Concept
Who Can Invoke Article IV
Privileges and Immunities Clauses
Who Can Invoke Article IV
Article IV, § 2, clause 1 speaks to a defined group: “The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.”1 The guarantee runs to citizens, so a plaintiff must show that the word describes him or her before anything else matters. Justice Washington's classic account in Corfield v. Coryell described what the clause protects: interests that “are fundamental; which belong, of right, to the citizens of all free governments.”2 Whether a plaintiff's interest qualifies, and whether the state has discriminated without good reason, are questions for later sections. A plaintiff who cannot claim the clause's text never reaches them.
The text sorts plaintiffs into two groups. A natural person who is a United States citizen qualifies once he or she proves domicile in a state other than the one whose law is challenged. A corporation or an alien does not qualify, whatever the facts. The first subsection takes up natural persons. The second takes up the excluded plaintiffs and the other constitutional claims they can still bring.
Citizenship and Domicile
The Privileges and Immunities Clause of Article IV protects citizens of other states against state laws that discriminate in favor of a state's own citizens, so a litigant must establish that he or she is a citizen of some state other than the one whose law is under attack.3 For a natural person, citizenship in a state has two parts: the person must be (1) a United States citizen and (2) a bona fide resident of that state.4 This definition tracks § 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment, which makes persons born or naturalized in the United States citizens of the United States and of the state where they reside.5 A claimant can satisfy one part and fail the other, so a complete answer addresses each by name.
The first part excludes anyone who is not a United States citizen, however long that person has lived in a state, because the clause is limited to individuals who are U.S. citizens.6 The second part decides most fact patterns. Bona fide residence means domicile: the person has taken up residence in the state with the intent to remain indefinitely, not for a fixed or temporary period.7 Physical presence, even for years, does not establish it, and the reason lies in what the clause protects. The clause shelters a citizen of one state who goes into another and meets worse treatment than that state gives its own people, and only someone who belongs to a different state can be that outsider. A second rule keeps the inquiry from leaving anyone adrift: once a person establishes a domicile, that status lasts until he or she establishes a new domicile somewhere else.8
The citizenship requirement also carries a standing consequence. A litigant who is not a citizen of some other state would be asserting the constitutional rights of others, and the rule against third-party standing bars that claim in federal court.9 The defect is a threshold one. The court never reaches whether the burdened interest is fundamental or whether the state has a good reason for the discrimination.
Saul shows how the threshold fails in practice. South Dakota refuses to sell him cement because he does not live in the state. Saul was born and raised in South Dakota and moved to Wyoming a few years ago to attend college, and during the summers he runs a small construction business in Wyoming. When he moved, he planned to attend college there and then, on graduation, relocate to a warmer climate such as Florida.10 Because he planned only a temporary stay, he never took up Wyoming residence with the intent to remain indefinitely, so he is not a Wyoming citizen. He is not yet a Florida citizen either, since he has not settled there. His South Dakota domicile continues until he establishes a new one, so he remains a South Dakota citizen, and a South Dakota citizen cannot invoke the clause against South Dakota. That the refusal burdens his business does not matter at this stage.
The same structure explains why a citizen of the challenged state generally has no claim. In the Slaughter-House Cases, the right to pursue one's trade was a privilege of state citizenship protected by Article IV, § 2. Even so, the clause was not triggered, because Louisiana's monopoly law affected all independent butchers regardless of their state of citizenship.11 A later section develops this limit.
Saul and Paula both live outside the state whose law they attack, so physical location cannot separate them. Domicile does. A fact pattern that says a claimant “lives in” another state therefore invites one more question: does that residence carry an intent to remain? Phrases such as “until graduation,” “for the year,” or “on a temporary assignment” signal presence without that intent, and the old domicile stays in place.
Because any step can end the analysis, run the threshold in order:
Corporations and Aliens
Corporations and aliens cannot invoke the Comity Clause, because it protects only “Citizens.”13 Begin with corporations. The Court has long held that a corporation is not a “citizen” of a state within the meaning of Article IV, § 2; see Bank of Augusta v. Earle.14 A law that specifically discriminates against out-of-state corporations is therefore not subject to scrutiny under the clause. An out-of-state corporation also lacks standing to challenge a law that discriminates generally against out-of-staters in favor of the state's own citizens.15
The reason is third-party standing. A claim under the clause says that citizens' privileges have been infringed. Because a corporation is not a citizen within the meaning of the clause, invoking it would mean asserting the rights of third parties, and the rule against third-party standing forbids that.16
The word “citizen” does not mean the same thing throughout the Constitution. Under Article III, corporations count as citizens of a state, so suits involving corporations involve “citizens” for federal jurisdictional purposes.17 Under other provisions, such as the Fourteenth Amendment's definition of citizen, the term covers neither corporations nor aliens, and the Comity Clause protects only citizens.18 A corporation that is a Wyoming citizen for diversity purposes therefore gains nothing when it turns to Article IV.
Reeves, Inc. v. Stake supplies the illustration. South Dakota was discriminating against out-of-staters with respect to the fundamental right to do business in the state, here by buying cement. Reeves nonetheless lacked standing to invoke the Privileges and Immunities Clause, because it would be invoking the constitutional rights of third parties rather than its own.19 The state's conduct looks the same whether the buyer is a corporation or an individual, so the plaintiff's identity decides the first step. A natural person who is a United States citizen domiciled outside South Dakota can invoke the clause against the same refusal, though whether that person wins depends on later steps.
Aliens fall outside the clause for a parallel reason: it does not extend to alien residents of the United States, because they are not United States citizens.20 Domicile cannot supply the missing element, since state citizenship requires both United States citizenship and bona fide residence. A lawful alien who has lived in a state for decades satisfies only the second.
A plaintiff shut out of Article IV may still have a remedy elsewhere. The Equal Protection Clause forbids a state to “deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws,” and corporations, though not citizens for Article IV, are persons within its meaning. Review is usually only rational basis, but the clause sometimes overturns discriminatory legislation: in Metropolitan Life Insurance Co. v. Ward, 470 U.S. 869 (1985), the Court applied it to invalidate an Alabama law that taxed out-of-state insurance companies at a higher rate than domestic companies.21 A lawfully resident alien may likewise receive very similar protection from the Equal Protection Clause against unjust residency or citizenship requirements.22 Corporations and aliens can also sue under the dormant Commerce Clause, which, unlike the Privileges and Immunities Clause, has no citizenship limit.23 The Fourteenth Amendment's Privileges or Immunities Clause offers no way around the exclusion, since it too protects only citizens.24 Later sections develop the equal protection and commerce routes.