4 P.3d 209 (Wyo. 2001)
WMC was committed to its $45 million expansion project, at the heart of which was its westward construction. Because the doctors' properties lay west, WMC's acquisition of them was a necessity. The doctors did not want to relocate for a number of legitimate reasons. To persuade them to move, WMC promoted the "state-of-the-art" replacement medical office building which would equal in quality what Dr. Roussalis had in his existing medical office building. The new building would represent WMC's vision of the partnership achievable between a hospital and a doctor. If WMC moved quickly to secure the doctors' commitment, WMC could affect a $2.6 million saving in interest on its $31.8 million revenue bond. In order to obtain the revenue bond, WMC had to show a binding contract on the doctors' properties. WMC needed to begin construction as soon as possible. WMC approached the doctors and negotiations ensued. WMC desired a maximum construction cost term; it proposed a "cost cap" of $150/sq. foot. The doctors rejected a maximum construction cost term or "cost cap" until the design drawings, plans and specifications were developed and final because they wanted to know what the new building would look like. It would take four to six months to develop final design drawings, plans and specifications. WMC did not want to wait that amount of time because of the $2.6 million interest savings if it moved quickly. WMC and the doctors intentionally and deliberately deleted from the Letter of Intent the maximum construction cost or "cost cap" term. They intentionally and deliberately included the terms which appear in that document. They knew the new medical building project would not be a "typical" project in any sense. According to Mike Gurkin, the general contractor, in a "typical" construction project, the design drawings, plans and specifications are developed and finalized first; then that package is distributed to the subcontractors who submit bids (construction costs) based on the drawings, plans, and specifications; when the bids are received, the cost of construction is determined, winning bids are accepted, construction contracts awarded, and construction begins. WMC's new building project took on strange trappings. Because of WMC's "fast track" requirements, the doctors' new medical building would be literally designed and built "on the run."
Our earlier statement of the facts accurately identifies the contents of the Letter of Intent which the parties signed in March, 1995, in culmination of their negotiations. It is true, as WMC argues, that this document does not contain a term stating the "cost" of the new medical office building. However, as the doctors contend, a juror could reasonably infer that the parties did not intend that a specific "cost" term be essential to the formation of their contract. This reasonable inference could be drawn from the parties' prior negotiations and the contents of the cover memorandum which WMC's counsel Williams attached to WMC's final draft of the Letter of Intent. In that memorandum, Williams wrote:
I Attached is the revised letter agreement.... I have struggled with some way to incorporate a maximum construction cost, which was a concern of the Board, but I don't see any way to do that at this point in time, so I need to proceed without that figure in the agreement.
The doctors also note that Williams testified, "we talked at the board level about taking a leap of faith, if you will, to-that we could do the [doctors'] transaction without having that safety hook [of a cost cap]." From this evidence, a juror could draw the reasonable inference that the parties achieved mutual assent that a "cost" term was not an essential term of the contract.
As we read the parties' Letter of Intent, we are struck by the words of present contract formation. For example, in the opening paragraph we find the words "the following offer," "(b)y signing this letter of intent, you are agreeing to a legally enforceable contract for this exchange upon successful and acceptable completion of all of [WMC's] obligations as described in this letter." In the closing paragraph, we find similar contract formation language: "(t)his agreement is binding," and "(WMC) intends to be legally bound by the terms and conditions set forth in this letter." As WMC's counsel Williams explained, WMC intentionally included in this closing paragraph language specifically binding not only the doctors, but also their heirs, successors and assigns so that they too would be bound in the event one or both doctors died "halfway into the building." In reviewing the results of other litigation about whether such letters of intent are binding, Professor Farnsworth informs us that "(i)n many cases courts have looked to the degree of formality and the use of legal terminology." I Farnsworth, supra, § 3.8, n.3, at 179-80; and see § 3.8b, at 198-94. See, e.g., Field v. Golden Triangle Broadcasting, 451 Pa. 410, 305 A.2d 689, 692-93 (1973), cert. denied, 414 U.S. 1158, 94 S.Ct. 916, 39 L.Ed.2d 110 (1974) ("the letter agreement itself, by its terms (describing it as an 'offer'), formality and the extraordinary care in its execution, indicates that the signatories intended to bind themselves to an enforceable contract"); APCO Amusement Co. v. Wilkins Family Restaurants, 673 S.W.2d 523, 527-28 (Tenn.App.1984) ("instrument speaks through words such as 'agrees,' 'acceptance,' and 'accepts' (and) has been dated and signed"); and Reynolds Aluminum Co. v. Multnomah County, 206 Or. 602, 287 P.2d 921, 927 (1955), cert. denied, 350 U.S. 970, 76 S.Ct. 437, 100 L.Ed. 842 (1956) ("we find words speaking in the present, not in futuro, such as: 'seller hereby sells' and 'purchaser hereby buys'").
In addition to the language used in these opening and closing paragraphs, and the formality and care taken by the parties in drafting and in executing the document, we note that the document neither contains language that the parties will agree in the future about a specific cost figure nor language that they will execute in the future a later writing. Professor Farnsworth notes:
In doubtful cases, courts have looked to many factors, but no single factor is likely to be decisive. Often the final decision is left to the trier of the facts.
I Farnsworth, supra, § 3.8, at 180-81.
Against the argument that the failure to spell out usual terms shows that the parties did not intend to be bound, Professor Farnsworth replies, appropriately we think, "such an inference seems unjustified if there is no indication that those terms were to be the subject of further negotiations." Id. at 182. We would add the observation that the movant in a summary judgment setting, WMC here, does not enjoy the benefit of inferences; rather, only the non-movant, the doctors here, does. We agree with that said in Berg Agency v. Sleepworld-Willingboro, Inc., 136 N.J.Super. 369, 346 A.2d 419, 424 (1975):
The absence of some provisions in a document does not necessarily negate its viability as a binding agreement.
The key factor is not the absence of any contractual undertakings which may normally be included by contracting parties engaged in a similar transaction. It is rather the intent of the particular parties involved in the transaction at issue. And the presence or absence of essential contract provisions is but an element in the evidential panorama underlying a factual finding of intent and enforceability.
In our judgment, the contents of the Letter of Intent and the reasonable inferences which a jury may draw from them are evidence which may support a jury's conclusion of the intent of the parties to be bound.
Other provisions of the Letter of Intent provide evidence from which a reasonable juror could conclude that the parties' intention was that the kind of building, not the cost of that building, was an essential term of their contract. From this evidence a reasonable juror could also conclude that the parties achieved mutuality of assent and definiteness about "the kind of building to be constructed." Those provisions include numbered paragraphs one through five and nine of the document. Those provisions speak in terms of "an approximately 9,500 square foot medical office building, with a full roughed-in basement" which is "an equivalent amount of square footage from (the doctors') existing buildings, as adjusted for ADA compliance, space required for the pilot computer project, and additional stairway and related office requirements;" "(t)he floor plan of the new building ... shall be at the discretion and direction of (the doctors) ..., and shall be based on architectural and/or engineering drawings which are approved by (the doctors)." Exhibit A to the document is a representative, not exhaustive, list of the types of high quality specific features "which will be incorporated into the design and construction of this new medical office building." In the words of these parties, "(i)t is (their) general intent ... that the new building will be of comparable quality to (Dr. Roussalis' currently occupied building), i.e. that the new building will be a replacement building of the same high quality and state-of-the-art which was built into (Dr. Roussalis' existing building)." The quality of both the interior and exterior of the new building "shall be equal in quality" or "of comparable quality" to Dr. Roussalis' existing building.
