664 F.2d 1174 (11th Cir. 1981)
Richard Emery Clark and Zygmund Fornalski were convicted after a bench trial for willfully and knowingly possessing marijuana with intent to distribute in violation of 21 U.S.C. §§ 841(a)(1) and 846.1 They were the only occupants of the cabin cruiser C-LARK II when it was intercepted by the Coast Guard.2
On April 6, 1977 the Coast Guard cutter POINT BARNES sighted the C-LARK II in the vicinity of Gun Cay, approximately fifty miles southeast of the Florida coast. The POINT BARNES was on law enforcement patrol and had been told to watch for a white cabin cruiser approximately thirty feet in length that was suspected of carrying narcotics. The C-LARK II met the general description of that vessel. The POINT BARNES ordered her to stop and prepare to be boarded by the Coast Guard.3
Clark stated that the C-LARK had come from Gun Cay and was going to Ft. Lauderdale. A customs officer aboard the POINT BARNES stated to the Coast Guard captain his belief that the C-LARK was loaded with some type of cargo. Clark and Fornalski were told to open the door to the ship’s cabin. The officers aboard the POINT BARNES saw that the floor of the C-LARK’s cabin was strewn with burlap bags. The customs officer asked Clark what was contained in the ship’s cabin. Clark replied that the ship was carrying fish.4
When the officer asked Clark to produce the fish, he said “just come aboard.” In fact, the C-LARK was carrying approximately 2,000 pounds of marijuana. Upon boarding, the Coast Guard and customs officials saw marijuana in the cabin within plain view. Clark and Fornalski were then frisked, read their rights, and placed under arrest. The C-LARK was thoroughly searched and brought into Miami.5
After the C-LARK was seized by the Coast Guard, officer Pope piloted the vessel to Miami, arriving about noon on April 6, 1977. Pope testified that he turned the bales of marijuana over to a Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) agent whose name he could not remember. DEA Agent Aguiree testified that he picked up the bales from the customs docks in Miami about 12:30 on April 6 shortly after they were unloaded from the C-LARK.6 Clark and Fornalski appealed their convictions, raising issues regarding the search, Miranda warnings, and chain of custody.7
Whether the Coast Guard's stop and boarding of the C-LARK II and subsequent search violated the Fourth Amendment?8
The Coast Guard has plenary power under 14 U.S.C. § 89(a) to stop and board American vessels on the high seas to inspect for safety, documentation, and obvious customs and narcotics violations.9 The fact that this authority is exercised without probable cause or reasonable suspicion does not violate the fourth amendment.10 After the Coast Guard and customs officers boarded the ship, they found marijuana inside the ship’s cabin within plain view, and this discovery provided probable cause for the search of the entire vessel.11
Yes. On April 6, 1977 the Coast Guard cutter POINT BARNES sighted the C-LARK II in the vicinity of Gun Cay while on law enforcement patrol after having been told to watch for a white cabin cruiser suspected of carrying narcotics, and the vessel met the general description.12 The POINT BARNES ordered the C-LARK II to stop and prepare to be boarded.13 Clark stated that the vessel had come from Gun Cay and was going to Ft. Lauderdale.14
A customs officer stated his belief that the C-LARK was loaded with cargo.15 Clark and Fornalski were told to open the cabin door, revealing burlap bags on the floor.16 Clark replied that the ship was carrying fish but then said just come aboard when asked to produce them.17 Upon boarding the officers saw marijuana in plain view.18
These specific facts show that the stop and boarding were authorized under the statute for both safety and narcotics inspection purposes, and the plain view observation supplied probable cause for the thorough search that followed.19
The Coast Guard's stop and boarding of the C-LARK II and subsequent search did not violate the Fourth Amendment.20
Whether questioning Clark about the vessel's destination without providing Miranda warnings violated the Fifth Amendment?21
The routine stop, boarding and inspection of an American vessel on the high seas by the Coast Guard does not in itself create a custodial situation that triggers the need for Miranda warnings.22 Clark has failed to establish the existence of any special circumstances that would render the preboarding conversation a custodial interrogation for Miranda purposes.23
No. Clark was asked about the C-LARK's destination during the preboarding conversation with officers before any boarding occurred.24 The stop was a routine Coast Guard enforcement action on the high seas.25 No facts indicate that Clark was in custody or subject to coercive interrogation at that moment.26 Clark has not shown any special circumstances converting the brief exchange into a custodial setting requiring warnings.27
Questioning Clark about the vessel's destination without providing Miranda warnings did not violate the Fifth Amendment.28
Whether the marijuana evidence was properly admitted despite a potential break in the chain of custody?29
The trial court determined that there was a sufficient degree of reliability that the marijuana introduced at trial originated from the C-LARK to warrant its admission into evidence.30 A minor break in the chain of possession might properly affect the weight that the trial judge accorded that evidence as the trier of fact, but should not preclude its admission into evidence.31
Yes. After seizure officer Pope piloted the C-LARK to Miami arriving about noon on April 6, 1977 and turned the bales over to a DEA agent whose name he could not remember.32 DEA Agent Aguiree testified that he picked up the bales from the customs docks in Miami about 12:30 on April 6 shortly after they were unloaded from the C-LARK. The trial court found a sufficient degree of reliability that the marijuana introduced at trial originated from the C-LARK.33
This minor gap affects only evidentiary weight rather than admissibility.34
The marijuana evidence was properly admitted despite a potential break in the chain of custody.35