576 U.S. 200 (2015)
In 2009 the Texas Division of the Sons of Confederate Veterans, a nonprofit entity, submitted an application to sponsor a specialty license plate.1 The proposed design placed the words “SONS OF CONFEDERATE VETERANS” at the bottom, featured the organization’s logo containing a square Confederate battle flag framed by the words “Sons of Confederate Veterans 1896,” and included a faint Confederate battle flag in the background on the lower portion of the plate.2 The Board’s predecessor denied the application.3
In 2010 SCV renewed the application before the Texas Department of Motor Vehicles Board.4 The Board invited public comment on its website and at an open meeting, received letters from elected officials opposing the proposal, and after considering the responses voted unanimously to deny the design.5 The Board explained that it had found it necessary to deny the plate design application, specifically the confederate flag portion of the design, because public comments had shown that many members of the general public find the design offensive, and because such comments are reasonable.6 The Board added that a significant portion of the public associate the confederate flag with organizations advocating expressions of hate directed toward people or groups that is demeaning to those people or groups.7
SCV and two of its officers filed suit in federal district court against the chairman and members of the Board.8 The complaint alleged that the rejection violated the First Amendment and sought an injunction requiring approval of the proposed design.9 The District Court entered judgment for the Board.10 A divided panel of the Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reversed.11 It held that Texas’s specialty license plate designs are private speech and that the Board, in refusing to approve SCV’s design, engaged in constitutionally forbidden viewpoint discrimination.12 The dissenting judge argued that Texas’s specialty license plate designs are government speech, the content of which the State is free to control.13
The Supreme Court granted the Board’s petition for certiorari.14 Texas law requires all motor vehicles operating on the State’s roads to display valid license plates.15 Each of these plates contains the word “Texas,” a license plate number, a silhouette of the State, a graphic of the Lone Star, and the slogan “The Lone Star State.”16 The Board may create new specialty license plates on its own initiative or on receipt of an application from a nonprofit entity seeking to sponsor a specialty plate.17 A nonprofit must include in its application a draft design of the specialty license plate.18 Texas law vests in the Board authority to approve or to disapprove an application.19 The Board has approved over 350 specialty plate designs.20 Texas also owns the designs on its license plates, including the designs that Texas adopts on the basis of proposals made by private individuals and organizations.21 Texas dictates the manner in which drivers may dispose of unused plates.22
Whether Texas’s specialty license plate designs constitute government speech?23
When government speaks, it is not barred by the Free Speech Clause from determining the content of what it says.24 The government may express its own viewpoint and decline to express an opposing view.25 The central framework from Johanns asks whether the Government sets the overall message to be communicated and approves every word that is disseminated.26 Three factors from Summum guide the inquiry: history of the medium as a vehicle for government messages, whether the speech is closely identified in the public mind with the state, and whether the state maintains direct control over the message through final approval authority.27
Yes. The history of license plates shows that they long have communicated messages from the States. Texas has selected messages such as “Read to Succeed” and “Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo” through its designs for decades. Texas license plate designs are often closely identified in the public mind with the State. Each plate bears the name TEXAS in large letters at the top. The plates serve the governmental purposes of vehicle registration and identification. They constitute a government-issued ID that observers reasonably interpret as conveying a message on the issuer’s behalf. Texas maintains direct control over the messages conveyed on its specialty plates. The Board must approve every specialty plate design proposal before the design can appear on a Texas plate. Texas law provides that the State has sole control over the design. The Board has actively exercised this authority by rejecting at least a dozen proposed designs.
The proposed design placed the words SONS OF CONFEDERATE VETERANS at the bottom, featured the organization’s logo containing a square Confederate battle flag framed by the words Sons of Confederate Veterans 1896, and included a faint Confederate battle flag in the background on the lower portion of the plate. The Board’s predecessor denied the application. In 2010 SCV renewed the application before the Texas Department of Motor Vehicles Board. The Board invited public comment on its website and at an open meeting, received letters from elected officials opposing the proposal, and after considering the responses voted unanimously to deny the design.
The Board explained that it had found it necessary to deny the plate design application, specifically the confederate flag portion of the design, because public comments had shown that many members of the general public find the design offensive, and because such comments are reasonable. SCV and two of its officers filed suit in federal district court against the chairman and members of the Board. The complaint alleged that the rejection violated the First Amendment and sought an injunction requiring approval of the proposed design. The District Court entered judgment for the Board.
A divided panel of the Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reversed. It held that Texas’s specialty license plate designs are private speech and that the Board, in refusing to approve SCV’s design, engaged in constitutionally forbidden viewpoint discrimination. The dissenting judge argued that Texas’s specialty license plate designs are government speech, the content of which the State is free to control. The Supreme Court granted the Board’s petition for certiorari.