WMC pointedly relies on that provision (paragraph four under the heading New Medical Office Building) which recites that "Tom Judy will direct the interior design, and Martin Sheldon or a similarly qualified finish expert will be in charge of the woodwork in the new building" to support an inference to be drawn in WMC's favor that "you do not bring in an interior designer if you're concerned about cost." Of course, on summary judgment, favorable inferences are drawn in favor of the non-movant, not the movant. With respect to this "interior designer" provision, it must be remembered that WMC drafted this document and agreed to its provisions, including this one. The favorable inference to be drawn in the doctors' favor from this particular provision, using WMC's logic, is WMC was not concerned about cost either because it agreed to bring in the interior designer and qualified woodwork finish expert.
Keeping in mind these particular provisions describing "the kind of building to be constructed," we tie in to our analysis at this precise point what WMC's counsel Williams wrote on September 5, 1995, shortly after WMC had received Mr. Gurkin's estimate of the cost of the new building, when WMC was seeking a review of the new building's cost. Williams described the transaction in these words:
The concept of the transaction has always been that the "replacement" building would be the type of building that Dr. Roussalis would build if he were building a building of the same type of state-of-the-art quality (technologically and aesthetically) which was included in his current office when he built it 10 years ago. Dr. Roussalis built a very nice, and very expensive, building ten years ago ($182/ft.). As you can see, this is somewhat of a different concept than a straight replacement building, where the limits are clear that only features that are in the current building may be included in the new building. I appreciate that this is a very open-ended concept, but I can tell you that this was the essence of our agreement, and was the critical factor in the physicians agreeing to locate. That is the intent and spirit of the letter agreement.
(Emphasis added.) These words provide evidence from which a reasonable juror could conclude that the parties' intention, about what was or was not an essential term of the contract, was what kind of building was to be constructed. Moreover, Williams' closing words in this letter to the effect that if the cost reviewer concludes that an increase in the project is in order, WMC needs to know and wants "the building to be a success in all aspects"—are evidence from which a reasonable juror could conclude that cost was not an essential term of the contract, but that "the type of building that Dr. Roussalis would build of state-of-the-art quality" was.
From the facts that the parties knowingly and purposely negotiated "out" a specific cost figure; WMC did not want to wait four to six months for final design drawings, plans and specifications from which a specific cost figure is typically determined, and the new building was literally being designed and built "on the run;" the parties, as evidenced by Exhibit A to their Letter of Intent, expressly contemplated that other high-quality features would be added to the new building as performance proceeded, which additional features would more likely than not increase the "cost" of the building; a reasonable juror could draw the inference that the parties did not intend a specific cost figure to be an essential term of their contract. From the facts, including those provisions of the Letter of Intent particularly related to the quality of the new building, a reasonable juror could draw the inference that the parties intended a "Dr. Roussalis-built" building to be an essential term of their contract. As WMC's Williams put it, that "very open-ended concept ... was the essence of our agreement ... (and) the intent and spirit of the letter agreement."
We now turn our attention to the parties' post-Letter of Intent actions as evidence of the parties' mutuality of assent and definiteness about their transaction. Of course, WMC's Williams' September 5, 1995, letter to the "cost reviewer," just mentioned above, falls into this category, and will be taken into account, but need not be repeated here. Other post-Letter of Intent actions exist and are described earlier in the statement of facts. Rather than reiterate verbatim that evidence here, we shall briefly identify some of the highlights of that evidence.
Shortly after the doctors and WMC's authorized representative signed the Letter of Intent, WMC counsel Williams reported to the WMC Board "that signed contracts with (the doctors) have been secured. Demolition of the existing buildings (on the land south of the hospital) will begin in mid-April and construction of the new office building will begin in June." WMC's Carriger informed general contractor Gurkin of the contractual agreement with the doctors and declared WMC's "legally binding commitment" to Gurkin to enter into a construction contract for the project.
WMC believed that a June 1996 completion date on the doctors' new building was critical timing in the building schedule of the new hospital. Mr. Gurkin asked WMC's Williams if it would be better to delay actual construction of the doctors' new building until the design drawings, plans and specifications were finalized, so that a cost estimate could be prepared. Williams instructed Gurkin to proceed with construction in order to be completed as early as possible.
In late April, 1995, WMC held a press conference to announce the hospital expansion project and the doctors' new medical office building. At WMC's request, Dr. Roussalis attended and spoke.
In May, 1995, the county commissioners of Natrona County approved proceeding with the revenue bond issue for financing the hospital expansion; the WMC Board and the hospital trustees approved a resolution authorizing the revenue bond issue; and the county commissioners approved the revenue bonds. Also in May, WMC's Williams signed a site application plan which he submitted to the City of Casper, showing that WMC as "owner" was constructing a medical office building for the doctors. In early June, the $31.8 million revenue bond issue was finalized, and the Norwest Bank of Casper received the proceeds as trustee of the bond funds.
From March through the summer months of 1995, the doctors spent countless hours on the design of the new building. Gurkin "loaded them up." In June, Gurkin did the demolition work to clear the site on which the new medical office building would be constructed. Excavation of the basement occurred.
In mid-July, after Carriger's death, representatives of WMC and the City of Casper signed a site plan agreement for the doctors' new building. WMC's Williams asked Gurkin to give him an estimate of the cost of the new building; Gurkin told Williams that he (Gurkin) had to know how to proceed because he was soon to pour the building's foundation, spending $100,000. Gurkin gave Williams a written "guess" of the cost of the new building (11,900 square feet main floor and 11,900 square feet basement) of $2,677,500. Gurkin told Williams that there were fifty-four substantial items of cost which "can flow either up or down $5,000 per item." He cautioned that each item's cost could not be pinned down until the plans, all of the changes and approvals, were complete; and a project of this size should have a 5% to 10% override for changes as the project develops. Thus, a reasonable juror could infer from this evidence that WMC knew or should have known at that time the cost might exceed $3 million. Williams directed Gurkin to shut down the project; Williams arranged an emergency meeting of the WMC Board. At that meeting the WMC Board read Gurkin's cost "guess" letter, reviewed the Letter of Intent, and discussed what action to take. The Board did not discuss what amount of money it was prepared to spend on the project, but authorized Williams to restart construction. Williams told Gurkin to resume full operations. Gurkin poured the new building's 11,900 square foot foundation. From this evidence, a reasonable juror could infer that the parties' intention was that a specific cost figure was not an essential term of their contract, but that a new building of the type and high quality that Dr. Roussalis would build was.
In early August, 1995, the architects delivered the final design drawings, plans and specifications to Gurkin, who immediately distributed bid packages to various subcontractors. On August 21, based on the subcontractors' bids, Gurkin had a cost estimate of $3,547,791 for the new building. Gurkin gave this information to WMC's Williams. Over the next several weeks these various parties met and discussed the estimate, cost-cutting, and other possible arrangements. In early September, Williams contacted the "cost reviewer" as we earlier described.
Late in September, the parties met and discussed rescission of the contract. The parties dispute the outcome of these discussions. But, from the fact that they discussed rescission, a reasonable juror could infer that the parties believed they had contracted earlier. Various WMC representatives made settlement overtures to the doctors after the rescission discussions.
