695 N.W.2d 570 (Minn. 2005)
On January 27, 2001, Karen Schafer went to a Perkins Restaurant in St. Cloud, Minnesota, with a friend and their daughters.1 At the restaurant, Schafer ordered a pumpkin muffin. She unwrapped the muffin and, using her fork, placed a piece of the muffin in her mouth. Upon swallowing, she immediately felt a “sharp pain” in her throat and “a choking sensation.”2
After drinking some water and still feeling as though there was something stuck in her throat, Schafer went directly to a hospital emergency room.3 Before leaving the restaurant, Schafer’s friend notified a Perkins employee that, as a result of swallowing a piece of the muffin, Schafer was going to the emergency room. The rest of the muffin was not saved.4
At the hospital, a doctor told Schafer that she had a cut on her throat, but the doctor did not observe any object that would have caused the cut. Schafer was prescribed a painkiller and released. Two days later, she returned to the emergency room where she was diagnosed with a throat infection and was hospitalized for three days. According to Schafer, it took her about three months to fully recover. Although Schafer is not able to identify what was in the muffin that caused the problems with her throat, she speculated in her deposition that “it had to have been something sharp and hard.”5
Schafer sued Perkins, alleging that the pumpkin muffin was in a defective condition unreasonably dangerous to consumers, the defective condition was a direct cause of the injury to her throat, and, as a result of the injury, she suffered damages in the form of medical expenses, loss of earnings, pain, disability, and emotional distress. Perkins, in turn, asserted a third-party claim for contribution against Foxtail Foods, the company that manufactured the muffin mix Perkins used to make the pumpkin muffin.6
After some discovery, Perkins and Foxtail moved for summary judgment, arguing that Schafer had failed to establish a prima facie case of negligence because she could not identify the object in the muffin that caused her injury. The district court granted summary judgment on that basis and the court of appeals affirmed.7
Whether a restaurant customer can establish a prima facie claim of negligence against the restaurant where she was served without identifying the specific object that allegedly caused her injury?8
In a negligence action, the defendant is entitled to summary judgment when the record reflects a complete lack of proof on any of the four essential elements of the claim.9 Those elements are (1) the existence of a duty of care; (2) a breach of that duty; (3) an injury; and (4) the breach of the duty being the proximate cause of the injury.10 The elements most relevant in this case are proximate cause and breach.11 A plaintiff may reach the jury without direct proof of the specific injury-causing object or substance when the plaintiff establishes by reasonable inference from circumstantial evidence that the injury-causing event was of a kind that would ordinarily only occur as a result of a defective condition in the food product.12 The defendant must have been responsible for a condition that was the cause of the injury.13 The injury-causing event was not caused by anything other than a food product defect existing at the time of the food product’s sale.14
Yes. On January 27, 2001, Karen Schafer went to a Perkins Restaurant in St. Cloud, Minnesota, with a friend and their daughters. She ordered a pumpkin muffin, unwrapped it, and using her fork placed a piece in her mouth.15 Upon swallowing, she immediately felt a sharp pain in her throat and a choking sensation.16 After drinking water and still feeling something stuck in her throat, Schafer went directly to a hospital emergency room.17 Before leaving, her friend notified a Perkins employee that she was going to the emergency room as a result of swallowing a piece of the muffin.18
At the hospital, a doctor told Schafer she had a cut on her throat but observed no object that would have caused the cut.19 There is no allegation that Schafer had any throat-related ailment immediately preceding her swallowing the first bite of the muffin.20 Although Schafer could not identify the object and the rest of the muffin was not saved, the events occurred in the presence of witnesses and Schafer speculated it had to have been something sharp and hard.21 These facts permit a reasonable inference satisfying all three elements of the circumstantial-evidence test, so the district court’s grant of summary judgment was error.22
A restaurant customer can establish a prima facie claim of negligence against the restaurant without identifying the specific object that allegedly caused her injury when the three-element circumstantial-evidence test is met.23
Whether the reasonable expectation test should be adopted for determining whether a food product is defective?24
