222 F.3d 472 (8th Cir. 2000)
Carl Shen, a United States citizen who retains dual Taiwanese citizenship, moved to Taiwan in 1989 to become managing director of Leo A. Daly Company's operation there.1 To conduct business in Taiwan, Daly was required to designate a responsible person or legal representative, and Shen was so designated.2 In November 1992, Daly decided to withdraw from Taiwan because of business setbacks, terminated Shen, but failed to remove him as its responsible person.3
In December 1993, Shen received a notice from the Taiwan Tax Authority that it wanted to audit Daly's 1992 Taiwan tax returns.4 Shen notified Daly's accounting firm in Taiwan and informed them of his concern that he could be held responsible for any deficiency because his chop, the Taiwanese equivalent of a signature, was affixed to the returns.5 Daly responded that it was inconceivable any tax could be owed because Daly had suffered large losses in Taiwan.6 In January 1994, Shen asked Daly to indemnify him should the Taiwan Tax Authority impose the tax liability on him directly.7
Following this request and until mid-October 1995, Shen, through a series of letters to Daly personnel and to Mr. Leo A. Daly III himself, implored Daly to resolve the tax dispute and remove him as the responsible person.8 In May 1994, the Taiwan Tax Authority assessed a tax liability of approximately $80,000 against Daly for 1991 and 1992.9 Daly did not appeal the assessment, and it became final in June 1995.10 In October 1995, the Taiwan Ministry of Finance and the Bureau of Entry and Exit informed Shen he was forbidden from leaving the country until resolution of the Daly tax issue.11
Shen brought suit for a declaratory judgment in Taiwan to remove himself as Daly's responsible person, but the court denied relief because Daly had not replaced him.12 In 1997, Shen sued Daly in the United States District Court for the District of Nebraska.13 He requested a preliminary injunction to force Daly to pay the taxes, which the district court entered on December 31, 1997.14 The district court held a bench trial in February 1999 on the issue of a permanent injunction and damages.15
The district court found a violation of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing and granted a permanent injunction.16 Shen was also awarded attorney's fees and $4760 in damages on his contractual claims.17 Shen, however, did not prevail on his claims for false imprisonment or intentional infliction of emotional distress.18 Both he and Daly appealed the judgment.19
Whether the Taiwanese court's judgment in Shen's declaratory judgment action should be given preclusive effect?20
To give the judgment of a foreign country preclusive effect, it must be recognized as a legitimate judgment.21 A judgment should be enforced and not retried if the foreign forum provided a full and fair trial of the issues in a court of competent jurisdiction, ensured the impartial administration of justice, and ensured the trial was without prejudice or fraud.22 The foreign court must also have proper jurisdiction over the parties and the judgment must not violate public policy.23 The burden of proof in establishing that the foreign judgment should be recognized and given preclusive effect is on the party asserting it should be recognized.24
No. Daly, the party arguing that the Taiwan judgment should be given preclusive effect, must establish each of these factors.25 Daly has merely asserted the Taiwanese judgment should be given effect, it has not provided the district court or this court with any authority that guides toward the recognition of foreign judgments.26 Additionally, Daly did not produce any evidence to support its res judicata defense.27 Accordingly, it did not provide enough information for us to determine if the Taiwan tribunals are impartial or if Taiwan procedures are compatible with due process.28
Therefore, Daly did not meet its burden of proof, and the Taiwanese court's judgment will not be accorded preclusive effect.29
The Taiwanese court's judgment should not be given preclusive effect.30
Whether the district court abused its discretion in granting preliminary and permanent injunctive relief?31
We review the district court's decision to grant injunctive relief for an abuse of discretion and we will affirm unless the district court clearly erred in its characterization of the facts, made a mistake of law, or abused its discretion in considering the equities.32 Under Nebraska law, whether a person is an agent is a question of fact.33 An agency relationship can be implied from words, conduct or circumstances that evidence an intent to create one.34 A principal and an agent are in a fiduciary relationship.35 Because of the fiduciary relationship, the principal owes the agent a duty of good faith and fair dealing in the incidents of their relationship.36
No. After Daly terminated Shen in December 1992, Daly did not remove Shen as its responsible person.37 When Shen entreated Daly to remove him as its responsible person in January 1994, Daly still did not act.38 In June 1994, Daly tried to have one of the employees of its accounting firm in Taiwan replace Shen and informed Shen that the employee had become Daly's new responsible person.39 The employee, however, decided not to take the appointment, and Daly failed to inform Shen of this fact for seven months.40
By the time Shen learned there was no replacement for him, the threat of a travel restriction was looming, and Daly was unable to find anyone willing to take the appointment.41 The result of Daly's initial inaction and subsequent inability to replace Shen as responsible person was that Shen remained Daly's agent regarding actions taken by Taiwan.42 Daly breached its duty as a fiduciary in the following ways. Daly did not pay the tax when it was assessed. It chose not to appeal the assessment through proper channels. Daly did not find a replacement for Shen as responsible person.43 The district court did not abuse its discretion in granting the injunction based on Daly's breach of fiduciary duty.44
The district court did not abuse its discretion in granting preliminary and permanent injunctive relief.45
Whether the district court erred in granting judgment as a matter of law on Shen's false imprisonment claim?46
We review the decision to grant judgment as a matter of law de novo, viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to Shen.47 False imprisonment is the unlawful restraint against his will of an individual's personal liberty.48 Although it is difficult to define exactly how close the level of restraint must be, in this case the country of Taiwan is clearly too great an area within which to be falsely imprisoned.49
No. Shen's liberty was restrained in this case because he was not allowed to leave Taiwan.50 Shen's confinement, however, was to a whole country.51 He was free to move about Taiwan, and was not restrained in any way in his daily activities.52 Although it is difficult to define exactly how close the level of restraint must be, in this case the country of Taiwan is clearly too great an area within which to be falsely imprisoned.