On October 5, 1995, WMC held a press conference at which it issued a prepared statement which included the announcement that the parties' agreement "has been cancelled." It also stated:
(WMC) took a good faith business risk in proceeding with the construction of the (doctors') new office building prior to having the final cost determined, in order to facilitate the construction schedule of the new hospital and to take advantage of the favorable bond market. The ultimate cost of the proposed clinic was too high to proceed, and the decision was made to take the loss associated with abandoning the property exchange, and instead alter the location of the new hospital.
So, in lieu of westward expansion, WMC would expand southward, engulfing the site intended for the doctor's new office building.
From this post-Letter of Intent conduct, a reasonable juror could infer that the parties achieved mutual assent and definiteness in their exchange transaction, but WMC ultimately backed out because of the high cost. We find genuine issues of material fact for the trier of fact to resolve.
In addition to arguing that the parties' failure to include a "cost" term in their alleged contract was fatal to their achieving mutual assent on the new building's cost, WMC argues there was not even mutual assent on an objective standard by which cost could be determined, or when or how cost was to be determined.
WMC claims that the Letter of Intent "simply states that the new building is to be 'comparable' to the Roussalis building.... This is no standard at all." According to WMC, the doctors "interpret the comparability provision to mean the new building was to be of the highest quality, without limitation, regardless of cost." WMC characterizes the doctors' approach with these words, "they brought in an interior designer, which you don't do if you're concerned about cost." WMC also believes that the "Section 1031 exchange" nature of the transaction provided some measure of protection against uncontrolled costs. WMC claims that the law treats as too indefinite for legal enforcement a term which gives one party to a contract an unlimited right to determine the nature and extent of performance. WMC claims that the "comparability" provision of the Letter of Intent as interpreted by the doctors, is just such an indefinite term.
About WMC's argument that the "comparability" standard in the Letter of Intent is no standard at all, the doctors respond that WMC agreed to this subjective standard in order to induce the doctors to sign the Letter of Intent. In support of this response, the doctors point to WMC's own words, as conveyed by its counsel Williams, to the "cost reviewer" in early September, 1995, that the new building "would be the type of building that Dr. Roussalis would build if he were building a building of the same type of state-of-the-art quality (technologically and aesthetically)" as he built ten years earlier. Williams emphasized that this "Dr. Roussalis transaction concept" was "a different concept than a straight replacement building, where the limits are clear that only those features that are in the current building may be included in the new building.... (This was the essence of our agreement." The doctors' legal authority in support of this subjective standard is Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 34 (1981).1
According to the doctors, the law allows the parties to a contract to give one of them a large choice of what performance that party may demand or must accept, and a term is not too indefinite that provides one party's performance must be satisfactory to the other party. 17A Am. Jur.2d, Contracts § 199, at 210; § 648, at 655-56 (1991). The doctors also respond that WMC's actions and words as design and construction of the new building proceeded through spring and summer of 1995 obviated any objection of indefiniteness. Id., § 198 at 209.
In analyzing the parties' respective positions on this particular point, we have consulted several authorities. Corbin provides some guidance. For example, he counsels:
The courts must take cognizance of the fact that the argument that a particular agreement is too indefinite to constitute a contract frequently is an afterthought excuse for attacking an agreement that failed for reasons other than the indefiniteness. In such instances, the court should not be too fussy to determine how the gaps should have been filled. It is simply unnecessary.
(T)hat the parties have left some matters to be determined in the future should not prevent enforcement, if some method of determination independent of a party's mere "wish, will and desire" exists, either by virtue of the agreement itself or by commercial practice or other usage or custom. This may be the case, even though the determination is left to one of the contracting parties, if this party is required to make it "in good faith" in accordance with some existing standard or with facts capable of objective proof.
1 Joseph M. Perillo, Corbin on Contracts § 4.1, at 535-37 (rev. ed.1998). Corbin also comments on the effect of part performance of an indefinite contract:
That one of (the parties), with the knowledge and approval of the other, has begun performance is nearly always evidence that they regard the contract as consummated and intend to be bound thereby. It may also aid in the interpretation of their words with respect to the character of the performances to be rendered. In this way, the indefiniteness may be cured, or at least reduced. The fair and just solution may then be the enforcement of promises rather than a decision that no contract exists.
Id. at 542; and see § 4.7 at 606-13. Acknowledging that an agreement which provides that the performance to be rendered shall be left to the will or discretion of one of the parties has been held not enforceable, Corbin also observes "that one of the parties reserves the power of fixing or varying the price or other performance is not fatal if the exercise of this power is subject to prescribed or implied limitations, as that the variation must be in proportion to some objectively determined base or must be reasonable or in good faith." Id., § 4.4, at 586-87.
Professor Farnsworth counsels that, in deciding whether the requirement of definiteness has been met, a court would first interpret the language of the contract, and might next consider the parties' preliminary negotiations and references to external sources of terms, including trade and other standard terms. I Farnsworth, supra, § 3.28, at 356. He also observes
(a)n agreement may be fleshed out by usages to which the parties are subject, by a course of dealing between the parties prior to their agreement, or by a course of performance between them after their agreement. Indefiniteness may also be cured by the addition of such implied terms as will be supplied by law, including—at least as to minor items—the parties' implied obligations of good faith and fair dealing.
Id. at 357.
We note here that, under Wyoming law, every contract is deemed to contain an implied term of good faith and fair dealing. See, Garner v. Hickman, 709 P.2d 407, 411 (Wyo.1985), and cases cited therein; Kahn v. Traders Insurance Co., 4 Wyo. 419, 471, 34 P. 1059, 1075 (1893). We see no reason why that would not be true in this case. Finally, Professor Farnsworth counsels, "(a) host of opinions can be found to support the proposition that less definiteness is required to support an award of damages than a decree of specific performance." I Farnsworth, supra, § 3.28 at 361. In this case, the doctors seek an award of money damages, not a decree of specific performance.
In light of the above and foregoing authorities, we have concluded that WMC's argument, that the parties failed to achieve mutuality of assent on an objective standard by which cost could be determined, must be tested by the trier of fact. A reasonable juror could find from the evidence that, just as the parties may have intended not to have a specific "cost" term as an essential term of their agreement, they intended not to have an objective standard for determining specific cost. As the doctors point out, there is evidence from which a reasonable juror could infer that WMC expressly agreed to a subjective standard. WMC's own words in its September 5 letter to its "cost reviewer" are strong evidence of a "Dr. Roussalis" standard. The provisions in the Letter of Intent which speak of exterior and interior quality, of the doctors' approval of architectural and engineering drawings, of high quality features on the representative Exhibit A list, of a state-of-the-art computer system, and of WMC's buy-back guarantee of the greater of $1.25 million or the actual cost of the new building are also evidence of an intentional subjective standard. That juror could also turn WMC's own logic against it because WMC agreed to having interior design and woodworking experts in charge of and directing the interior quality. If one does not have such experts when there is concern about costs, WMC's agreement to having them on the project speaks loudly against WMC's litigious position. That juror may find evidentiary value in WMC's actions upon receiving in mid-July Mr. Gurkin's "guess" of a construction cost of $2.6 million. Rather than insisting on a need to establish and apply an objective standard for determining cost, WMC authorized Mr. Gurkin to resume construction, knowing that the doctors were working on the design drawings, plans and specifications as the Letter of Intent directed them to do.
A reasonable juror may also determine that the doctors' legal obligation of good faith and fair dealing and the Section 1031 nature of the exchange serve to contain the doctors' exercise of discretion under the "Dr. Roussalis" standard within reason; we think those factors are worthy of the juror's consideration. We are satisfied that evidence exists from which a reasonable juror could find a sufficiently definite standard by which to measure the doctors' performance. For all of the above and foregoing reasons, we hold that genuine issues of material fact regarding contract formation exist in this record.