Texas law requires all motor vehicles operating on the State’s roads to display valid license plates. The Board may create new specialty license plates on its own initiative or on receipt of an application from a nonprofit entity seeking to sponsor a specialty plate. The Board has approved over 350 specialty plate designs. Texas owns all designs on its plates and requires vehicle owners to return unused specialty plates to the State.
These facts establish that Texas sets the overall message and approves every word disseminated on its specialty plates.28
Texas’s specialty license plate designs constitute government speech.29
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Chief Justice Roberts, Justice Scalia, And Justice Kennedy
Justice Alito dissented on the ground that the messages on Texas’s specialty license plates are private speech rather than government speech.30 He argued that the history of the Texas specialty plate program shows it is a recent development. In this development the State allows private entities to secure plates conveying their own messages. This crosses the line from government speech into private speech. He further contended that the program lacks the selective receptivity present in Summum. Texas proclaims it is open to all private messages except those that would offend some who viewed them. The fees collected demonstrate that the State is selling space on mobile billboards rather than speaking itself.
In his view the Confederate battle flag expresses a viewpoint. The Board’s rejection of the SCV design on the ground that many members of the public find it offensive constitutes viewpoint discrimination.
Whether Texas’s specialty license plate program creates a nonpublic forum for private speech?31
Forum analysis applies to government restrictions on purely private speech occurring on government property.32 A designated public forum exists where government property not traditionally regarded as a public forum is intentionally opened up for that purpose.33 A limited public forum exists where a government reserves a forum for specific groups or for the discussion of specific topics.34 A nonpublic forum exists where the government is acting as a proprietor managing its internal operations.35 Forum analysis is not appropriate when the State is speaking on its own behalf.36
No. Texas’s policies and the nature of its license plates indicate that the State did not intend its specialty plates to serve as either a designated public forum or a limited public forum. The State exercises final authority over each specialty license plate design. It takes ownership of each specialty plate design. It has traditionally used its plates for government speech. The plates are not a nonpublic forum. With respect to specialty license plate designs Texas is not simply managing government property but instead is engaging in expressive conduct. This is shown through historical context, observers’ reasonable interpretation of the messages, and the effective control the State exerts over the design selection process. The fact that private parties take part in the design and propagation of a message does not extinguish the governmental nature of the message or transform the government’s role into that of a mere forum provider.37 The fact that Texas vehicle owners pay annual fees to display specialty license plates does not imply that the plate designs are merely a forum for private speech. The existence of government profit alone is insufficient to trigger forum analysis.
This case does not resemble other cases in which the Court has identified a nonpublic forum such as a school district’s internal mail system or advertising space on city buses.38
Texas’s specialty license plate program does not create a nonpublic forum for private speech.39
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Chief Justice Roberts, Justice Scalia, And Justice Kennedy
Justice Alito dissented on the ground that Texas has created a limited public forum by allowing state property to be used by private speakers according to rules that the State prescribes.40 He maintained that the Board’s rejection of the SCV design because public comments showed many members of the general public find the design offensive constitutes viewpoint discrimination forbidden in a limited public forum.41 He argued that the Board’s approval of the Buffalo Soldiers plate at the same meeting while rejecting the SCV plate further demonstrates that the State is discriminating on the basis of viewpoint.42
Whether the Texas Department of Motor Vehicles Board’s rejection of the Sons of Confederate Veterans proposed design violated the First Amendment?43
Because specialty license plate designs constitute government speech, the State is entitled to refuse a proposed design.44 The government’s ability to express its own viewpoint necessarily includes the right to decline to express an opposing view.45 The First Amendment stringently limits a State’s authority to compel a private party to express a view with which the private party disagrees. Compelled private speech is not at issue when the State refuses to include a design on its own government speech plates.
No. Because Texas’s specialty license plate designs constitute government speech, the Board was entitled to reject SCV’s design.46 Just as Texas cannot require SCV to convey “the State’s ideological message,” SCV cannot force Texas to include a Confederate battle flag on its specialty license plates. The determination that the designs are government speech means the Free Speech Clause does not require Texas to approve the proposed design.47
The Texas Department of Motor Vehicles Board’s rejection of the Sons of Confederate Veterans proposed design did not violate the First Amendment.48
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Chief Justice Roberts, Justice Scalia, And Justice Kennedy
Justice Alito dissented on the ground that the Board’s rejection of the SCV design was viewpoint discrimination in violation of the First Amendment.49 He argued that the Board’s order expressly stated the design was denied because many members of the public find it offensive, which is pure viewpoint discrimination.50 He further contended that the precedent set by treating private messages on specialty plates as government speech threatens private speech that government finds displeasing and could extend to other government property such as billboards or bulletin boards.51