163 U.S. 625, 16 Sup.Ct. 1073, 41 L.Ed. 287
Merriam died on January 30, 1889, having bequeathed personal property to the United States by will.1 Although the death occurred in 1889, New York tax authorities did not assess an inheritance tax until February 16, 1893.2 The assessment took place after the enactment of chapter 399 of the Laws of 1892, which imposed a tax on transfers of property to corporations not exempt by law from taxation.3
New York had previously enacted chapter 483 of the Laws of 1885, as amended by chapter 215 of the Laws of 1891, providing that property passing by will to any body politic or corporate would be subject to tax.4 The 1892 legislation repealed the earlier acts but included a saving clause preserving liabilities incurred prior to its passage.5 The United States challenged the tax on the legacy, asserting exemption from the requirement.6
The dispute was litigated in the courts of New York, culminating in a judgment by the Supreme Court of the State of New York against the United States.7 Error was taken from that judgment to the United States Supreme Court.8 The case was submitted on May 8, 1896, and decided on May 25, 1896, with Mr. Justice Brown delivering the opinion of the Court.
Whether personal property bequeathed by will to the United States is subject to an inheritance tax under the laws of New York?9
The right to dispose of property by will is purely a creature of statute and within legislative control.10 A state may impose conditions upon its exercise.11 This includes a requirement that the legatee contribute a percentage of the property to the public treasury before the bequest takes effect.12 The tax is therefore imposed upon the transmission of the property rather than upon the property itself.13
Yes. The testator Merriam died on January 30, 1889, having bequeathed personal property to the United States by will.14 New York tax authorities assessed the inheritance tax after the 1892 statute took effect.15 The tax operates as a condition on the statutory right of testamentary transfer.16 The legacy reaches the United States only after the tax has been paid from the estate.17
Personal property bequeathed by will to the United States is subject to an inheritance tax under the laws of New York.18
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Harlan dissented from the opinion of the Court.19 He registered disagreement with the majority holding that the New York inheritance tax applied to the bequest of personal property to the United States.20 The published opinion contains no further elaboration of separate grounds for the dissent.21
His formal dissent stands as a clear expression of disagreement with the Court's resolution that the state tax could validly attach to a legacy passing to the federal government under the New York statutes.22
Whether it is within the power of the State to tax bequests to the United States?23
Every state possesses the power of regulating the manner and terms within which property within its dominion may be transferred by last will and testament.24 A state may prescribe who shall and who shall not be capable of taking it.25 If a state may deny the privilege altogether, it may annex to the grant any conditions required by its interests or policy.26
Yes. The Court applied the established principle that the tax operates as a condition upon the statutory right of testamentary transfer rather than as a direct levy upon federal property.27 The legacy reaches the United States only after the tax has been paid.28 The state therefore exercises its authority over the transmission of property located within its borders without taxing the United States itself.29
It is within the power of the State to tax bequests to the United States.30
Whether, under these statutes, the United States are a corporation exempted by law from taxation?31
Statutory exemptions from inheritance taxation apply only to domestic corporations created by the state.32 The exemptions are limited to religious, educational, charitable, or reformatory purposes.33 A purely political or governmental entity such as the United States does not fall within the class of corporations the legislature intended to exempt.34
No. The Court of Appeals of New York had construed the exemption provisions as limited to corporations created by New York and subject to its visitation.35 The United States is not among the religious, educational, charitable, or reformatory entities identified in the tax laws as qualifying for exemption.36
Under these statutes, the United States are not a corporation exempted by law from taxation.37