II. Whether Alleged Oral Modifications to the Alleged Letter of Intent Agreement Fail for Lack of Consideration.
WMC asserts that alleged oral modifications of the alleged agreement, namely, the expansion of the size of the building from 9,500 square feet to about 11,900 square feet and the addition of many special features beyond the list on Exhibit A attached to the Letter of Intent, fail for lack of consideration. Hopper v. All Pet Animal Clinic, Inc., 861 P.2d 531, 540 (Wyo.1993); Willard Given & Assoc.'s, P.C. v. First Wyo. Bank, 706 P.2d 247, 251 (Wyo.1985); Harvard v. Anderson, 524 P.2d 880, 883 (Wyo.1974). WMC correctly states that this Court follows the "pre-existing duty rule," namely, an agreement to do what one is already bound to do cannot serve as consideration to support a modification. See Brodie v. General Chemical Corp., 934 P.2d 1263, 1268 (Wyo.1997); Harvard, 524 P.2d at 883; Long v. Forbes, 58 Wyo. 533, 548-49, 136 P.2d 242, 246-47 (1943). WMC claims that the doctors provided no new consideration to support the square footage increase or the many special features they added after the parties signed the Letter of Intent. Without new consideration to support these modifications, WMC reasons, the modifications were invalid and fail.
Earlier in this opinion, we stated the facts and circumstances surrounding the square footage increase of the building size and noted that in the Letter of Intent the parties expressly stated that the list of specific features shown on Exhibit A attached to the Letter of Intent was representative, but "not meant to be exhaustive ... of the types of high quality features which the new facility will incorporate." With these facts and circumstances in mind, we will analyze the parties' contentions concerning whether there was consideration to support these modifications.
In response to WMC's claim that the addition of many special features beyond the representative list on Exhibit A attached to the Letter of Intent was not supported by new consideration, the doctors answer that, in the Letter of Intent, the parties specifically provided for the addition of special features as the design and construction of the building progressed. Implicit in this answer would seem to be the point that new consideration was unnecessary to support the addition of special features expressly anticipated or contemplated by the parties in the original agreement. In other words, the additional special features, provided for in the original agreement, are deemed supported by the consideration which supported the original agreement. We think that logically follows, and WMC offers no authority to the contrary. Moreover, the doctors maintain that the additional features were discussed with WMC's representatives Carriger and Williams, who supported the additions because WMC (1) received the benefit of promoting the new state-of-the-art building for WMC's organizing efforts with its visionary Wyoming Integrated Network, a state-wide association of hospitals and physicians, with WMC at its hub; and (2) would re-acquire the building in the future, pursuant to the buy-back provision in the Letter of Intent, and therefore would benefit from the additional special features.
With respect to WMC's claim that the building size increase was also not supported by new consideration, the doctors maintain that WMC knew of and expressly approved the increase and received its benefits because of the probability that WMC would re-acquire the building in the future. In this regard, we recall the facts and circumstances of WMC's knowledge of and involvement in this size increase, and in particular WMC's October 5, 1995, prepared statement to media representatives in which WMC explained the size increase to the public and stated that the "additional space would be useful" when WMC re-acquired the property. The doctors correctly observe that, of the many definitions given for consideration, one of them recognized by this Court is "a benefit to the promisor or a detriment to the promisee." Laibly v. Halseth, 345 P.2d 796, 799 (Wyo.1959); Moorcroft State Bank v. Morel, 701 P.2d 1159, 1162 (Wyo.1985).
We are inclined to agree with the doctors' argument. With respect to the additional special features, we find that the parties contemplated and provided for them in the Letter of Intent; new consideration was unnecessary to support them. But even if new consideration were necessary, the benefits accruing to WMC from these additional special features constitute consideration. With respect to the building size increase, we hold that WMC received a benefit from this increase and that benefit constituted consideration.
Even if the benefit received by WMC did not constitute consideration for the building size modification, we would find an appropriate and applicable exception to the "pre-existing duty rule" in Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 89, at 237 (1981). See Wilder v. Cody Country Chamber of Commerce, 868 P.2d 211, 219 (Wyo.1994). That section states in pertinent part:
A promise modifying a duty under a contract not fully performed on either side is binding (a) if the modification is fair and equitable in view of circumstances not anticipated by the parties when the contract was made.
Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 89, at 237. Whether a modification is fair and equitable goes beyond the absence of coercion and requires an objectively demonstrable reason for seeking a modification. Id. at § 89 cmt. b, at 238. The reason for modification must rest in circumstances not anticipated when the contract was made. Id. When such a reason is present, the relative financial strength of the parties, the formality with which the modification is made, the extent to which it is performed or relied on, and other circumstances may be relevant to show or negate imposition or unfair surprise. Id. Recalling Dr. Roussalis' testimony and architect Trice's letter to WMC explaining the reasons for the building size increase, we conclude that the facts and circumstances surrounding the size modification were not anticipated by the parties when they signed the Letter of Intent. Recalling from the relevant portion of the statement of facts that WMC approved of the size modification and cooperated with the doctors in making the modification, that WMC's site plan agreement with the City of Casper called for an 11,838 square foot building, that WMC authorized Mr. Gurkin to pour an 11,900 square foot foundation, and that Mr. Gurkin in fact poured that foundation, we must conclude that the size modification was fair and equitable. All of the facts and circumstances surrounding this modification negate imposition or unfair surprise.
III. Whether Alleged Oral Modifications of the Alleged Letter of Intent Agreement are Barred by the Statute of Frauds.
WMC contends there is no written agreement signed by it which (1) increases the size of the doctors' building from 9,500 square feet, as written in the Letter of Intent, to nearly 11,900 square feet, as now expected by the doctors; (2) changes the "full roughed-in basement," as written in the Letter of Intent, to a full finished basement, as now expected by the doctors; and (3) adds numerous special features in the building, such as basement air conditioning, motion sensor lighting, a nurse call system, brick pavers, and car block heaters, to name only a few, as now expected by the doctors. Because these alleged modifications to the Letter of Intent were orally made, if at all, and not made in writings signed by WMC, WMC claims they are barred by the statute of frauds. Wyo. Stat. Ann. § 1-23-105 (LEXIS 1999).
WMC asserts that the May 22, 1995, site plan application and the July 18, 1995, site plan agreement which reference an 11,838 square foot building, are merely evidence of the terms of a subsequent parol modification of the Letter of Intent which evidence is inadmissible to prove a written modification of the Letter of Intent, citing North American Uranium, Inc. v. Johnston, 77 Wyo. 332, 316 P.2d 325, 335 (1957) (citing 32 C.J.S. § 1005, 1011). WMC also contends the doctors' "documents" do not reference the numerous new features which the doctors have added to the building. WMC argues that Williams' July 21, 1995, letter to Gurkin, the doctors' representative, which instructed him to resume construction operations, "is not written confirmation of the alleged oral agreement." According to WMC, that letter does not mention either increased building size or the additional special features. WMC argues that these alleged modifications of increased size, finished basement, and additional features must be in a writing signed by WMC because the alleged agreement was one for the transfer of real estate and one which could not be performed within one year of its making, the Letter of Intent being signed in March 1995 and Gurkin confirming he had fifteen months in which to build the building. Wyo. Stat. Ann. § 1-23-105(a)(i) and (v) (LEXIS 1999). WMC maintains that the regrettable situation in which it and the doctors find themselves is the result of mistakes and misunderstandings, and the purpose of the statute of frauds is to guard against just such a situation.
