Concept
Cases Begun in Federal Court
The “adequate and independent state ground”
Cases Begun in Federal Court
The first question in any adequate-and-independent-state-ground problem is which court issued the judgment under review. The doctrine applies only to the Supreme Court's review of state-court decisions.1 A case that comes up from a lower federal court is reviewed under 28 U.S.C. § 1254, which lets the Court examine every issue in the case, including any state-law ground on which the lower court's ruling rests.2 A state-law holding in the fact pattern does not, by itself, trigger the doctrine.
The reason lies in the premise behind the doctrine: state courts have the last word on what state law means. When the Court reviews a case that began in a state court, the state courts have necessarily spoken on every state-law issue in it, and the Court accepts those rulings as correct.3 That acceptance is why an adequate and independent state ground ends the Court's review of a state judgment.
A case that began in federal court lacks that premise. The Court sees only the lower federal judges' reading of state law, not a definitive interpretation from the state's own courts. With no state ruling to defer to, the Court need not accept the federal judges' reading. If it believes they misinterpreted state law, it is free to correct the error.4
Even in cases from state courts, the bar depends on what the state court actually did. The Court has stressed that the fact that a state court "might" have rested its decision on state grounds is of no consequence if it in fact failed to do so. A possible adequate and independent state ground does not bar review where the state supreme court clearly rested its decision solely on the Federal Constitution.5 The two settings therefore ask different questions. In a state-court case, the question is whether the state court actually rested on an adequate and independent state ground. In a federal-court case, the question never arises, because no state court has spoken.
The supply-contract dispute differs from a state-court case in one respect: no state court has spoken. A student who sees a state-law holding in an exam stem and reaches for the doctrine by reflex will misapply it. Checking the court of origin first prevents that mistake.
A different doctrine, Pullman abstention, governs what a federal court does when state law is unsettled and no state court has spoken. The next section contrasts it with the doctrine covered here.