Aleyn 26, 82 Eng. Rep. 897 (K.B. 1647)
Paradine brought an action of debt against Jane in the King's Bench Division.1 The action was based on a lease for years that reserved rent payable at the four usual feasts.2 The plaintiff sought recovery of rent in arrear for three years ending at the Feast of the Annunciation, 21 Car.3
The defendant pleaded that Prince Rupert, an alien born and an enemy to the King and kingdom, had invaded the realm with a hostile army.4 With that force the invader entered upon the defendant's possession on 19 July 18 Car.5 The army expelled the defendant and held him out of possession until the Feast of the Annunciation, 21 Car., so that the defendant could not take the profits.6
The plaintiff demurred to the defendant's plea.7 The court considered the matter on March 26, 1647.8 The action arose from the lease and the events of the invasion during the specified period.9
Whether the defendant's plea that an alien enemy army had expelled him from the leased land was sufficient to answer the plaintiff's action for rent arrears under a lease for years?10
Where a party by his own contract creates a duty or charge upon himself, he is bound to make it good, if he may, notwithstanding any accident by inevitable necessity, because he might have provided against it by his contract.11
No. Paradine brought an action of debt against Jane in the King's Bench Division.12 The action was based on a lease for years that reserved rent payable at the four usual feasts. The plaintiff sought recovery of rent in arrear for three years ending at the Feast of the Annunciation, 21 Car.
The defendant pleaded that Prince Rupert, an alien born and an enemy to the King and kingdom, had invaded the realm with a hostile army. With that force the invader entered upon the defendant's possession on 19 July 18 Car. The army expelled the defendant and held him out of possession until the Feast of the Annunciation, 21 Car., so that the defendant could not take the profits.
The plaintiff demurred to the defendant's plea. The court considered the matter on March 26, 1647. The action arose from the lease and the events of the invasion during the specified period.
The lease created a duty upon the defendant by contract to pay the rent.13 Although the invasion by the alien enemy army prevented the defendant from taking the profits, the plea is insufficient because the duty was created by the parties upon the reservation.14 The reservation is treated as a covenant in law upon which the lessee must make good the rent notwithstanding the interruption by enemies.15
The defendant's plea was insufficient to answer the action for rent arrears.16