In response to WMC's argument, the doctors claim that the requirements of the statute of frauds have been satisfied to the extent the agreement sought to be enforced by them falls within the statute of frauds. Thus, they point out that, to the extent the agreement at issue is one for the sale or transfer of land, three particular writings signed by WMC's authorized agent contain a sufficient description of the land involved. These writings are the Letter of Intent, WMC's site plan application, and WMC's site plan agreement with the City of Casper. The Letter of Intent contains legal descriptions of both properties to be exchanged. WMC's site plan agreement contains a legal description of WMC's property on which the proposed office building was to be built and describes an "11,838 square foot medical office complex on a land site of 38,594 square feet." Clearly, the alleged oral modifications do not purport to modify the land involved. They do purport to modify the size of the building to be built on that land, the nature of the finish of the full basement of that building, and the kind of special features to be included in that building.
Neither party directs our attention to authority on the precise question which emerges from this situation, namely, whether these particular oral modifications are of such nature that they must be in writing signed by WMC. Our own research reveals the existence of a general rule that if an original agreement was required to comply with the statute of frauds, any material modification of that agreement must also conform to the statute of frauds. Allen v. Kingdon, 723 P.2d 394, 396-97 (Utah 1986). As to be expected, there are recognized exceptions to that general rule. One exception is
where a party has changed position by performing an oral modification so that it would be inequitable to permit the other party to found a claim or defense on the original agreement as unmodified,
Id. at 396. See also, Quirin v. Weinberg, 252 Mont. 386, 830 P.2d 537, 541 (1992); Crandell v. Resley, 804 P.2d 272, 275 (Colo.App.1990); Mikesell v. Newworld Dev. Corp., 122 Idaho 868, 840 P.2d 1090, 1095 (App.1992); Siegner v. Interstate Prod. Credit Ass'n, 109 Or.App. 417, 820 P.2d 20, 30 (1991); Kirk v. Tomulty, 66 Wash.App. 231, 831 P.2d 792, 796 (1992). This particular exception seems appropriately applicable to the alleged oral modification of the size of the building from 9,500 square feet to 11,900 square feet.
From our earlier statement of the facts, we recall that sometime in March, 1995, Carriger approved an increase in the square footage of the medical office building from about 9,500 square feet to about 11,900 square feet. Several pieces of evidence bear this out and explain the increase. In his deposition, WMC's Williams testified that Carriger "told me that he had approved the addition of a connecting space in between ... the doctors' suites and the rental suites." In his deposition, Dr. Roussalis testified that Carriger had approved the size increase, explaining that a substantial amount of the increase, about 1,100 to 1,300 square feet, was the result of enclosing the connecting space and was driven by safety considerations. According to Dr. Roussalis, early in the design drawing phase the architects (Anderson De Bartolo Pan) and the doctors realized that the unenclosed connecting space would cause a wind tunnel effect which was considered dangerous. The solution arrived at was to enclose the space; that enclosed area became an atrium or walkway. The remaining amount of size increase was attributable to some necessary changes in the tenant area and the addition of a canopy. The site plan agreement between WMC and the City of Casper, dated July 18, 1995, references an 11,838 square foot building. Mr. Gurkin's letter to WMC's Williams dated July 19, 1995, references an 11,900 square foot building. Upon receiving WMC's authorization to resume construction on July 19, 1995, Mr. Gurkin poured an 11,900 square foot foundation. In a letter to Williams dated August 25, 1995, Peter Trice, of the architectural firm Anderson DeBartolo Pan, explained the size increase in this way:
Program Issues
In our letter to Mike Gurkin dated February 28, 1995 (copy attached), we had reviewed the building program with respect to the tenant spaces. This document identifies the rationale for increasing the building's tenant spaces from 8,500 sf to 9,890 sf. During the design process, certain program elements were added such as:
Toilet, Mrs. Roussalis' Office 30 sf.
Exams Rooms Enlarged 80 sf.
Mrs. Youmans' Office Enlarged 25 sf.
One Procedure Room Enlarged 30 sf.
Staff Lounge Enlarged 25 sf.
Total 250 sf.
x 1.85 337 sf.
The final build program for tenant spaces was therefore 10,227 sf. (9,890 + 337). The actual design required 10,188 sf to accommodate these services. This is less than .5% variance from the program.
The remaining square footage is for building circulation and support space.
Stairs 370 sf.
Elevator 60 sf.
Lobby 1,194 sf.
Typically, multiple tenant medical office buildings require 20-25% additional square footage to allow for building support space, circulation and mechanical spaces. For this clinic, the final design required an additional 1,624 sf. or about 16% (excluding the mechanical space located in the basement). When this number is added to the revised tenant space program, the gross building square footage equals 11,812 sf. extremely close to the final design amount of 11,800 sf.
In a prepared statement dated October 5, 1995, which WMC issued to media representatives, WMC explained the size increase:
As the design progressed, the size of the building was increased, to take into account the requirements of the Americans With Disabilities Act and a pilot computerization project, as well as increased common areas which arose as a result of combining medical offices. Additionally, WMC agreed to a full basement, since there appeared to be at that time a probability that WMC would in the future re-acquire the property, and that additional space would be useful. The final size of the building was 11,800 square feet, with a full basement.
Finally, in his affidavit dated November 13, 1995, WMC's Williams stated, in relevant part:
After signing the Letter of Intent, WMC cooperated with (the doctors) by, among other things, expanding the size of the New Building beyond the 9,500 square feet provided for in the Letter of Intent, to 11,900 square feet.
Not only are there writings signed by WMC which evidence that size increase, but there is evidence that WMC expressly authorized Gurkin, the doctors' agent, to pour an 11,900 square foot foundation. Indeed, that foundation was poured and existed in the ground. That performance exclusively referable to the alleged agreement must certainly be considered sufficient to exempt it from the effect of the statute of frauds. Ryan v. Earl, 618 P.2d 54, 56 (Utah 1980). The construction of an 11,900 square foot foundation alone and without the aid of words of agreement is extraordinary unless as an incident of agreement. See Burns v. McCormick, 233 N.Y. 230, 135 N.E. 273 (1922). And see Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 139 (1981).2
In passing, we recall what we wrote in B & W Glass, Inc. v. Weather Shield Mfg., Inc., 829 P.2d 809, 819 (Wyo.1992), in the course of holding that under Wyoming law an oral promise otherwise within the statute of frauds declared in Wyo. Stat. Ann. § 34.1-2-201 (1991) (goods) and the Uniform Commercial Code may be enforceable on the basis of promissory estoppel. We said this Court "has accepted a role of leadership in invoking equitable principles to avoid injustice." Id. at 818. After touching on our precedent in this regard and quoting Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 139 (1981), we noted our approval of the use of promissory estoppel, as phrased in the Restatement (Second), to avoid the general statute of frauds. Remilong v. Crolla, 576 P.2d 461, 465 (Wyo.1978) (buyers of land could enforce an oral promise from the seller that all trailers would be removed from adjacent lands). Eschewing the concern of the 17th Century English courts "that a writing is the sole method to avoid undetected (perjury)," we confidently asserted that "(o)ur judicial system is capable of discerning perjury and reaching a determination in an instance in which a litigant establishes promissory estoppel by appropriately assuming his burden." B & W Glass, Inc., 829 P.2d at 819. Our interest in invoking equitable principles to avoid injustice remains steadfast today.
