808 F.2d 1316 (9th Cir. 1986)
Lee Seiler, a graphic artist and creator of science fiction creatures, sued George Lucas and Lucasfilm, Ltd. for copyright infringement, claiming that the Imperial Walkers appearing in the 1980 motion picture The Empire Strikes Back copied his own creatures known as Garthian Striders.1 Seiler asserted that he had created and published the Garthian Striders in 1976 and 1977, but he did not obtain a copyright registration until 1981, when he deposited reconstructions of the originals with the Copyright Office.2
Prior to trial, Seiler sought to display enlarged comparisons of his Striders and the Imperial Walkers during his opening statement, prompting the district court to conduct a seven-day pre-trial evidentiary hearing on the admissibility of his evidence.3 During the hearing, Seiler produced neither the original drawings of the Garthian Striders nor any documents establishing their existence before the release of The Empire Strikes Back, leading the district court to find that he had lost or destroyed the originals in bad faith and to exclude all secondary evidence, including the post-1980 reconstructions.4
Following the evidentiary ruling, the district court granted summary judgment to Lucas and Lucasfilm, and Seiler appealed to the Ninth Circuit, which had jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1291 and reviewed the matter de novo.5
Whether the best evidence rule applies to Seiler's drawings of science fiction creatures?6
Rule 1002 of the Federal Rules of Evidence requires the original writing, recording, or photograph to prove the content of a writing, recording, or photograph, except as otherwise provided in the rules or by Act of Congress.7 Writings and recordings are defined in Rule 1001 as letters, words, or numbers, or their equivalent, set down by handwriting, typewriting, printing, photostating, photographing, magnetic impulse, mechanical or electronic recording, or other form of data compilation.8 The rule addresses concerns including fraud prevention, the centrality of writings in legal relations, the fallibility of human memory as reliable evidence of terms, and the hazards of inaccurate or incomplete duplication.9
Yes. Seiler's drawings qualify as writings under Rule 1001(1) because they consist of the equivalent of words and figures as objective manifestations of creative ideas that affect legal relations through copyright protection.10 The contents of the drawings are at issue because there can be no proof of substantial similarity unless the works are juxtaposed and compared.11 Seiler could produce no originals existing before the 1980 release of the film and offered only post-release reconstructions deposited in 1981.12
The policies of the rule are implicated because the reconstructions were made years later and could be tainted by exposure to the movie.13 The dangers of fraud are present where no pre-1980 documentary evidence exists.14 Seiler was therefore required to produce the originals or show unavailability without bad faith under Rule 1004(1), which he could not do.15
The best evidence rule applies to Seiler's drawings of science fiction creatures.16
Whether Rule 1008 of the Federal Rules of Evidence requires a jury determination of the existence and authenticity of Seiler's original drawings?17
Rule 1008 provides that when the admissibility of other evidence of contents of writings, recordings, or photographs under these rules depends upon the fulfillment of a condition of fact, the question whether the condition has been fulfilled is ordinarily for the court to determine in accordance with the provisions of rule 104.18 However, when an issue is raised whether the asserted writing ever existed, or whether another writing, recording, or photograph produced at the trial is the original, or whether other evidence of contents correctly reflects the contents, the issue is for the trier of facts to determine as in the case of other issues of fact.19 The preliminary determination of whether originals were lost or destroyed in bad faith under Rule 1004(1) remains a question for the judge.20
No. The trial judge properly held the seven-day hearing to determine the admissibility of the reconstructions based on the condition of fact whether the originals were lost or destroyed in bad faith.21 In the established facts, Seiler indicated prior to opening statement that he planned to show reconstructions to the jury, prompting the evidentiary hearing at which the district court found the originals lost or destroyed in bad faith after hearing testimony that Seiler had testified falsely and fabricated the reconstructions.22 Had Seiler proved the originals were not lost in bad faith, the reconstructions would have been admissible and their accuracy would then have been a question for the jury under Rule 1008(c).23 Since admissibility depended on the bad-faith finding, the judge correctly resolved that preliminary question without submitting it to the jury.24
Rule 1008 of the Federal Rules of Evidence does not require a jury determination of the existence and authenticity of Seiler's original drawings.25
Whether 17 U.S.C. § 410(c) overrides the Federal Rules of Evidence and mandates admission of Seiler's secondary evidence?26
Section 410(c) of the Copyright Act provides that in any judicial proceedings the certificate of a registration made before or within five years after first publication of the work shall constitute prima facie evidence of the validity of the copyright and of the facts stated in the certificate.27 The evidentiary weight to be accorded the certificate of a registration made thereafter shall be within the discretion of the court.28 This section does not compel admission of attached works when those works are otherwise inadmissible under the Federal Rules of Evidence such as the best evidence rule. Nor does it speak to whether reconstructions match non-existent originals.29
No. The certificate of copyright registration obtained in 1981 has no bearing upon the ultimate facts Seiler seeks to prove.30 It pertains only to the attached reconstructions rather than establishing that those reconstructions are identical to any pre-1980 originals.31 Seiler deposited reconstructions with the Copyright Office in 1981 after the release of The Empire Strikes Back.32 The certificate makes no reference to any preexisting work or reconstruction process.33
Section 408 permits deposit only of bona fide copies of the original work.34 The district court's finding of bad-faith loss or destruction of the originals overcame any presumption that might arise from the certificate.35 Section 410(c) therefore does not override the best evidence rule or require admission of the excluded secondary evidence.36
17 U.S.C. § 410(c) does not override the Federal Rules of Evidence and does not mandate admission of Seiler's secondary evidence.37