475 U.S. 1 (1986)
Pacific Gas and Electric Company has for the past 62 years distributed a newsletter called Progress in its monthly billing envelopes to over three million customers.1 The newsletter has contained political editorials, feature stories on matters of public interest, tips on energy conservation, and information about utility services and bills.2
In 1980, Toward Utility Rate Normalization intervened in a ratemaking proceeding before the California Public Utilities Commission and urged the Commission to prohibit Pacific Gas and Electric from using the billing envelopes to distribute its political editorials.3 The Commission determined that the extra space in the billing envelopes, defined as the space remaining after inclusion of the monthly bill and required legal notices up to a total weight that would not result in additional postage, is the property of the ratepayers.4
The Commission permitted Toward Utility Rate Normalization to use the extra space four times a year for the next two years to communicate with ratepayers and raise funds.5 During those months, Pacific Gas and Electric may use any space not used by TURN and may include additional materials if it pays extra postage.6 The Commission required TURN to state that its messages are not those of Pacific Gas and Electric and reserved the right to grant access to other groups in the future.7
Pacific Gas and Electric appealed the Commission's order to the California Supreme Court, which denied discretionary review.8 The United States Supreme Court noted probable jurisdiction.9
Whether the California Public Utilities Commission may require a privately owned utility company to include in its billing envelopes speech of a third party with which the utility disagrees?10
The First Amendment prohibits government compulsion of speech that forces a speaker to associate with views it disagrees with or burdens its own expression.11 This principle was established in Miami Herald Publishing Co. v. Tornillo, where a right-of-reply statute was invalidated because it penalized newspapers for their expression by requiring them to publish replies.12 The same concern applies in Wooley v. Maynard, where individuals could not be forced to display a state motto on their license plates.13 These protections extend to corporations, as they contribute to the marketplace of ideas under cases such as First National Bank of Boston v. Bellotti and Consolidated Edison Co. v. Public Service Commission of New York.14
No. Pacific Gas and Electric Company has distributed its newsletter Progress in billing envelopes for 62 years, reaching over three million customers with content including political editorials and public interest stories.15
In 1980, Toward Utility Rate Normalization sought access to the extra space in those envelopes, which the Commission declared to be ratepayer property.16
The Commission ordered that TURN could use the extra space four times a year to communicate and raise funds.17 This requires Pacific Gas and Electric to include TURN's messages while allowing the utility to use remaining space or pay extra postage.18
The order forces the utility to disseminate speech with which it may disagree and creates a risk that it will feel compelled to respond or limit its own speech to avoid controversy.19 The access is viewpoint-discriminatory because it is granted to groups opposing the utility's interests in ratemaking proceedings.20
Although the state has interests in effective regulation and exposing customers to varied views, these can be served by less restrictive means such as awarding costs and fees to participating groups.21 The order is not content-neutral.22 Therefore, the order is not a narrowly tailored means of advancing compelling interests nor a valid time, place, or manner restriction.23 The Commission's order impermissibly burdens protected speech by requiring Pacific Gas and Electric to use its property to spread a third party's message.24 The fact that ratepayers are deemed to own the extra space does not eliminate the constitutional violation, as the utility still must use its envelopes and return address to distribute the messages.25 This situation is distinguishable from PruneYard Shopping Center v. Robins, where access did not burden the owner's own speech.26
The order of the California Public Utilities Commission violates the First Amendment rights of Pacific Gas and Electric Company.27
Related opinions on this issue
Chief Justice Burger joined the judgment but would decide the case under Wooley v. Maynard.28 He emphasized that the central question is the infringement of Pacific's right to be free from forced association with views with which it disagrees.29 Burger would also rely on the portion of Tornillo holding that a forced right of reply violates a newspaper's right to be free from forced dissemination of views it would not voluntarily disseminate.30
He concluded that compelling Pacific to mail messages for others cannot be distinguished from compelling it to carry the messages of others on its trucks, its buildings, or other property used in the conduct of its business.31
Justice Marshall concurred in the judgment and distinguished the case from PruneYard.32 He noted that appellant has never opened up its billing envelope to the use of the public.33 Appellant has not abandoned its right to exclude others from its property to the degree that the shopping center owner had done in PruneYard.34
Marshall found that the state's justification of subsidizing another speaker chosen by the State is insufficient to sustain even a minor burden on speech. He concluded that the State has crossed the boundary between constitutionally permissible and impermissible redefinitions of private property.35
Joined by Justice White And Justice Stevens Join As To Part I
Justice Rehnquist dissented, arguing that the case is governed by PruneYard and that negative free speech rights applicable to individuals and perhaps the print media should not be extended to corporations generally.36 He maintained that the right of access here will not have any noticeable deterrent effect on the utility's speech.37
Rehnquist concluded that the interest in facilitating and enlarging public discussion furthers rather than abridges First Amendment values and that the right of access is constitutionally indistinguishable from the right of access approved in PruneYard.38
Justice Stevens dissented, contending that the order is a narrow requirement limited to fundraising solicitations closely related to the billing envelope's purpose.39 He noted that the Commission did not select among competing advocacy groups and that the limited editorial license is confined to specific matters.40
Stevens analogized the requirement to Securities and Exchange Commission regulations requiring the incumbent board of directors to transmit proposals of dissident shareholders which it opposes.41 He argued that the order does not cross the threshold of unconstitutionality.42