356 U.S. 44 (1958)
Perez was born in Texas in 1909 and resided in the United States until 1919 or 1920, when he moved with his parents to Mexico, where he lived without interruption until 1943.1 In 1928 he was informed that he had been born in Texas.2 At the outbreak of World War II, Perez knew of the duty of male United States citizens to register for the draft but failed to do so.3
In 1943 Perez applied for admission to the United States as an alien railroad laborer, stating that he was a native-born citizen of Mexico, and was granted permission to enter on a temporary basis.4 He returned to Mexico in 1944 and shortly thereafter applied for and was granted permission, again as a native-born Mexican citizen, to enter the United States temporarily to continue his employment as a railroad laborer.5 Later in 1944 he returned to Mexico once more.6
In 1947 Perez applied for admission to the United States at El Paso, Texas, as a citizen of the United States.7 At a Board of Special Inquiry hearing, he admitted having remained outside of the United States to avoid military service and having voted in political elections in Mexico.8 He was ordered excluded on the ground that he had expatriated himself; this order was affirmed on appeal.9 In 1952 Perez, claiming to be a native-born citizen of Mexico, was permitted to enter the United States as an alien agricultural laborer.10 He surrendered in 1953 to immigration authorities in San Francisco as an alien unlawfully in the United States but claimed the right to remain by virtue of his American citizenship.11 After a hearing before a Special Inquiry Officer, he was ordered deported as an alien not in possession of a valid immigration visa; this order was affirmed on appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals.12
Petitioner brought suit in 1954 in a United States District Court for a judgment declaring him to be a national of the United States.13 The Court, sitting without a jury, found that petitioner had remained outside of the United States from November 1944 to July 1947 for the purpose of avoiding service in the armed forces of the United States and that he had voted in a political election in Mexico in 1946.14 The court denied the relief sought by the petitioner.15 The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed.16 The Supreme Court granted certiorari because of the constitutional questions raised by the petitioner.17
Whether Congress has the constitutional power to provide that a United States national loses nationality by voting in a political election in a foreign state?18
Congress possesses power to regulate foreign affairs even though no specific grant appears in the Constitution.19 This power permits legislation that attaches loss of citizenship to conduct creating serious embarrassments in the conduct of foreign relations.20 The means chosen must bear a rational relationship to that end under the Necessary and Proper Clause.21
Yes. Perez was born in Texas in 1909 and resided in Mexico from 1919 or 1920 until 1943.22 The District Court found that Perez voted in a political election in Mexico in 1946.23 Such voting by an American citizen can cause foreign governments to regard the action as reflecting United States policy or can promote courses of conduct contrary to American interests.24
Withdrawal of citizenship directly terminates the source of potential embarrassment because the conduct loses its character as the act of an American citizen.25 The classification of political elections is reasonably related to the foreign-affairs objective because only elections of political significance in the life of another country are covered.26
Congress therefore had constitutional authority to enact the provision declaring that voting in a foreign political election results in loss of United States nationality.27
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justices Black And Douglas
Chief Justice Warren dissented.28 The Fourteenth Amendment confers citizenship as a constitutional birthright that Congress may not divest through exercise of its general regulatory powers.29 Whatever may be the scope of its powers to regulate the conduct and affairs of all persons within its jurisdiction, a government of the people cannot take away their citizenship simply because one branch of that government can be said to have a conceivably rational basis for wanting to do so.30
Citizenship is man's basic right for it is nothing less than the right to have rights.31 Only voluntary conduct demonstrating abandonment of allegiance can result in loss of citizenship.32 While the essential qualities of the citizen-state relationship under our Constitution preclude the exercise of governmental power to divest United States citizenship, the establishment of that relationship did not impair the principle that conduct of a citizen showing a voluntary transfer of allegiance is an abandonment of citizenship.33
The bare act of voting in a foreign election, without more, does not invariably show such abandonment, especially when the election is open to aliens under foreign law.34 The fatal defect in the statute before us is that its application is not limited to those situations that may rationally be said to constitute an abandonment of citizenship.35 Because the statute applies indiscriminately, it exceeds congressional authority.36
Joined by Justice Black
Justice Douglas joined the Chief Justice.37 The philosophy of the opinion that sustains this statute is foreign to our constitutional system.38 It gives supremacy to the Legislature in a way that is incompatible with the scheme of our written Constitution.39
The Fourteenth Amendment places citizenship beyond the reach of any enumerated power when used to cancel the right.40 What the Constitution grants the Constitution can take away.41 But there is not a word in that document that covers expatriation.42
He emphasized that the statute permits expatriation for ambiguous conduct lacking any demonstrated transfer of allegiance.43 If Congress can withdraw citizenship for voting abroad on the theory that it regulates foreign affairs, then the same power could be used to cancel citizenship for any unpopular view on foreign policy.44 If casting a ballot abroad is sufficient to deprive an American of his citizenship, why could not like penalties be imposed on the citizen who expresses disagreement with his Nation's foreign policy in any of the ways enumerated?45
This would undermine the absolute grant of citizenship.46
Whether Congress has the constitutional power to provide that a United States national loses nationality by departing from or remaining outside the United States in time of war or during a period declared by the President to be a period of national emergency for the purpose of evading or avoiding training and service in the land or naval forces of the United States?47
A court will not decide the constitutional validity of a provision when the judgment can be affirmed on an independent ground.48
No. The Court did not reach the question whether Congress has the constitutional power to provide that a United States national loses nationality by departing from or remaining outside the United States in time of war or during a period declared by the President to be a period of national emergency for the purpose of evading or avoiding training and service in the land or naval forces of the United States.49 The District Court found that Perez remained outside the United States from November 1944 to July 1947 for the purpose of avoiding service in the armed forces of the United States.50 The court of appeals affirmed the judgment of expatriation.51 Because the voting ground alone sustains the judgment, the Court expressly declined to adjudicate the constitutionality of the service-avoidance provision.52
The Court therefore did not reach or resolve the question whether Congress possesses power to attach loss of nationality to the conduct described in the service-avoidance provision.53
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justices Black And Douglas
Chief Justice Warren dissented on grounds applicable to both provisions.54 The Fourteenth Amendment confers citizenship as a constitutional birthright that Congress may not divest through exercise of its general regulatory powers. Congress did not assume it was empowered to use denationalization as a weapon to aid in the exercise of its general powers.55
Nor should we.56 The same reasoning applies to the service-avoidance provision because it attaches loss of nationality without requiring proof that the citizen intended to abandon American citizenship.57 The basic right of American citizenship has been too dearly won to be so lightly lost.58
Joined by Justice Black
Justice Douglas joined the Chief Justice. The Fourteenth Amendment grants citizenship to the native-born, as explained in United States v. Wong Kim Ark, supra.59 That right may be waived or surrendered by the citizen.60
But I see no constitutional method by which it can be taken from him.61 Once the Constitution grants citizenship by birth, no enumerated power permits Congress to turn an act into expatriation when the act lacks the quality of voluntary relinquishment or transfer of allegiance to another nation.62