zauderer.45 He contended that applying strict scrutiny to such notices is inconsistent with precedents governing the regulation of medical services.46 He concluded that both notice requirements are likely constitutional.47
Whether the FACT Act's unlicensed notice requirement violates the First Amendment?48
A disclosure requirement cannot be unjustified or unduly burdensome even under Zauderer.49 Disclosures must remedy a potentially real harm and extend no broader than reasonably necessary; speaker-based requirements that target particular facilities and impose government-scripted messages disconnected from the state's informational interest fail this standard.50
Yes. The unlicensed notice is a content-based regulation that requires facilities to post a government-scripted statement that they are not licensed and have no licensed medical provider on staff.51 The National Institute of Family and Life Advocates and the unlicensed crisis pregnancy center must display the notice at the entrance and in advertising materials in large type and multiple languages.52 California presented no nonhypothetical justification showing that women do not already know the facilities are unlicensed.53
The requirement is unduly burdensome because it applies to all print and digital advertising and drowns out the facilities' own messages.54 The notice targets a narrow subset of speakers providing pregnancy-related services while exempting others that could create similar confusion.55
The unlicensed notice requirement is unconstitutional.56
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Chief Justice Roberts And Justices Alito And Gorsuch
Justice Kennedy joined the majority and added that the unlicensed notice is also unconstitutional.57 He observed that the notice requires unlicensed facilities to state that they are not licensed by the State.58 This message is misleading because many unlicensed facilities provide high-quality services.59
Kennedy concluded that the notice is not purely factual and uncontroversial.60 The requirement compounds the constitutional problems already present with the licensed notice.61 He stressed that governments must not force persons to express a message contrary to their deepest convictions, as this imperils the liberties secured by the First Amendment.62
Joined by Justices Ginsburg, Sotomayor, And Kagan
Justice Breyer dissented and maintained that the unlicensed notice is constitutional.63 He argued that the notice requires unlicensed facilities to disclose that they are not licensed by the State.64 This is factual and uncontroversial information that prevents deception of women who may believe they are receiving services from a licensed medical provider.65
Breyer stated that the disclosure remedies a real harm and satisfies Zauderer because it is reasonably related to the State's interest in ensuring pregnant women know when they are receiving care from licensed professionals.66