There is evidence here which explains that construction problems unforeseen by the parties in March, 1995, before the design drawings, plans and specifications were prepared were responsible for the size increase. Although WMC raises some question whether Carriger agreed to the size modification, its own representative Williams testified that Carriger did. In any event, this is an issue which can be better resolved at trial.
With respect to the alleged oral modification of the building's special features, we must observe that the Letter of Intent expressly covered the topic of specific features to be incorporated into the design and construction of the building, listing them on Exhibit A to the Letter of Intent and stating that the list was representative, but not exhaustive of the types of high quality features to be incorporated into the building. We do not believe that the additional features which WMC wants to treat as an oral modification should be considered such in light of the express provision in the Letter of Intent. Rather, this subject is better left to be treated as a disputed issue of material fact, that is to say, what did the parties intend with respect to those additional features which might be incorporated into the building.
With respect to the alleged oral modification of the full roughed-in basement to a full finished basement, we believe that is a construction detail also better left to be treated as a disputed issue of material fact to be resolved at trial. Obviously, as we have noted earlier in this opinion, the nature of the parties' agreement was unique because, as Gurkin described it, the project was being designed and built simultaneously and on a fast track. Under such circumstances, it is foreseeable that design and construction details may change and such changes do not readily lend themselves to comply with the strict requirements of a writing. A similar situation arose in Petrie v. Spooner, 145 Ark. 138, 223 S.W. 383 (1920), where in a written contract Spooner agreed to build and convey to Petrie a house on a lot owned by Spooner according to plans to be approved by Petrie, but later a dispute arose concerning numerous changes and additions made during construction which Spooner claimed Petrie had approved; in answer to Petrie's contention that the oral modification violated the statute of frauds and he could not be held for the changes or additions to the plans, the court stated:
(I)t may be said that the writing evidencing the contract to sell the land does not prescribe what the plans of the building shall be. Upon the contrary, it expressly recites the fact to be that the plans had not been then prepared, but were to be subsequently prepared and approved; so that this written contract cannot be conclusive of the plans according to which the building was to be constructed, and the statute of frauds does not apply to the building contract. It was not essential that there be a written contract approving the plans for the building, and it was therefore permissible for the parties to modify or alter these plans without evidencing that modification or alteration in writing.
Id. at 385.
Upon the record before us, we conclude that these alleged oral modifications are not within the statute of frauds. We also conclude that disputed issues of material fact as to these alleged oral modifications exist and must be resolved at trial.
IV. Whether the Alleged Letter of Intent Agreement is Unconscionable.
WMC's assertion that the Letter of Intent was unconscionable at the time it was made and thereafter rests on the estimated construction cost of the new building, which Gurkin reported at $3,547,791 after receiving subcontractors' bids in late August, 1995, which estimate cost allegedly resulted from the combined oppressive effect of both the presence and absence of certain provisions in the Letter of Intent. Specifically, WMC points to the absence of a provision capping construction costs; the presence of open-ended provisions establishing a comparability standard for the new building and unchecked discretion in the doctors as to exterior and interior design, furnishings, and equipment; and the presence of a buy-back provision giving the doctors the opportunity, by running up costs, to increase the buy-back price WMC would pay. WMC claims that the resulting construction cost unfairly surprised WMC and made the contemplated property exchange grossly unequal, both of which are indices of unconscionability.
Although WMC's focus is on the oppressive nature of and the unfair surprise caused by these items, and not on unequal bargaining power, it asserts in passing that if unequal bargaining power were the issue, the doctors "had the upper hand" because they knew that WMC needed their property for hospital expansion, refused a cost cap provision, and agreed to open-ended provisions which they later interpreted as giving them unlimited discretion over design and cost.
Without supporting authority, WMC asserts that who proposed the allegedly unconscionable provisions is beside the point. In closing, WMC candidly reminds us that the question of unconscionability is one of law for the court, but that the court should be cautious in holding an agreement unconscionable.
Responding to WMC's argument, the doctors refer us to our leading case of Matter of Estate of Frederick, 599 P.2d 550, 556 (Wyo.1979), in which we discussed and applied, in the context of a filling station lease with an option to purchase, the relevant considerations in the identification of unconscionability. Based upon this, and similar authority, the doctors assert that a cursory review of the facts reveals the baseless nature of WMC's argument. In this regard, the doctors note that it was WMC, not them, which proposed the buy-back provision; the doctors did not reject the cost cap concept, but made it clear to WMC that they wanted to see the new building's design before they would agree to a cost cap; WMC did not want to wait the four to six month period for design drawings to be prepared and freely chose to proceed without a cost figure, thus bearing the risk of a higher-than-expected construction cost and corresponding buy-back cost. The doctors characterize WMC's argument as an allegation, which they deny, that they breached an obligation of good faith by "running up the cost" of the building to benefit themselves on the buy-back obligation. They claim this allegation presents issues of fact best suited for a jury. Like WMC, the doctors close their argument by reminding us that judges have been cautious in applying the doctrine of unconscionability.
We hold, as a matter of law, for the reasons which follow, that WMC's contention of unconscionability lacks merit. That we must exercise caution in our resolution of this issue is because we "recognize the basic right of persons, real and artificial, to freely enter into contracts." Sinclair Oil Corp. v. Columbia Cas. Co., 682 P.2d 975, 978 (Wyo.1984). Our reluctance to redraw or nullify the provisions of a contract made by competent parties draws strength from the eloquent statement from the United States Supreme Court which we favorably quoted in Sinclair Oil Corp.:
"The right of private contract is no small part of the liberty of the citizen, and that the usual and most important function of courts of justice is rather to maintain and enforce contracts, than to enable parties thereto to escape from their obligation on the pretext of public policy, unless it clearly appear that they contravene public right or the public welfare. It was well said by Sir George Jessel, MR., in Printing & Co. v. Sampson, L.R. 19 Eq. 465: 'It must not be forgotten that you are not to extend arbitrarily those rules which say that a given contract is void as being against public policy, because if there is one thing which more than another public policy requires it is that men of full age and competent understanding shall have the utmost liberty of contracting, and that their contracts, when entered into freely and voluntarily, shall be held sacred, and shall be enforced by courts of justice. Therefore, you have this paramount public policy to consider—that you are not lightly to interfere with this freedom of contract.'"
Id. at 978-79 (quoting Baltimore & Ohio Southwestern Railway Co. v. Voigt, 176 U.S. 498, 505, 20 S.Ct. 385, 387, 44 L.Ed. 560, 565 (1900)).
Our cases admit of the difficulty of defining unconscionability. See e.g., Svalina v. Split Rock Land and Cattle Co., 816 P.2d 878, 882 (Wyo.1991). Our cases repeat the various judicial definitions which other courts have offered and which give only the most general guidance on the meaning of the term. See, e.g., Estate of Frederick, 599 P.2d at 556.
Perhaps the better judgment is to confess, as the leading commentators have, that
(i)t is not possible to define unconscionability. It is not a concept, but a determination to be made in light of a variety of factors not unifiable into a formula.
1 James J. White and Robert S. Summers, Uniform Commercial Code § 4-3, at 218 (4th ed.1995). (Although the Uniform Commercial Code governs only transactions in goods, courts have applied its unconscionability provision, § 2-302, to other contracts either by analogy or as an expression of a general doctrine. I Farnsworth, supra § 4.28, at 497. See Wyo. Stat. Ann. § 34.1-2-302 (LEXIS 1999)).
