139 S. Ct. 2484 (2019)
In 2016 the Republican-controlled North Carolina General Assembly enacted a new congressional districting plan after its mapmaker received instructions to produce a delegation of ten Republicans and three Democrats.1 The mapmaker relied on precinct-level election data to draw lines that would achieve this result.2 The plan passed the legislature on a party-line vote even after one Democratic senator objected that recent statewide vote totals made the split unfair.3
Republican candidates won ten of thirteen districts in the 2016 election under the plan and nine of twelve in 2018.4 In 2011 Democratic leaders in Maryland undertook to redraw the state's eight congressional districts.5 The Governor at the time, Democrat Martin O'Malley, led the process.6 He appointed a redistricting committee to help redraw the map, and asked Congressman Steny Hoyer, who has described himself as a serial gerrymanderer, to advise the committee.7
The Governor later testified that his aim was to use the redistricting process to change the overall composition of Maryland's congressional delegation to 7 Democrats and 1 Republican by flipping one district.8 A decision was made to go for the Sixth, which had been held by a Republican for nearly two decades.9 To achieve the required equal population among districts, only about 10,000 residents needed to be removed from that district.10 The 2011 Plan accomplished that by moving roughly 360,000 voters out of the Sixth District and moving 350,000 new voters in.11
Overall, the Plan reduced the number of registered Republicans in the Sixth District by about 66,000 and increased the number of registered Democrats by about 24,000.12 The map was adopted by a party-line vote.13 A Democrat has held the Sixth District seat in every election since 2012.14
Voters and nonprofit organizations in both states filed separate suits in federal district courts alleging that the respective plans violated the Equal Protection Clause, the First Amendment, the Elections Clause, and Article I, Section 2.15 After a four-day trial the three-judge district court in North Carolina ruled for the plaintiffs.16 After summary-judgment proceedings the three-judge district court in Maryland also ruled for the plaintiffs.17
The state defendants in each case appealed directly to the Supreme Court under 28 U.S.C. § 1253.18 The Court postponed jurisdiction in both appeals, heard argument in March 2019, and later vacated the district-court judgments with instructions to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction.19
Whether partisan gerrymandering claims present political questions beyond the reach of the federal courts?20
Under Article III, federal courts may decide only cases or controversies that are of a judiciary nature and that possess judicially discoverable and manageable standards for resolution, as established in Baker v. Carr; claims lacking such standards constitute nonjusticiable political questions committed to the political branches.21
Yes. The established facts describe highly partisan districting plans enacted by the North Carolina Republican legislature in 2016 and the Maryland Democratic legislature in 2011.22 Each plan was designed through the use of precinct-level election data to produce a predetermined partisan outcome.23 Each plan was approved on party-line votes.24 These facts present classic partisan gerrymandering claims alleging violations of the Equal Protection Clause, the First Amendment, the Elections Clause, and Article I, Section 2.25
The legal rule requires a limited, precise, clear, manageable, and politically neutral standard before a court may adjudicate such claims.26 No such standard exists.27 Every proposed test either demands judicial prediction of future election results, relies on indeterminate notions of fairness such as proportionality or the efficiency gap, or collapses into the very political judgments the Constitution assigns to state legislatures and Congress under the Elections Clause.28 The North Carolina plan's explicit 10-3 target and the Maryland plan's wholesale reconfiguration of the Sixth District illustrate the degree of partisan manipulation at issue.29 Yet the absence of any judicially enforceable limit means the claims remain political questions.30
Partisan gerrymandering claims present political questions beyond the reach of the federal courts, so the district court judgments must be vacated and the cases remanded with instructions to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction.31
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justices Ginsburg, Breyer, And Sotomayor
Justice Kagan's dissent maintains that the extreme gerrymanders in North Carolina and Maryland deliberately diluted the votes of hundreds of thousands of citizens to entrench one party.32 These gerrymanders violate the Equal Protection Clause and the First Amendment by depriving voters of equal participation and associational rights.33 The dissent argues that lower courts have converged on a neutral three-part test requiring proof of predominant partisan intent, substantial vote dilution measured against the state's own districting criteria and political geography, and the absence of a legitimate nonpartisan justification.34
This test is judicially manageable because it uses the state's own benchmarks rather than any judge-imposed vision of fairness.35 It invalidates only the most egregious outliers, as demonstrated by the thousands of randomly generated maps showing the North Carolina plan as an extreme deviation and the Maryland plan's reversal of the Sixth District's partisan composition.36 The dissent concludes that the majority's refusal to intervene abdicates the judicial duty to protect the fundamental right to vote when politicians have rigged the system against the people.37