Concept
Textual Grants of War Power
War, defense, and foreign affairs powers
War and Foreign Affairs Powers
Textual Grants of War Power
The Constitution divides the war power between Congress and the President, and the division starts in the text. Article I, Section 8 gives Congress the power to declare war (clause 11), to raise and support armies (clause 12), to provide and maintain a navy (clause 13), and to spend for the common defense (clause 1). It also lets Congress make rules for the government and regulation of the land and naval forces.1 Article II, Section 2, clause 1 makes the President commander in chief.2 Together these provisions make up what lawyers call the war power: Congress's authority under clauses 11 through 14 to declare war and maintain armed forces, and the President's authority to conduct war.3
The two grants split the subject by function. The commander-in-chief role gives the President day-to-day managerial control over the military's activities, while the power to declare war sits with Congress.4 That division is what makes a textual separation-of-powers argument available. Suppose a President declared war without congressional approval. A challenger could argue that the President had usurped a power the Constitution assigns to Congress under Article I, Section 8.5
Congress also holds a check through the purse. Military appropriations carry a two-year limit that is unique to them. The limit keeps the President's war chest small, and it forces each new Congress to reassess the wisdom of continuing hostilities that an earlier legislature may have approved.6
In practice, the line between the branches falls between structure and operations. Congress controls the structure, organization, and broad-brush policies of the military departments, so the President cannot singlehandedly amend the Uniform Code of Military Justice, eliminate the Air Force, or double the Army's annual budget. The President, for his part, has broad authority to order troop deployments, develop battle plans, and manage operational matters.7
Had Congress enacted the same structural changes by statute, the structural objection would vanish, because reorganizing the departments, amending the military justice code, and setting the Army's budget are subjects Article I commits to Congress.8 The test on an exam is therefore which branch holds the particular function. The urgency of the military interest does not answer that question.
The enumerated grants are not the whole story. Coupled with the Necessary and Proper Clause and the inherent authority of the United States to conduct foreign affairs, they vest the United States with the complete power to make war.9 That is because the power to make war is the power to prosecute war successfully. It may therefore be used to prepare for war, to prevent it, to wage it, to end it, and to ameliorate its effects after hostilities cease, and courts rarely second-guess Congress or the President in these war-related contexts.10 The Necessary and Proper Clause also appears in theories about where unenumerated national powers come from. On one such theory, using those powers helps carry into execution “the aggregate of national powers” vested in the federal government.11
A broad power is still a limited one. The war power, like every other granted power, is subject to constitutional limitations, including those in the Bill of Rights, although the Supreme Court did not firmly establish until 1919 that war powers legislation is subject to judicial review.12 Article I also guarantees that the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus shall not be suspended, except in cases of rebellion or invasion when the public safety may require it.13 Where congressional control ends and executive command begins has produced uncertainty and debate in many settings, and later sections on sharing war power take up the contested points.14