The reasonable expectation test focuses on what is reasonably expected by the consumer in the food product as served, not what might be foreign or natural to the ingredients of that product before preparation.25 As applied to common-law negligence, the reasonable expectation test is related to the foreseeability of harm on the part of the defendant.26 The defendant has the duty of ordinary care to eliminate or remove in the preparation of the food served such harmful substance as the consumer of the food, as served, would not ordinarily anticipate and guard against.27 The reasonable expectation test is the more appropriate test to follow.28 Relying on consumers’ reasonable expectations is likely to yield a more equitable result instead of drawing arbitrary distinctions between foreign and natural substances.29
Yes. The foreign-natural test draws a distinction between foreign and natural characteristics of a food product ingredient.30 It holds that if an object or substance in a food product is natural to any of the ingredients there is no liability.31 This bright-line rule has been called into question.32 An unexpected natural object such as a chicken bone in chicken soup can cause as much harm as a foreign object such as a piece of glass in the same soup.33 The reasonable expectation test instead focuses on what is reasonably expected by the consumer in the food product as served.34 It is related to the foreseeability of harm.35
The defendant has the duty of ordinary care to eliminate or remove in the preparation of the food served such harmful substance as the consumer would not ordinarily anticipate and guard against.36 The majority of jurisdictions have adopted some formulation of the reasonable expectation test.37 The Restatement (Third) of Torts: Products Liability § 7 likewise recognizes reasonable consumer expectations in food products liability cases.38 Therefore the reasonable expectation test is adopted as the standard for determining defective food products liability claims in Minnesota.39
The reasonable expectation test should be adopted for determining whether a food product is defective because it yields more equitable results than the foreign-natural test and aligns with the majority view and the Restatement.40
Whether circumstantial evidence may be used to establish a prima facie defective food products claim when the specific harm-causing object cannot be identified?41
When the specific harm-causing object is not known, circumstantial evidence should be available, if such evidence is sufficient and other causes are adequately eliminated, for purposes of submitting the issue of liability to the jury in defective food products cases.42 Permitting the use of circumstantial evidence in such cases is consistent with jurisprudence on the use of circumstantial evidence to infer negligence in other contexts, such as exploding soft-drink bottle cases.43 In defective food products cases, a plaintiff may reach the jury without direct proof of the specific injury-causing object or substance when the plaintiff establishes by reasonable inference from circumstantial evidence that the injury-causing event was of a kind that would ordinarily only occur as a result of a defective condition in the food product.44 The defendant was responsible for a condition that was the cause of the injury.45 The injury-causing event was not caused by anything other than a food product defect existing at the time of the food product’s sale.
Yes. Schafer purchased a pumpkin muffin at a Perkins restaurant, began eating the muffin while at the restaurant, and experienced a sharp pain and choking sensation immediately after swallowing her first bite.46 Such an occurrence is not the kind of event that an ordinary consumer would anticipate and guard against.47 Although the harm-causing object was never identified, Schafer immediately reported her experience to a Perkins employee and went directly to a hospital emergency room where a doctor found a cut on her throat.48 The events occurred in the presence of witnesses, and there is no allegation of any prior throat ailment.49
Viewing this circumstantial evidence in the light most favorable to Schafer.50 A jury could reasonably infer that the injury is of a kind that would ordinarily only occur as a result of a defective condition in the pumpkin muffin.51 Perkins was responsible for making the muffin that caused the injury.52 The injury was not caused by anything other than a defect in the muffin existing at the time of sale.53 The Kneibel bright-line rule requiring identification of the harm-causing object is unduly restrictive.54 The three-element test derived from Holkestad and Restatement § 3 therefore governs.55
Circumstantial evidence may be used to establish a prima facie defective food products claim when the specific harm-causing object cannot be identified, provided the plaintiff satisfies the three-element test.56