930 A.2d 890
On March 20, 2002, around 6 p.m., Kristyn Pipher, Johnathan Parsell, and Johnene Beisel, all sixteen years old, were traveling south on Delaware Route 1 near Lewes in Parsell’s pickup truck.1 Parsell was driving, Pipher sat in the middle of the front seat, and Beisel occupied the passenger seat next to the door. They proceeded at a speed of 55 miles per hour.2
As they drove, Beisel unexpectedly grabbed the steering wheel, causing the truck to veer off onto the shoulder of the road.3 Parsell testified that the action caused him shock and surprise, and although he became more guarded, he did not expect Beisel to grab the wheel again.4 Pipher recalled that after the first incident, Parsell regained control, and both Parsell and Beisel laughed about the event as if it were a joke.5
Approximately thirty seconds later, Beisel yanked the steering wheel a second time.6 This caused Parsell’s truck to leave the roadway, slide down an embankment, and strike a tree, resulting in injuries to Pipher.7
At trial, Parsell acknowledged several steps he could have taken after the first incident, including admonishing Beisel not to touch the steering wheel again, pulling over to require Beisel to move to the back seat, or warning Beisel that he would put her out of the vehicle.8 Pipher testified that she believed Beisel grabbed the wheel a second time because Parsell had laughed off the first occurrence.9
Pipher was awarded $70,150.00 in damages against Beisel.10 However, Beisel was not located before, during, or after trial.11 The Superior Court entered judgment as a matter of law in favor of Parsell on Pipher’s negligence claim against him, and Pipher appealed that judgment to the Supreme Court of Delaware.12
Whether the Superior Court erred in granting judgment as a matter of law to Parsell on Pipher's claim that he was negligent?13
To establish a negligence claim, a plaintiff must establish that the defendant owed the plaintiff a duty of care, that the defendant breached that duty, and that the defendant’s breach was the proximate cause of the plaintiff's injury.14 The defendant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law if the plaintiff fails to establish a prima facie case of negligence, or under no reasonable view of the evidence could a jury find in favor of the plaintiff.15 Disputed issues of foreseeability and proximate cause involve factual determinations that must be submitted to a jury.16 A driver owes a duty of care to passengers because it is foreseeable that they may be injured if, through inattention or otherwise, the driver involves the car in a collision.17 When actions of a passenger that interfere with the driver’s safe operation of the motor vehicle are foreseeable, the failure to prevent such conduct may be a breach of the driver’s duty to either other passengers or to the public.18
Yes. On March 20, 2002, around 6 p.m., Kristyn Pipher, Johnathan Parsell, and Johnene Beisel, all sixteen years old, were traveling south on Delaware Route 1 near Lewes in Parsell’s pickup truck with Parsell driving, Pipher in the middle, and Beisel next to the door at 55 miles per hour.19 Beisel unexpectedly grabbed the steering wheel, causing the truck to veer onto the shoulder.20 Parsell testified this caused him shock and surprise, after which he became more guarded yet took no action and did not expect a repeat.21
Pipher recalled that after the first incident Parsell regained control and both Parsell and Beisel laughed about it as if it were a joke.22 Approximately thirty seconds later Beisel yanked the steering wheel a second time, causing the truck to leave the roadway, slide down an embankment, and strike a tree, injuring Pipher.23 At trial Parsell acknowledged he could have admonished Beisel not to touch the wheel again, pulled over to move her to the back seat, or warned her he would put her out of the vehicle.24 Pipher testified she believed Beisel grabbed the wheel a second time because Parsell laughed off the first occurrence.25
A reasonable jury could find that after the initial grab Parsell was on notice of a dangerous situation. The repeat conduct was foreseeable given the laughter and lack of response. His failure to take any preventive steps breached the duty owed to Pipher and proximately caused her injuries when the second grab occurred.26
The Superior Court erred in granting judgment as a matter of law to Parsell because the issues of Parsell’s alleged breach of duty to Pipher, the foreseeability of Beisel’s repeat conduct, and the proximate cause of Pipher’s injuries were all factual determinations that should have been submitted to the jury.27