214 U.S. 185 (1909)
Peck brought this action on the case for libel against the Tribune Company.1 The libel alleged appeared in an advertisement printed in the defendant’s newspaper, The Chicago Sunday Tribune.2 The advertisement began with the heading 'Nurse and Patients Praise Duffy's' and described Mrs. A. Schuman as one of Chicago’s most capable and experienced nurses who paid tribute to Duffy’s Pure Malt Whiskey.3 It included a portrait of the plaintiff with the words 'Mrs. A. Schuman' under it, followed by a quoted statement recommending the whiskey as the best tonic and stimulant, and ended with the name and address 'Mrs. A. Schuman, 1576 Mozart st., Chicago, Ill.'4
The declaration alleged that the plaintiff was not Mrs. Schuman, was not a nurse, and was a total abstainer from whiskey and all spirituous liquors.5 There was also a count for publishing the plaintiff’s likeness without leave.6 The defendant pleaded not guilty.7
At the trial, subject to exceptions, the judge excluded the plaintiff’s testimony in support of her allegations and directed a verdict for the defendant.8 His action was sustained by the Circuit Court of Appeals.9
Whether the advertisement was published of and concerning the plaintiff?10
A publication is of and concerning the plaintiff if the insertion of the plaintiff’s picture in the place and with the concomitants described imported that she was the nurse and made the statements set forth.11 This holds notwithstanding the presence of another fact inconsistent with the plaintiff’s having signed or adopted it.12 Many might recognize the plaintiff’s face without knowing her name. Those who did know it might be led to infer that she had sanctioned the publication under an alias.
Yes. The advertisement printed in the defendant’s newspaper The Chicago Sunday Tribune included a portrait of the plaintiff with the words Mrs. A. Schuman under it, followed by the quoted statement recommending Duffy’s Pure Malt Whiskey, and ended with the name and address Mrs. A. Schuman, 1576 Mozart st., Chicago, Ill.13
This imported that the plaintiff was the nurse making the statements.14 Many might recognize the plaintiff’s face without knowing her name, and those who did know it might be led to infer that she had sanctioned the publication under an alias.15 Although the declaration alleged that the plaintiff was not Mrs. Schuman, was not a nurse, and was a total abstainer from whiskey and all spirituous liquors, the publication still concerned her.16
The advertisement was published of and concerning the plaintiff.17
Whether the defendant is liable for libel even if it published the portrait by mistake and without knowledge that it was the plaintiff's?18
If the publication was libellous, the defendant took the risk.19 A libel is harmful on its face.20 If a man sees fit to publish manifestly hurtful statements concerning an individual, without other justification than exists for an advertisement or a piece of news, the usual principles of tort will make him liable, if the statements are false or are true only of some one else. Whatever a man publishes he publishes at his peril.21
Yes. There was some suggestion that the defendant published the portrait by mistake and without knowledge that it was the plaintiff’s portrait or was not what it purported to be.22 That fact, if it was one, was no excuse.23 The publication of the false statements concerning the plaintiff makes the defendant liable under the principles of tort.24 Yet the risk of publication remains with the defendant regardless of mistake.25
The defendant is liable for libel even if it published the portrait by mistake and without knowledge that it was the plaintiff's.26
Whether the publication constituted a libel by tending to hurt the plaintiff's standing with a considerable and respectable class in the community?27
If the advertisement obviously would hurt the plaintiff in the estimation of an important and respectable part of the community, liability is not a question of a majority vote.28 No falsehood is thought about or even known by all the world.29 No conduct is hated by all.30 If it will be known by a large number and will lead an appreciable fraction of that number to regard the plaintiff with contempt, that is enough to do her practical harm.31
Yes. The publication represented the plaintiff as a nurse recommending whiskey after years of constant use both by herself and as given to patients.32 Yet the plaintiff was a total abstainer from whiskey and all spirituous liquors according to the declaration.33 It may be that giving a certificate and the use of one’s portrait in aid of an advertisement would be regarded with irony or a stronger feeling only by a few.34
But the obvious tendency of what is imputed to the plaintiff by this advertisement is seriously to hurt her standing with a considerable and respectable class in the community.35 Such inquiries are beside the point under the general principles of tort.36
The publication constituted a libel by tending to hurt the plaintiff's standing with a considerable and respectable class in the community.37
Whether the plaintiff may maintain the action and go to the jury without alleging or proving special damage?38
Since the publication is libellous on its face, the plaintiff has the right to prove her case and go to the jury. If the advertisement obviously would hurt the plaintiff in the estimation of an important and respectable part of the community, the defendant would have got all that it could ask if it had been permitted to persuade the jury, if it could, to take a contrary view. Special damage need not be alleged.39
Yes. No special damage was alleged.40 It seems impossible to say that the obvious tendency of what is imputed to the plaintiff by this advertisement is not seriously to hurt her standing with a considerable and respectable class in the community.41 Therefore it was the plaintiff’s right to prove her case and go to the jury.42
The plaintiff may maintain the action and go to the jury without alleging or proving special damage.43