292 U.S. 98, 54 S.Ct. 580, 78 L.Ed. 1149 (1934)
John Pokora, an ice dealer, was driving his truck west along Edwards Street in Springfield, Illinois, to load ice from a depot at the southwest corner of Tenth and Edwards Streets.1 The Wabash Railway tracks run along Tenth Street, with four tracks at the crossing: a switch track, the main track, and two additional switches.2 Pokora had initially stopped at the northeast corner but found too many trucks ahead, so he proceeded to cross the tracks toward the other depot.3
As he approached the crossing, Pokora stopped his truck about ten or fifteen feet east of the switch track and looked north for trains, but a string of box cars on the switch track, five to ten feet from the north line of Edwards Street, obstructed his view.4 He listened for signals but heard neither bell nor whistle.5 He then crossed the switch track and, upon reaching the main track, was struck by a northbound passenger train traveling at twenty-five to thirty miles per hour.6
Pokora made his crossing in the day time on a frequented highway in a populous city. Between the switch and main tracks there was an eight-foot space, but locomotive and box car overhangs narrowed the safe zone.7 Pokora remained seated in his truck throughout.8 Following the collision, Pokora sued the Wabash Railway Company for damages in federal district court.9
The District Court directed a verdict for the defendant, finding contributory negligence as a matter of law.10 The Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment, relying on the Supreme Court's prior decision in Baltimore & Ohio Railroad Co. v. Goodman.11 The Supreme Court granted a writ of certiorari to review the case.12
Whether the District Court properly directed a verdict for the defendant on the ground that Pokora was contributorily negligent as a matter of law?13
The question whether reasonable caution forbade going forward in reliance on the sense of hearing, unaided by that of sight, is for the jury when vision is cut off by obstacles at a crossing.14
No. Pokora stopped his truck about ten or fifteen feet east of the switch track and looked north for trains, but a string of box cars obstructed his view while he listened for signals.15 Pokora made his crossing in the day time on a frequented highway in a populous city, with an eight-foot space between tracks narrowed by overhangs, and Pokora remained seated throughout.16 The District Court directed a verdict for the defendant, finding contributory negligence as a matter of law, but the facts permit the inference that the truck was in the zone of danger by the time the field of vision was enlarged, making the issue one for the jury rather than a directed verdict.17
The District Court did not properly direct a verdict because the evidence did not show contributory negligence so obvious that one conclusion and one only is permissible for rational and candid minds.18
Whether the rule announced in B. & O. R. Co. v. Goodman required Pokora to stop his vehicle and get out to survey the tracks before crossing?19
The opinion in Goodman is limited to its facts. It does not impose an absolute duty to get out of the vehicle at every obstructed crossing. Standards of prudent conduct are taken from the facts of life. Extraordinary situations are for the judgment of a jury.20
No. Pokora did stop before starting to cross the tracks. Getting out would likely be futile or dangerous because a train traveling at thirty miles an hour covers a quarter of a mile in thirty seconds and box cars might be shunted down upon him.21 The facts show the crossing was straight for five blocks north with no locomotive visible at the forward end of the cars. The balance of advantage depends on circumstances that a jury must weigh rather than a fixed rule from Goodman.22
The rule announced in Goodman did not require Pokora to stop his vehicle and get out to survey the tracks before crossing.23