Concept
Equal Protection and the Default Tier
Rational basis review
Rational Basis in Equal Protection
Equal Protection and the Default Tier
The Fourteenth Amendment forbids a State to "deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws."1 Read as a demand for identical treatment, that sentence would doom nearly every statute, because every law sorts people into groups and hands some of them a burden or benefit that others do not get. A state that licenses sixteen-year-olds to drive and refuses fourteen-year-olds has classified by age, yet the classification is not unconstitutional merely because it classifies. The Clause asks something narrower. It requires government to treat similarly situated individuals in a similar manner. It does not govern the process of decision-making, but it limits the government's power to classify people as different in type when it dispenses benefits or punishments.2 Where heightened scrutiny is not called for, government remains free to legislate on the basis of generalizations, even ones that operate as irrebuttable presumptions, so long as it can rationally conclude that generalized rules suit its purposes.3
The live question, then, is how hard a court should look at a particular classification. Since 1937 the Court has deferred to economic and social regulation unless the law infringes a fundamental right or discriminates against a group that warrants special judicial protection.4 The Justices no longer decide for themselves whether the classifications in general social welfare or economic legislation are legitimate. They sustain a classification that arguably relates to a legitimate function of government.5 Two reasons support this restraint. Deference lets the more democratic branches decide everything except the areas where heightened scrutiny has a justification,6 and the Constitution presumes that even improvident decisions will eventually be rectified by the democratic process.7
Every equal protection problem breaks into three questions: what is the classification, what level of scrutiny applies to it, and does the government's action meet that level.8 The levels form a ladder. At the top, strict scrutiny demands that the government show that its classification is necessary to achieve a compelling purpose. In the middle, a gender-based classification receives intermediate scrutiny: it must serve important governmental objectives and be substantially related to achieving them.9 At the bottom sits rational basis review, which takes whatever remains. Unless a classification is a type of discrimination that warrants intermediate or strict scrutiny, rational basis is the test, and it is the minimum that every government action challenged under equal protection must meet.10
Rational basis review asks whether the law is rationally related to a legitimate government purpose.11 The test is deferential, and the law starts with the presumption of validity. A classification outside the suspect-class and fundamental-right categories is presumptively permissible, and the party challenging it carries the burden of establishing that no rational relationship exists.12
Two ordinary laws show the default at work. A 14-year-old who says that the minimum driving age denies equal protection must prove that the law is not rationally related to a legitimate government purpose.13 A zoning code that lets some owners build commercial structures and confines others to residential use classifies owners just as plainly. It will be upheld if the classification is at least arguably rationally related to a legitimate purpose, and the test is almost always satisfied.14 Neither law burdens a fundamental right or targets a group that warrants special protection, so nothing displaces the lenient test.
The default gives way when a trigger appears. Craig v. Boren concerned a law that set different ages for men and women to buy low-alcohol beer, and a classification drawn by gender must serve important governmental objectives and be substantially related to achieving them.15 The Court applies that intermediate scrutiny because gender, like race, is an immutable characteristic determined solely by the accident of birth, and because gender-based classifications too often reflect "old notions" and "archaic and overbroad generalizations" about the relative abilities of men and women.16 A driver's license law and a beer law can both draw lines by age. What separates them is that the beer law also sorted people by sex, and once that trigger appeared, rational basis no longer applied. Strict and intermediate scrutiny receive their own treatment elsewhere. For now, the point is that rational basis is what remains when neither trigger is present.
By its terms the Clause restrains only a "State," so Congress needs a different route to the same rule.17 In Bolling v. Sharpe, a companion to Brown v. Board of Education that concerned segregated public schools in the District of Columbia, the Court held that equal protection applies to the federal government through the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment.18 The requirements are now settled as the same whether the challenge is to federal action under the Fifth Amendment or to state and local action under the Fourteenth. The Court has declared that "[e]qual protection analysis in the Fifth Amendment area is the same as that under the Fourteenth Amendment."19 The default tier therefore governs federal classifications just as it governs state ones, even though the textual source differs. The chapter returns to federal classifications when it reaches alienage.