13 F.R.D. 311 (S.D.N.Y. 1952)
The defendants are authors of a book entitled “U.S.A. Confidential”.1 The book contains passages on pages 39-40, 196, and 208 that referred to Neiman models as call girls priced at a hundred dollars a night.2 It described salesgirls as pretty and often much cheaper at twenty dollars on average.3 The book stated that most of the sales staff are fairies.4 It also made related statements about imported faggots in the Neiman-Marcus set.5
On April 14, 1952, the Neiman-Marcus Company, a Texas corporation operating a department store in Dallas, and three groups of its employees filed an original complaint in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York alleging that the book libeled and defamed them.6 The complaint was dismissed on August 19, 1952, with leave to amend.7 The dismissal occurred because the individual plaintiffs had not specified that they were members of the libelled groups at the time the cause of action arose.8 They also had not disclosed the numerical size of those groups.9
The plaintiffs filed an amended complaint.10 It stated that nine individual models constituted the entire group of models at the time of publication.11 Fifteen salesmen of a total of twenty-five were suing on their own behalf and on behalf of the others pursuant to Rule 23(a)(3).12 Thirty saleswomen of a total of 382 were suing on their own behalf and on behalf of the others pursuant to the same rule.13 The amended complaint further alleged that the book was published simultaneously in every state.14
The defendants moved to dismiss the amended complaint as to the salesmen and saleswomen for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted.15 They also sought to dismiss the action in its entirety for failure to comply with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.16 In the alternative, they asked to require the plaintiffs to serve an amended complaint in which the claim of each plaintiff would be separately stated.17
The individual plaintiffs' community and place of livelihood is in Texas.18
Whether the amended complaint states a claim upon which relief can be granted as to the salesmen plaintiffs?19
Where a defamatory publication refers to some or most members of a small group, each individual member of that group may maintain an action for libel because the imputation casts suspicion on all.20
Yes. The salesmen plaintiffs constitute a group of twenty-five total employees at the time of publication, with fifteen suing on their own behalf and on behalf of the others.21 The book states that most of the sales staff are fairies, referring to some of this small group without excluding any particular members.22 This satisfies the elements for individual recovery under the principles applied from New York law, Texas law, and the Restatement of Torts section 564 comment c illustration 2, which authorizes suit by each member when the statement concerns a portion of a small household or group.23
The publication occurred simultaneously in every state.24 The plaintiffs' community and place of livelihood is in Texas, supporting potential recovery in at least one jurisdiction where such group libel claims are recognized.25
The amended complaint states a claim upon which relief can be granted as to the salesmen plaintiffs.26
Whether the amended complaint states a claim upon which relief can be granted as to the saleswomen plaintiffs?27
Where the group or class libelled is large, absent circumstances pointing to a particular plaintiff as the person defamed, no individual member of the group or class has a cause of action for libel.28
No. The saleswomen plaintiffs number three hundred eighty-two at the time of publication, with thirty suing on their own behalf and on behalf of the others.29 The book refers to the salesgirls generally as pretty and often much cheaper without naming any specific individual or using language that isolates any ascertainable person within this large class.30 No circumstances are alleged that would point to any particular saleswoman.31 The size of the group prevents the defamation of the class from infecting each individual member as a matter of law.32
The general allegation that the matter was written of and concerning each of them is insufficient to satisfy the requirement that the words referred solely or especially to the plaintiff.33
The amended complaint does not state a claim upon which relief can be granted as to the saleswomen plaintiffs.34
Whether the salesmen plaintiffs may sue on behalf of others similarly situated under Rule 23(a)(3) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure?35
A spurious class suit under Rule 23(a)(3) is appropriate where there are common questions of law and fact affecting the several rights of the members of the class and common relief is sought against the defendants.36 It serves as a permissive joinder device in which the right and liability of each individual plaintiff is distinct.37
Yes. The fifteen salesmen plaintiffs sue on their own behalf and on behalf of the other ten similarly situated salesmen pursuant to Rule 23(a)(3).38 The amended complaint presents common questions of law and fact regarding the defamatory effect of the statements about most of the sales staff being fairies.39 Common relief is sought against the defendants for the same publication.40
This structure aligns with the description of a spurious class suit as merely a permissive joinder device.41 The use of the rule is appropriate here because the rights of the class members are affected by the same publication and legal standards.42
The salesmen plaintiffs may sue on behalf of others similarly situated under Rule 23(a)(3) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.43
Whether the claims of each member of each class must be separately stated?44
No. The amended complaint presents the claims of the models, salesmen, and saleswomen without requiring each individual member to file a separate statement of claim.47 The repetition of basic allegations regarding the publication of the book and its distribution in every state is properly avoided under the spirit of Rule 8(a).48 The defendants' contention that the claims of each member of each class should be separately stated lacks merit because it does not conform to the requirements of a short and plain statement.49
The claims of each member of each class need not be separately stated.50
Whether the claims of the models, salesmen, and saleswomen are properly joined in one cause of action?51
No. Different allegedly libellous statements were made as to each of the groups in the book.54 Only the Neiman-Marcus Company is properly positioned to complain as to all of the statements.55 The models, salesmen, and saleswomen each face distinct passages referring to their respective groups.56 To allow the joinder of the claims of the two remaining groups of individuals in one cause of action would unduly prejudice the defendants at the trial of this action and in preparation for it.57
This requires the amended complaint to be dismissed with leave to file separate complaints as to the two groups of individuals and the corporation.58
The claims of the models, salesmen, and saleswomen are not properly joined in one cause of action.59