403 U.S. 713, 91 S. Ct. 2140, 29 L. Ed. 2d 822 (1971)
Petitioner Organization for a Better Austin (OBA) is a racially integrated community organization in the Austin neighborhood of Chicago.1 Respondent is a real estate broker whose office and business activities are in the Austin neighborhood. He resides in Westchester, Illinois, a suburb of Chicago some seven miles from the Austin area.2
OBA is an organization whose stated purpose is to "stabilize" the racial ratio in the Austin area. OBA has opposed and protested real estate tactics and activities generally known as "block-busting" or "panic peddling."3 It was the contention of OBA that respondent had been one of those who engaged in such tactics, specifically that he aroused the fears of the local white residents that Negroes were coming into the area and then, exploiting the reactions and emotions so aroused, was able to secure listings and sell homes to Negroes.4
OBA alleged that since 1961 respondent had from time to time actively promoted sales in this manner by means of flyers, phone calls, and personal visits to residents of the area in which his office is located, without regard to whether the persons solicited had expressed any desire to sell their homes.5 Thereafter, during September and October of 1967, members of petitioner organization distributed leaflets in Westchester describing respondent's activities.6
The challenged publications were critical of respondent's real estate practices in the Austin neighborhood. One of the leaflets set out the business card respondent used to solicit listings, quoted him as saying "I only sell to Negroes," cited a Chicago Daily News article describing his real estate activities and accused him of being a "panic peddler." Another leaflet stated that: "When he signs the agreement, we stop coming to Westchester." Leaflets were given to persons in a Westchester shopping center, passed out to some parishioners on their way to or from respondent's church in Westchester, and left at the doors of his neighbors.7
The trial court found that petitioners' "distribution of leaflets was on all occasions conducted in a peaceful and orderly manner, did not cause any disruption of pedestrian or vehicular traffic, and did not precipitate any fights, disturbances or other breaches of the peace."8 Respondent sought an injunction in the Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois, on December 20, 1967.9 After an adversary hearing the trial court entered a temporary injunction enjoining petitioners "from passing out pamphlets, leaflets or literature of any kind, and from picketing, anywhere in the City of Westchester, Illinois." On appeal to the Appellate Court of Illinois, First District, that court affirmed.10
Whether an order of the Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois, enjoining petitioners from distributing leaflets anywhere in the town of Westchester, Illinois, violates petitioners' rights under the Federal Constitution?11
Any system of prior restraint on expression comes to the Court with a heavy presumption against its constitutional validity.12 The First Amendment protects peaceful pamphleteering as a form of communication, and an injunction against distributing literature critical of business practices cannot be justified by an individual's interest in being free from public criticism.13
Yes. The injunction operates as a prior restraint on speech based on previous publications rather than redressing private wrongs through subsequent punishment.14 Petitioners were engaged openly and vigorously in making the public aware of respondent's real estate practices through peaceful means.15 The claim that the expressions were intended to exercise a coercive impact does not remove them from First Amendment protection.16
Designating the conduct as an invasion of privacy is not sufficient to support an injunction against peaceful distribution of informational literature.17 The Appellate Court erred in viewing the activities as coercive rather than informative.18 The intent to influence conduct through public awareness is not fundamentally different from the function of a newspaper.19 It does not remove the expression from the reach of the First Amendment so long as the means remain peaceful.20
The injunction issued by the Illinois court must be vacated because it violates the petitioners' rights under the First Amendment.21
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Harlan dissented on jurisdictional grounds.22 He argued that the Court lacked jurisdiction to decide the case on the merits because the temporary injunction was not a final judgment within the meaning of 28 U.S.C. § 1257. The Illinois Supreme Court had never passed on the merits of petitioners' constitutional contentions.23
Review of interlocutory orders at this stage interferes with Illinois' arrangements for the expeditious processing of litigation by placing primary responsibility for constitutional adjudication in its Supreme Court. Harlan concluded that the writ should be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction to respect the congressional judgment limiting appellate review to final judgments rendered by the highest state court in which a decision could be had.24