Our leading case of Estate of Frederick, as well as Svalina which relied upon it, identified the approach and the various factors which we have considered in making a determination that an agreement is or is not unconscionable. These factors and others which we find appropriate have been identified by other courts and leading commentators. This Court, and most others, as well as leading commentators, test the contention "as of the time the agreement is made and not in accordance with hindsight." Estate of Frederick, 599 P.2d at 556, and see, White and Summers, supra, § 4-3, at 211. We consider the characteristics of the parties including age, education, intelligence, business acumen and experience. Estate of Frederick, 599 P.2d at 556. A leading commentator reports, "Courts have generally been chary about using the doctrine ... to protect merchants and similar professionals and have declined to apply the doctrine in favor of sophisticated corporations." I Farnsworth, supra, § 4.28, at 505-06; and see White and Summers, supra, § 4-9, at 237 (courts "have not generally been solicitous of business persons in the name of unconscionability"). For example, in Continental Airlines v. Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co., 819 F.2d 1519, 1527 (9th Cir.1987), in rejecting an airline's claim of unconscionability in connection with a contract for the purchase of aircraft, that court said "it makes little sense in the context of two large, legally sophisticated companies to invoke the ... doctrine." See also, AT & T v. New York City Human Resources Admin., 833 F.Supp. 962, 988-89 (S.D.N.Y.1993) and cases cited therein. We consider whether the allegedly aggrieved party has enjoyed the advice of legal counsel. Estate of Frederick, 599 P.2d at 556. "(N)umerous courts have considered the presence and advice of counsel to constitute circumstantial, if not conclusive, evidence that a contract is not unconscionable." Resource Management Co. v. Weston Ranch, 706 P.2d 1028, 1045 (Utah 1985); and see, Cryogenic Equipment, Inc. v. Southern Nitrogen, Inc., 490 F.2d 696, 699 (8th Cir.1974) (negotiators included knowledgeable commercial lawyer with eighteen years experience and an engineer with twenty-four years in management and production). We consider which party proposed the allegedly unconscionable provisions. Estate of Frederick, 599 P.2d at 556; Svalina, 816 P.2d at 882. As a matter of common sense and fairness, which party proposed an allegedly unconscionable provision is of legitimate concern to a court asked to exercise its equitable power. Because a court focuses on the relative fairness of the obligations assumed and is determining the presence vel non of one-sided terms which oppress or unfairly surprise an innocent party, we find it difficult to accept the notion that a party who proposes an allegedly unconscionable term can be viewed as an innocent party who is oppressed or unfairly surprised by a provision of its own making. See, e.g., Osgood v. Medical, Inc., 415 N.W.2d 896, 901-02 (Minn.App.1987) (terms not unconscionable where party asserting so provided them); Johnson v. Mobil Oil Corp., 415 F.Supp. 264, 268 (E.D.Mich.1976) (one of the variety of factors is who drafted the agreement). We also find it appropriate to consider whether both absence of meaningful choice and presence of contract provisions unreasonably favorable to the other party must be found to satisfy a claim of unconscionability. Leading commentators report that most courts require a quantum of both and take a balancing approach in applying them. White and Summers, supra, § 4-7, at 230-31; and see, Maxwell v. Fidelity Financial Services, Inc., 184 Ariz. 82, 907 P.2d 51, 58 (1995) ("Many courts, perhaps a majority, have held that there must be some quantum of both procedural and substantive unconscionability to establish a claim, and take a balancing approach in applying them"); and White and Summers, supra, § 4-9, at 242 ("In general, then, in the absence of procedural unconscionability (bargaining naughtiness or absence of meaningful choice), courts will not invalidate commercial contracts in the name of unconscionability"). In Estate of Frederick, we identified and applied in our analysis factors falling under the rubric of this so-called procedural unconscionability: deprivation of meaningful choice as to whether to enter into the contract, compulsion to accept terms, opportunity for meaningful negotiation, such gross inequality of bargaining power that negotiations were not possible, characteristics of alleged aggrieved party (underprivileged, uneducated, illiterate, easily taken advantage of), and surprise by fine print or concealed terms. Estate of Frederick, 599 P.2d at 556.
Having carefully considered WMC's argument in light of the record and the foregoing authority, we must reject its claim of unconscionability. The record does not support WMC's contention that the doctors enjoyed superior bargaining power, the so-called "upper hand." While it is true the doctors knew that WMC wanted their property for hospital expansion, it is also true that WMC, before giving them this knowledge, had explored its available options of expanding either westwardly in the doctors' direction or southwardly in the direction it ultimately selected when the deal with the doctors began to collapse. It was WMC that freely chose to approach the doctors, who initially did not want to sell their properties, and convinced them that they were standing in the way of what was best for WMC. WMC envisioned transforming itself into a regional medical center working in partnership with an integrated network of doctors. It proposed to build the doctors a state-of-the-art medical office building as a showcase for WMC's integrated network vision. It was WMC that determined the greatest cost savings would be realized by westwardly expansion. It was WMC that pressed for negotiations with the doctors. At all times WMC was represented by its chief executive officer, informed board members, and experienced legal counsel. The record shows that that legal counsel in an early September, 1995, letter, explained about the absence of a cost cap provision:
The physicians would not sign any type of agreement with a dollar limitation in it until a complete set of plans and specifications were generated and approved. Because of WMC's desire to proceed on the revenue bonding process prior to those plans being completed, and the necessity that the land be under contract prior to issuing the bonds (for rating and bond insurance purposes), the decision was made to leave the agreement open-ended.
(Emphasis added). The record further shows that WMC's October, 1995, press release stated, "(WMC) took a good faith business risk in proceeding with the construction of the new office building prior to having the final cost determined, in order to facilitate the construction schedule of the new hospital and to take advantage of the favorable bond market." We are aware that there are elements of risk in any contract. Estate of Frederick, 599 P.2d at 556. It has been rightly said:
The policy underlying that rule (unconscionability cannot be demonstrated by hindsight) is that virtually all contracts involve the assessment of risks. How fast, if at all, will land values rise over the next ten years? Are interest rates likely to increase, decrease, or remain constant? Is a particular venture likely to be a wild success or an abysmal failure? ... Assessment of such risk is intrinsic to the process of contracting and affects the terms on which contracts are entered into.
To judge the substantive fairness of contracts at a date subsequent to their making could nullify many contracts entailing a speculative element.
Resource Management Co., 706 P.2d at 1043.
The record shows WMC is a sophisticated business entity and was represented by experienced negotiators, including experienced legal counsel, and that they negotiated with the doctors over many weeks. The record does not show WMC was compelled to accept provisions but rather enjoyed meaningful negotiation and freely proposed the provisions it would now challenge. We have no difficulty in concluding that WMC had the unfettered choice to either assent to the alleged agreement, negotiate modifications to its provisions, or simply walk away from the doctors as easily as it had first walked toward them in the early days of 1995.
