146 La. 735, 84 So. 37 (1920)
Miss Carrie E. Nickerson brought this suit against H. R. Hayes, William or “Bud” Baker, John W. Smith, Mrs. Fannie Smith, Bliss Minnie Smith, A. J. Hodges, G. G. Gatling, R. M. Coyle, Sam P. D. Coyle, and Dr. Charles Coyle, claiming $15,000 as damages.1 The damages were alleged to have been caused in the form of financial outlay, loss in business, mental and physical suffering, humiliation, and injury to reputation and social standing, all growing out of an alleged malicious deception and conspiracy with respect to the finding of a supposed pot of gold.2
Subsequent to the filing of the petition, and before the trial, the said Miss Nickerson died.3 Her legal heirs, some 10 in number, were made parties plaintiff, and now prosecute this suit.4 All of the defendants, save and except Miss Minnie Smith, William or “Bud” Baker, and H. R. Hayes, filed, in effect, a general denial.5 They denied any knowledge of or connection with the matters out of which the alleged damages arose.
These three defendants filed a joint answer.6 After denying the injuries charged, or that there was any malicious or unlawful intent, they admitted that they had fixed up an old copper bucket or pot, filled with dirt and rocks, and had buried it at a point where the said Miss Carrie Nickerson and her helpers would likely dig in search of an imaginary pot of gold. She and her said associates had been, for several months, digging over the property of defendant John W. Smith on information obtained from a negro fortune teller in the city of Shreveport, and boarding at the home of the said Smith, father of the said Minnie Smith, without paying therefor, and generally acting in such a manner as to make themselves nuisances to the community.
For some reason the case was allowed to remain on the docket of the lower court for more than three years before being tried.7 It was finally submitted to a jury, and resulted in a verdict in favor of the defendants.8 After an unsuccessful motion for a new trial, the plaintiffs prosecuted this appeal.
Miss Nickerson was a kinswoman of Burton and Lawson Deck, the exact degree of relationship not being fully shown by the record.9 There had been, in the family, a tradition that these two gentlemen, who died many years ago, had prior to their deaths, buried a large amount of gold coin on the place now owned by the defendant John W. Smith, or on another near by.10 She was employed by the California Perfume Company to solicit orders for their wares in the towns, villages, etc., in Webster and other parishes.11 On the occasion of a visit to the city of Shreveport she seems to have interviewed a negro fortune teller, who told her that her said relatives had buried the gold, and gave her what purported to be a map or plat showing its location on the property of Smith.
Thereafter, with the help of some three or four other persons, principally relatives, and one Bushong, she spent several months digging, at intervals, around the house and on the premises of Smith.12 Smith seems to have extended them a cordial welcome, and to have permitted them to dig almost without limit as to time and place. In addition he boarded the fortune hunters, while so engaged, without charge. Accordingly the three defendants obtained an old copper kettle or bucket, filled it with rocks and wet dirt, and buried it in an old chimney seat on the adjoining place, where the searchers had been or were intending to also prospect for the supposed treasure.13
Two lids or tops were placed on the pot, the first being fastened down with hay wire.14 Then a note was written by Hayes, dated, according to some, July 1, 1884, and, as to others, 1784, directing whoever should find the pot not to open it for three days, and to notify all the heirs. This note was wrapped in tin, placed between the first and second lids, and the latter was also securely fastened down with hay wire.15 This took place some time toward the latter part of March. According to these three defendants, it was to have been an April fool, but plans miscarried somewhat, and the proper opportunity for the “find” did not present itself until April 14th. On that day Miss Nickerson and her associates were searching and digging near the point where the pot had been buried.16 One Grady Hayes, a brother of H. R. Hayes, following directions from the latter, and apparently helping the explorers to hunt for the gold, dug up the pot and gave the alarm.
After depositing the pot in the bank, Miss Nickerson went to Minden, La., and induced Judge R. C. Drew to agree to accompany her to Cotton Valley on the following Monday for the purpose of seeing that the ceremonies surrounding the opening of the treasure were properly conducted.17 The deposit at the bank had been made on Saturday. With the stage thus set, the parties all appeared at the bank on Monday morning at about 11 o’clock.18 Among the number were H. R. Hayes, one of the defendants, who seems to have been one of the guiding spirits in the scheme, and one Bushong. Judge Drew, as the spokesman for the party, approached Gatling and informed him that it was desired that the pot be produced for the purpose of opening and examining the contents for the benefit of those thus assembled.
Miss Nickerson was a maiden, nearing the age of 45 years, and some 20 years before had been an inmate of an insane asylum, to the knowledge of those who had thus deceived her.19 She was energetic and self-supporting in her chosen line of employment as a soap drummer until she met the colored fortune teller who gave her the information which she evidently firmly believed would ultimately enable her to find the fortune which the family tradition told her had been left hidden by her deceased relatives.20 The conspirators, no doubt, merely intended what they did as a practical joke, and had no willful intention of doing the lady any injury.21 However, the results were quite serious indeed, and the mental suffering and humiliation must have been quite unbearable, to say nothing of the disappointment and conviction which she carried to her grave some two years later that she had been robbed.22
Whether the three defendants who admitted burying the pot are liable for damages arising from the deception practiced on Miss Nickerson?23
Under R. C. C. art. 2315 the court may award damages to compensate for the wrong done by fault.24
Yes. The three defendants Hayes, Baker, and Smith admitted constructing an old copper pot filled with rocks and wet dirt, fastening two lids with hay wire, inserting a dated note directing that the pot remain unopened for three days and that all heirs be notified, and burying the pot in an old chimney seat where Miss Nickerson and her associates were searching.25 Miss Nickerson, a maiden nearing forty-five who had spent months excavating on the Smith property after consulting a fortune teller, was known by these defendants to have been an inmate of an insane asylum twenty years earlier.26 On April 14 the pot was produced with the assistance of Grady Hayes.27
Miss Nickerson took it to the bank and returned the following Monday with Judge Drew and other relatives to open it.28 When the contents proved to be only dirt and stones she flew into a rage, accused the participants of robbery, and carried to her grave two years later the conviction that she had been robbed.29 Although the defendants intended no willful injury, the mental suffering and humiliation they caused were unbearable and directly traceable to their admitted scheme.30
The three defendants are liable under article 2315 for the damages their deception inflicted.31
Whether the remaining defendants participated in or are connected to the events giving rise to the claimed injuries?32
Liability under article 2315 requires proof that each defendant committed or joined the act causing damage.33
No. Although the record shows that only Hayes, Baker, and Smith filed an answer admitting they prepared and buried the pot while all other defendants filed general denials asserting no knowledge of or connection to the scheme, no testimony or document placed A. J. Hodges, G. G.
Gatling, the Coyle defendants, John W. Smith, or Mrs. Fannie Smith inside the conspiracy.3435 Their mere presence at the bank or ownership of the land where digging occurred does not constitute participation in the planting of the false pot.36
The demands against all defendants except Hayes, Baker, and Smith are rejected for lack of connection to the deception.37
Whether the legal heirs who were substituted after Miss Nickerson's death may recover on the cause of action?38
Article 2315 creates a cause of action that survives the injured party's death so that heirs may prosecute the claim and recover such damages as the court deems reasonable.39
Yes. Miss Nickerson died after filing suit but before trial, and her ten legal heirs were properly substituted as parties plaintiff.40 The court determined that a living plaintiff would have received substantial damages yet concluded that five hundred dollars reasonably compensates the heirs for the wrong done to their decedent.41
The heirs may recover five hundred dollars from the three liable defendants.42