415 U.S. 566 (1974)
On January 30, 1970, two police officers in Leominster, Massachusetts, observed Goguen wearing a small cloth version of the United States flag, approximately four by six inches, sewn to the seat of his blue jeans.1 The first officer saw Goguen standing and talking with a group of persons on a public street, where the group was not engaged in any demonstration or protest, and no disruption of traffic or breach of the peace occurred.2 Later, the second officer observed Goguen walking in the downtown business district of Leominster.3
The following day, the first officer swore out a complaint charging Goguen under the contempt provision of the Massachusetts flag-misuse statute with publicly treating the flag of the United States contemptuously.4 After a jury trial in the Worcester County Superior Court, Goguen was convicted and sentenced to six months in the Massachusetts House of Corrections.5 The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court affirmed the conviction.6
Goguen then sought federal habeas corpus relief in the United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts, which found the flag-contempt portion of the statute impermissibly vague under the Due Process Clause and overbroad under the First Amendment, ordering his release.7 The United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit affirmed on both vagueness and First Amendment grounds.8 The Supreme Court of the United States noted probable jurisdiction to review the judgment.9
Whether the contempt provision of the Massachusetts flag-misuse statute is unconstitutionally vague as applied to Goguen's conduct?10
The due process doctrine of vagueness requires that criminal statutes provide fair notice of what conduct is prohibited and reasonably clear guidelines for law enforcement officials and triers of fact to prevent arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement.11 When a statute's literal scope reaches expression sheltered by the First Amendment, the doctrine demands a greater degree of specificity than in other contexts.12
Yes. The statutory language at issue fails to provide fair notice or clear guidelines for enforcement.13
Goguen was charged solely with publicly treating the flag contemptuously by wearing a small cloth flag on the seat of his trousers, without any physical desecration or breach of the peace.14 The phrase 'treats contemptuously' is sufficiently unbounded to prohibit any public deviation from formal flag etiquette and lacked a narrowing state court interpretation at the time of Goguen's prosecution.15 This permits policemen, prosecutors, and juries to pursue their personal predilections, as shown by the hypothetical contrasting a war protestor and an American Legion member caught in the rain.16
Due process is denied when such inherently vague statutory language allows selective law enforcement.17
The contempt provision of the Massachusetts flag-misuse statute is unconstitutionally vague as applied to Goguen's conduct.18
Whether Goguen exhausted his state remedies with respect to his vagueness claim?19
Under the exhaustion doctrine for federal habeas corpus, a petitioner must fairly present the substance of his federal constitutional claim to the state courts so that they have an opportunity to pass upon it.20
Yes. Goguen filed an unsuccessful motion to dismiss in state superior court.21 In that motion he cited the Fourteenth Amendment and alleged that the statute under which he was charged was impermissibly vague and incapable of fair and reasonable interpretation by public officials.22 That motion was incorporated in his amended bill of exceptions to the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court.23 Goguen's brief before that court raised vagueness points and cited relevant vagueness precedents.24
Although the federal claims were not perfectly compartmentalized, the state court's opinion addressed Goguen's First Amendment and vagueness claims separately, demonstrating that the court was aware of both arguments.25 The substance of the vagueness claim was therefore fairly presented to the state courts under the exhaustion standards.26
Goguen exhausted his state remedies with respect to his vagueness claim.27