Because we do not find that WMC was deprived of meaningful choice in any sense of that concept, we need not dwell long considering WMC's contention that the combined effect of both the presence and absence of certain provisions resulted in an unfair, one-sided agreement which produced an excessive construction cost which unfairly surprised WMC and made the contemplated property exchange grossly unequal. White and Summers, supra, § 4-7, at 230-31; § 4-9, at 242; Maxwell, 907 P.2d at 58. As we noted earlier, the record shows, as the doctors claim, that WMC both provided, and freely deleted, some of the provisions it would now challenge. It is, therefore, in a poor position to now claim it is an innocent party which is unfairly surprised. Although WMC complains of the excessive construction cost estimate which Gurkin calculated in August, 1995, after receiving subcontractors' bids based upon finally available design drawings, plans and specifications, the record shows it was reasonably foreseeable to WMC that the construction cost estimate would be high. It was, after all, WMC that insisted on the atypical way in which this construction project proceeded. WMC knew, as Gurkin discussed with it early on, that most projects are typically drawn and designed a year before they are bid. Gurkin said to WMC, "get the plans drawn, let me give you a price, and then build the building." Gurkin asked WMC's legal counsel, to no avail, "if it wouldn't be better to delay actual construction of the building until the design and specifications were finalized, so that a cost estimate could be prepared." But WMC pushed for a June, 1996, completion date because that date, in WMC's judgment, "was critical timing in the building schedule of the new hospital (in order to avoid building over two full winters)." It is common knowledge that in major projects construction costs are difficult to manage. Surely, that difficulty must be exacerbated when the project is designed and built on the fly against a compressed time schedule as this one was. Moreover, the record shows that WMC knew that one of the doctors had built "a very nice and very expensive" ($182 per square foot) office building ten years earlier. Inflation is a commonly known element of risk in any contract. Estate of Frederick, 599 P.2d at 556. It was reasonably foreseeable to WMC that the new building would be more costly than the building constructed ten years earlier. By mid-April, 1995, a week before WMC at a press conference announced the hospital expansion project and the doctors' new medical office building project, WMC had in hand Gurkin's rough preliminary estimate of a $2.1 million construction cost based upon a 9,850 square foot building, or about $215 per square foot, apparently not counting the full basement. At that time WMC also knew that the size of the building had increased from 9,850 square feet to 11,900 square feet because Carriger and the doctors had agreed to it in March. Knowing in mid-April, then, of a $215 per square foot estimate and of an 11,900 square foot building, WMC reasonably should have known that a rough estimate of the construction cost would be around $2.5 million, apparently not counting a full basement. If a construction cost of $45 per square foot were applied to an 11,900 square foot full basement (as Gurkin estimated in his July, 1995, letter to WMC), that results in an additional $500,000 roughly, for a total rough estimate of $3 million. Thus, in the early days after the agreement was made, it was reasonably foreseeable to WMC that construction costs were going to be high. This was brought to WMC's attention again in mid-July, 1995, when Gurkin gave WMC his "guesstimate" of $2.6 million. He informed WMC that this "guesstimate" could grow another $500,000 roughly depending on increases of $5,000 each on fifty-four substantial items ($270,000) and an override of 5% to 10% for changes (10% of $2.8 million is $280,000; add that figure to $2.8 million estimate, for a total rough estimate of $3 million). Having this information in July, 1995, the WMC board heard its board member Dallas Laird comment to the effect that "we knew that this was going to be an expensive building," and then WMC authorized Gurkin to pour an 11,900 square foot foundation and resume construction operations.
In analyzing this matter, it is also important to keep in mind that WMC reaped a substantial benefit almost immediately upon the parties' execution of the agreement. That execution of the agreement paved the way for WMC to secure its revenue bond financing at a favorable interest rate for the hospital expansion construction project. In May, in succession the county commissioners approved proceeding with the revenue bond issue, the WMC board and the hospital's trustees approved a resolution authorizing the bond issue, and the county commissioners approved the bonds. In early June, 1995, the $31.8 million revenue bond issue was finalized and the trustee of the bond funds received the proceeds. WMC's actions of using the doctors' Letter of Intent agreement to secure this substantial benefit and later repudiating that same document runs dangerously close to violating the long-recognized principle that a party to a contract cannot rely upon part of the contract and repudiate the rest to the prejudice of another party to that contract. McKenzie v. Neale Const. Co., Inc., 75 Wyo. 175, 186, 294 P.2d 355, 359 (1956).
Having carefully considered WMC's argument in light of the record and the foregoing factors, we must reject its claim that the alleged agreement is an unfair, one-sided agreement that produced an excessive construction cost which unfairly surprised WMC and made the contemplated property exchange grossly unequal.
V. Whether the Parties Formed and Performed an Agreement of Rescission Cancelling the Alleged Letter of Intent Agreement.
WMC contends the record shows in mid-September, 1995, when the parties were at impasse over cuts to the $3.5 million cost estimate, the doctors orally offered to rescind the alleged Letter of Intent agreement if three conditions were satisfied by WMC; WMC accepted that offer; WMC shut down the project in reliance on the agreement of rescission; and WMC performed the three conditions contained in the doctors' offer. WMC asserts that a legally binding agreement of rescission resulted from these foregoing events.
Challenging WMC's assertion, the doctors contend the record shows that WMC never unconditionally assented to their oral offer; WMC did not unconditionally perform the three conditions of their offer; the doctors withdrew their offer before WMC accepted the offer and performed its conditions; and, in the days following the doctors' offer, WMC not only did not unconditionally perform the three conditions but it made, through various agents, several different settlement offers to the doctors, all of which belie WMC's assertion that a legally binding agreement of rescission was formed.
To be sure, Wyoming law recognizes that if an executory contract is within the Statute of Frauds and is in writing, a subsequent oral agreement to rescind the contract is effectual if that oral agreement fulfills the requisites of a contract at common law. Gaido v. Tysdal, 68 Wyo. 490, 505, 235 P.2d 741, 746 (1951); and see 10 Richard A. Lord, Williston on Contracts § 20:48, at 758 (4th ed.1999); Restatement (Second) of Contracts §§ 148 and 288 (1981). "An agreement of rescission is limited to the discharge of contract duties.... (C)onsideration is provided by each party's discharge of the other's remaining duties.... The agreement may even be inferred from conduct—like an implied-in-fact contract—if it indicates mutual abandonment." I E. Allen Farnsworth, Farnsworth on Contracts § 4.24, at 526-27 (2d ed.1998). We agree that
the validity of such an understanding to rescind is controlled by the same rules as in the case of other contracts.... (T)here must exist an offer by one party and an unconditional acceptance of that precise offer by the other, prior to withdrawal by the offeror, before a binding agreement is born.
Lemlich v. Bd. of Trustees of Harford Comm. College, 282 Md. 495, 385 A.2d 1185, 1189 (1978).
Our case law identifies the requisites of a contract. "An offer, acceptance, and consideration are the basic elements of a contract." Bouwens v. Centrilift, 974 P.2d 941, 946 (Wyo.1999) (quoting Miller v. Miller, 664 P.2d 39, 40 (Wyo.1983)). There must be mutual assent to the same terms. Bouwens, 974 P.2d at 946. The contracting process is usually straightforward. One party makes a manifestation of assent, called an offer, to another; the latter then makes a manifestation of assent, called an acceptance, to the former. Id. "Whether an oral contract exists, the terms and conditions of the oral contract and the intent of the parties are generally questions of fact." Wilder v. Cody Country Chamber of Commerce, 868 P.2d 211, 218 (Wyo.1994). Only when the offer, the terms of the offer, and the unconditional acceptance of the offer are shown without any conflict in the evidence does the interpretation of the contract become a question of law for the court. Id.; Engle v. First Nat'l Bank of Chugwater, 590 P.2d 826, 830 (Wyo.1979). With these requisites in mind, we proceed to examine the record to determine whether there is conflict in the evidence relating to these requisites.