Therefore, the district court correctly granted judgment as a matter of law.53
The district court did not err in granting judgment as a matter of law on Shen's false imprisonment claim.54
Whether the district court properly dismissed Shen's intentional infliction of emotional distress claim?55
We review legal conclusions de novo, and factual findings for clear error.56 To establish a claim for intentional infliction of emotional distress, Shen must prove three elements. First, there has been intentional or reckless conduct. Second, the conduct was so outrageous in character and so extreme in degree as to go beyond all possible bounds of decency and is to be regarded as atrocious and utterly intolerable in a civilized community. Third, the conduct caused emotional distress so severe that no reasonable person should be expected to endure it.57
Yes. The harms Shen suffered because of Daly's refusal to pay the tax included missed family occasions, estrangement from his wife, lost business opportunities, shame, depression, insomnia, anxiety, and a variety of health problems for which, he testified, he sought medical attention.58 Although Shen undoubtedly did suffer stress and anxiety in this situation, his suffering does not rise to the level required by Nebraska law.59 Additionally, Daly's conduct, though unquestionably unfair, did not exceed all possible bounds of decency.60
Therefore, we find no error in the district court's dismissal of this claim.61
The district court properly dismissed Shen's intentional infliction of emotional distress claim.62
Whether Daly is entitled to a set-off of amounts Shen owes against the damages awarded?63
We review the district court's decision for an abuse of discretion.64 The pleading rules in the federal courts are very liberal.65 Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 15 contemplates that courts should allow pleadings to be amended if it is necessary to further justice and will not prejudice the parties.66 Rule 15(b) provides that when issues not raised by the pleadings are tried by express or implied consent of the parties, they shall be treated in all respects as if they had been raised in the pleadings.67 Consent may be implied if evidence to support the claim was introduced at trial without objection.68
Yes. Although Shen did not expressly consent to try the set-off issue, the issue was tried by implied consent in this case.69 On cross-examination, Shen, without objection, testified he received the refund from withholding taxes from the Taiwanese government.70 He testified that it was Daly's money and amounted to $6700.71
Additionally, Shen acknowledged he owes Daly the money.72 The fact that the money is owed is not disputed.73 Therefore, we find the court abused its discretion and Daly is entitled to the set-off.74
Daly is entitled to a set-off of amounts Shen owes against the damages awarded.75
Whether the district court erred in awarding attorney's fees for the Taiwan action and the Nebraska action?76
Under Nebraska law, attorney's fees are only proper if they are permitted by statute or by uniform practice.77 As a general rule of practice in Nebraska, attorneys' fees are allowed to the successful party in litigation only where such allowance is provided by statute.78 There is no Nebraska statute authorizing attorney's fees for a breach of fiduciary duty.79 The bar on attorney's fees only applies in the very case being litigated.80 It would not apply to the award of attorney's fees for the action in Taiwan because that award, in essence, is compensatory.81 Nebraska courts have held that attorney's fees are recoverable as compensatory damages when a person, damaged by a tort, was required to bring a suit against a third person to protect his interests.82 A person who commits a breach of fiduciary duty is guilty of tortious conduct.83
No. There is no Nebraska statute authorizing attorney's fees for a breach of fiduciary duty.84 Therefore, the district erred in awarding attorney's fees for this action.85 However, the bar on attorney's fees only applies in the very case being litigated.86
It would not apply to the award of attorney's fees for the action in Taiwan because that award, in essence, is compensatory. Daly's breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing is a breach of fiduciary duty.87 And, although Shen sued Daly in the action in Taiwan, he was required to bring his suit to protect his interest and have the travel restriction lifted.88 Therefore, the attorney's fees awarded for the suit in Taiwan were proper as an element of damages for breach of fiduciary duty.89
The district court erred in awarding attorney's fees for the Nebraska action but did not err in awarding attorney's fees for the Taiwan action.90
Whether the district court should have awarded additional compensatory damages for breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing?91
We review the district court's damage award for an abuse of discretion.92 Under Nebraska law, the amount of damages to be awarded is a determination solely for the fact finder, and its action in this respect will not be disturbed on appeal if it is supported by evidence and bears a reasonable relationship to the elements of the damages proved.93
No. The district court's award of attorney's fees for the action in Taiwan as damages for the breach of the covenant of good faith is supported by evidence in the record.94 The amount awarded bears a reasonable relationship to the elements of the damages proved, including the costs Shen incurred to protect his interests after Daly's breach.95 Thus, we find no abuse of discretion by the district court.96
The district court should not have awarded additional compensatory damages for breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing.97