413 U.S. 49, 67, 93 S.Ct. 2628, 2641, 37 L.Ed.2d 446 (1978)
On December 28, 1970, the district attorney for the Superior Court of Fulton County and the solicitor for the Criminal Court of Fulton County filed civil complaints in the Superior Court of Fulton County against the operators of Paris Adult Theatre I and Paris Adult Theatre II in Atlanta, Georgia.1 The complaints alleged that the theaters were exhibiting two motion pictures, Magic Mirror and It All Comes Out in the End, to the public for paid admission in violation of Georgia Code Annotated section 26-2101.2 They sought a declaration that the films were obscene together with an injunction against their continued exhibition.3
The theaters operated as adult establishments open only to persons over 21 years of age who provided proof of age.4 They charged a three-dollar admission fee and displayed signs stating Atlanta's Finest Mature Feature Films, Adult Theatre You must be 21 and able to prove it, and If viewing the nude body offends you, Please Do Not Enter.5 The two films depicted sexual conduct that the Georgia Supreme Court later characterized as hard core pornography leaving little to the imagination, including scenes of simulated fellatio, cunnilingus, and group sex intercourse.6
On January 13, 1971, the films were produced at a jury-waived trial along with photographs stipulated to accurately portray the single entrance to both theaters.7 Criminal investigators testified that they had paid admission to view the films and that nothing on the exterior of the theater indicated the full nature of the content shown.8 No evidence was presented that minors had ever entered the theaters or that the operators maintained a systematic policy of barring minors apart from the posted signs.9
On April 12, 1971, the trial judge dismissed the complaints.10 The judge assumed that obscenity was established but concluded that the display of the films in a commercial theater, when surrounded by notice to the public of their nature and by reasonable protection against exposure to minors, was constitutionally permissible.11 The Georgia Supreme Court unanimously reversed. It assumed that the theaters barred minors and gave full warning to the public. However, it held that the films were without protection under the First Amendment and that their exhibition should have been enjoined.12
The United States Supreme Court noted probable jurisdiction, heard argument on October 19, 1972, and on June 21, 1973, vacated the judgment of the Georgia Supreme Court and remanded the case for further proceedings not inconsistent with its decision in Miller v. California.13
Whether the exhibition of obscene motion pictures in a commercial theater open only to consenting adults may be prohibited by the State?14
Obscene material is not protected by the First Amendment as a limitation on state police power under the Fourteenth Amendment.15 States have a legitimate interest in regulating the use of obscene material in local commerce and in places of public accommodation even if sold only to consenting adults.16 The right recognized in Stanley v. Georgia does not extend beyond the privacy of the home to commercial exhibition.17
Yes.18 The Georgia statute as construed by the Georgia courts meets the Miller v. California standards.19 The statute defines obscene material as that which to the average person applying contemporary community standards appeals to the prurient interest, is patently offensive, and lacks serious literary artistic political or scientific value.20 The films Magic Mirror and It All Comes Out in the End were found to be hard core pornography leaving little to the imagination and depicting simulated fellatio cunnilingus and group sex intercourse.21
The commercial theaters charged admission and operated as public accommodations open to adults over twenty one with posted signs but without evidence of a systematic policy barring minors beyond the signs.22 The state interest in protecting the quality of life the tone of commerce and the public from offense of public exhibition of obscene material justifies regulation even when minors are excluded and only consenting adults attend.23
The exhibition of obscene motion pictures in a commercial theater open only to consenting adults may be prohibited by the State.24
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justice Stewart And Justice Marshall
Justice Brennan dissented on the ground that the Roth approach culminating in the Miller restatement cannot provide stable manageable standards without jeopardizing First Amendment values.25 The concept of obscenity cannot be defined with sufficient specificity to provide fair notice prevent erosion of protected speech or avoid institutional harms to the judiciary.26
He would hold that at least absent distribution to juveniles or obtrusive exposure to unconsenting adults the First and Fourteenth Amendments prohibit governments from wholly suppressing sexually oriented materials on the basis of their allegedly obscene contents.27 This applies even when exhibited in commercial theaters to consenting adults.28 Brennan anchored this view in the vagueness problems that have produced per curiam reversals under Redrup and the failure of any formula to separate obscenity from protected expression without chilling effects.29
Justice Douglas dissented on the ground that the First Amendment does not permit regulation of obscenity at all because the line between obscenity and protected expression is too vague to be enforced.30 Prior to the Constitution the Colonies had no law excluding obscenity from the regime of freedom of expression.31
He would reverse the judgment because the State has no power to regulate the content of films shown to consenting adults.32 The creation of an obscenity exception was a legislative and judicial tour de force that should have required a constitutional amendment.33 Douglas emphasized that tastes are too personal to define and that government is not permitted to sit in judgment on one's tastes or beliefs save as they involve action within the reach of the police power.34
Whether the right to privacy recognized in Stanley v. Georgia extends to the public exhibition of obscene material in a commercial theater?35
No.3839 Stanley was based on the right of privacy in the home and does not control the commercial exhibition of obscene material in a theater that is a public accommodation under the Civil Rights Act of 1964.40 The theaters here operated with a common box office and lobby on Peachtree Street charged a three dollar admission fee and displayed signs indicating mature feature films but remained open to the public.41
The idea of a privacy right and a place of public accommodation are mutually exclusive in this context.42 Conduct that the state police power can prohibit on a public street does not become protected merely because moved to a theater stage.43 The state has legitimate interests in the quality of life the total community environment and the tone of commerce that are distinct from any privacy interest in the home.44
The right to privacy recognized in Stanley v. Georgia does not extend to the public exhibition of obscene material in a commercial theater.45
Whether Georgia's obscenity statute is unconstitutionally vague or overbroad as applied to the exhibition of the films in question?46
A statute is not unconstitutionally vague or overbroad when as construed by the state courts it gives adequate notice of what is prohibited. It is consistent with the Miller standards defining obscenity as material that appeals to the prurient interest is patently offensive and lacks serious value.47
No. The Georgia statute defines obscene material as that which to the average person applying contemporary community standards would be considered as appealing to the prurient interest. The material is patently offensive. Taken as a whole it lacks serious literary artistic political or scientific value.
This definition accords with the Miller standards.48 The Georgia Supreme Court held that the definition given in the charge to the jury was in accord with Memoirs v. Massachusetts and that the films were in fact obscene.49 The statute as construed provides adequate notice to persons in the position of the petitioners who operated the theaters and the films meet the test as hard core pornography.50 The procedure of a full adversary civil proceeding prior to any criminal indictment further ensures notice and avoids prior restraint issues.51
Georgia's obscenity statute is not unconstitutionally vague or overbroad as applied to the exhibition of the films in question.52
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justice Stewart And Justice Marshall
Justice Brennan would have held the Georgia statute unconstitutionally overbroad on its face because it reaches material protected by the First Amendment and does not provide the narrow specificity required in the regulation of expression.53
He argued that the statute prohibits dissemination of any material that appeals to the prurient interest is patently offensive and lacks serious value which is the standard rejected in Memoirs.54 Even if constitutional the films have serious value and are not hard core pornography that may be regulated.55 Brennan concluded that the State has no legitimate interest in regulating exhibition to consenting adults and that the right to view such material in private is protected by the First Amendment.56