144 S.W.3d 429 (Tex.
Several hundred lessee dealers in seventeen different states lease service stations and buy gasoline from Shell Oil Company, Motiva Enterprises LLC, Equilon Enterprises LLC, and Equiva Services LLC, operating those stations as independent businesses.1 Each dealer and Shell enter into two agreements: a Lease and a Dealer Agreement.2 Under the Dealer Agreement, each dealer agrees to buy Shell-branded gasoline from Shell at the dealer prices in effect at the time of purchase, referred to as the DTW price because it includes delivery to the dealer's station by a Shell tanker truck.3
Shell markets gasoline to the public through a retail network that includes lessee dealers, company-operated stations, and jobbers.4 Jobbers pay a rack price that is available for gasoline bought and picked up at Shell's terminals and is typically lower than the DTW price.5 Shell's agreements with the dealers prohibit them from selling any gasoline except Shell-branded gasoline.6 Agreements between Shell and its jobbers effectively eliminate the only major alternative source for Shell-branded gasoline at the lower rack price.7 The dealers claim that Shell's DTW prices cannot be set in good faith because they are so high that they put Dealers at a competitive disadvantage. Dealers further assert that Shell's DTW pricing is part of a plan to replace them with company-operated outlets which are more profitable for Shell.8
Shell moved for summary judgment on the dealers' claims, contending that it charged a posted price applied uniformly to all dealers and that the price was commercially reasonable.9 The trial court granted Shell's motion for summary judgment.10 The court of appeals reversed the summary judgment, concluding that circumstantial evidence raised a fact issue about Shell's subjective good faith when setting its DTW price.11
Whether the price fixed by a refiner for the sale of its gasoline under an open-price-term contract with its dealers was in good faith as required by section 2.305(b) of the Texas Business and Commerce Code?12
Under section 2.305(b) of the Texas Business and Commerce Code, a price to be fixed by the seller or by the buyer means a price for him to fix in good faith.13 Good faith is defined to mean honesty in fact and the observance of reasonable commercial standards of fair dealing.14 Official Comment 3 to section 2.305 creates a presumption that in the normal case a posted price or a price in effect satisfies the good faith requirement.15
Yes. Shell established as a matter of law that its DTW price was fixed in good faith because the price was commercially reasonable, falling within the range of DTW prices charged by other refiners in the markets where the dealers operated, and was applied uniformly to similarly situated dealers without discrimination.16
Circumstantial evidence concerning the relatively high DTW price, the captive nature of the franchise relationship, and the general decline in dealers' business fortunes does not raise a fact issue on bad faith.17 Good faith under section 2.305(b) does not require Shell to set a competitive or lowest available price for each individual dealer, and the dealers contractually agreed to the DTW pricing arrangement.18
Shell fixed its DTW price in good faith as a matter of law under section 2.305(b), and the dealers take nothing on their claims.19