Concept
Who May Accept
Offer: what counts, preliminary negotiations, and who may accept
Who May Accept
An offer can be complete in every other respect and still conclude nothing when the wrong person says yes. The earlier sections of this chapter asked whether a communication was an offer and whether its terms were definite enough to enforce. Those questions assume that someone is in a position to accept; this section asks who that someone is. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 29 answers by tying the power of acceptance to what the offeror manifested, not to what a stranger who learns of the proposal might want to do.1
The section takes up three questions in order. How do the offeror's words and conduct pick out an offeree? What forms can the empowered group take? Section 29(2) names a specified person, members of a specified group or class acting separately or together, and anyone who makes a specified promise or renders a specified performance.2 And what does an empowered person hold? An offer gives the offeree a continuing power to complete the manifestation of mutual assent by acceptance.3 That power is a capacity to form a contract, and it carries no duty to use it.
The Restatement states common-law rules, so a mixed deal raises a threshold question. When a transaction combines goods and services, such as an estimate to sell and install carpet, the predominant purpose test asks which element predominates: Article 2 applies if the sale of goods predominates and the labor is incidental, and the common law applies if the opposite is true.4
Offeror Names the Offeree
The offeror is master of the offer. The offeror writes its terms, may dispense with the requirement that acceptance be communicated,5 and under § 29(1) decides who may accept: the manifested intention of the offeror determines the person or persons in whom a power of acceptance is created.6 The allocation protects the party whose promise is on the line. An acceptance transforms the offeror's conditional promise into a contract,7 and a seller extending credit, an employer hiring for skill, or an owner with a single parcel to sell has good reason to care who ends up on the other side.
The simplest case is an offer addressed to one person. Kay's email to Doug names the person she invites to assent, communicates her willingness to contract, sets out the essential terms, leaves nothing open for negotiation, and conveys the reasonable understanding that a contract will come into being on Doug's assent.8 Doug holds the power, and no one else does.
Because § 29(1) speaks of manifested intention, the circle of offerees is drawn objectively. Only persons who are justified in understanding that their assent is invited may accept.9 A recipient deciding whether to act sees only what the offeror outwardly showed, and a rule that looked behind the showing to a private plan would let an offeror disown anyone who reasonably took the invitation as meant for him. The law of written offers applies the same logic to terms: one who makes a written offer that is accepted is bound by it though ignorant of its terms or its proper interpretation, and cannot avoid the writing by pointing to a narrower private intention.10
A car dealership's sign tested the rule. A golfer claimed the benefit of the sign, and the dealership answered, accurately, that it had intended the sign only for a tournament held the day before. The court nonetheless found a contract, reasoning that under the circumstances the golfer was justified in understanding that the sign invited acceptance by him as well.11 The limit lived only in the dealership's head. The sign the golfer saw conveyed a wider invitation, so the circle of offerees was the wider one the sign reasonably showed.
The same principle keeps a recipient from passing an offer along. Unless the offer says otherwise or is clearly open to anyone who sees it, it is personal to the person or persons to whom it is addressed, and an identified offeree cannot transfer the power of acceptance.12 The likely reason is the offeror's freedom to choose a counterparty. After formation, a party may delegate performance, within limits, but remains liable on the contract, so the other side keeps a claim against the person it chose.13 Before acceptance the offeree owes nothing, and a transfer of the power would leave the offeror with no such claim against the person chosen.
The second scene comes out differently because a promise the offeror makes as part of the offer may itself be a contract, commonly called an option.14 The offeree has paid for the promise not to revoke, so the power and right to accept become an enforceable right in the nature of property, and absent contrary agreement the original offeree may assign it.15 The mechanics of options, including duration and formal requirements, belong to the reading on irrevocable offers. Here the point is that the exception rests on the offeror's own bargain: the offeror sold the offeree the right to accept, and a purchased right can be resold. The unpaid offeree in the first scene holds only what the invitation gave, and the invitation named Rob.
When an exam stem has someone other than the addressee purport to accept, run two steps. First ask whom the offeror's words and conduct invited, read as a reasonable recipient would read them. If the answer is a named or identifiable person, ask whether that person bought the offeror's promise to hold the offer open, since only a paid option travels with an assignment.
Persons, Classes, and Performers
Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 29(2) lists the shapes an offeror's choice can take: an offer may create a power of acceptance in a specified person, in one or more of a specified group or class acting separately or together, or in anyone or everyone who makes a specified promise or renders a specified performance.19 Each shape answers two questions at once: who may accept, and how many acceptances the offer can absorb. The first shape, one named person, needs no further treatment. The group and performer shapes are where an offeror's exposure can outrun what the offeror meant to risk, so the rest of this subsection takes them up.
An offer may go to a defined or undefined group. Where it does, the offer's words and setting decide whether it contemplates multiple acceptances or may be accepted only by the first person to reply.20 The phrase 'acting separately or together' in § 29(2) leaves the offeror free to choose.21
An offer to anyone who renders a specified performance seems at first to promise a contract with the whole world. The Carbolic Smoke Ball Company's celebrated advertisement shows why it does not. The company promised £100 'to any person who contracts the increasing epidemic influenza, colds, or any disease caused by taking cold, after having used the ball three times daily for two weeks according to the printed directions supplied with each ball.'22 The advertisement named no one. It addressed any person who did what it asked,23 so under § 29(2) the power of acceptance belongs to each person who renders the specified performance.24
An indefinite addressee ordinarily points away from an offer. One court, quoting a commentator, called that only a guide: it works for advertisements and circular letters, but 'in reward cases, the addressee is equally indefinite and, yet, the expression is an offer,' and the more definite the proposal, the more reasonable it is to treat it as a commitment.25
Compare the ordinary store advertisement. An ad reading 'nationally advertised at $440, today only at $250' states no quantity and uses no language of commitment, so the cases treat it as a preliminary proposal inviting offers, and a shopper who tenders $250 forms no contract.26 The stole advertisement behind Lefkowitz's dispute used different words, 'FIRST COME FIRST SERVED,' which speak to the quantity question the suit ad left open. Lefkowitz was the first customer to present himself and demanded the stole for $1.00; the store refused because of a house rule that the offer was intended for women only.27
The number of acceptances an offer to the public can absorb depends on whether the requested performance can happen more than once. The smoke-ball promise went to any person who did what it asked, so each user who performed and fell ill could claim. A reward for Vince's lost dog Barfy differs, because only one dog can be returned. Vince can be liable to only one person, and although the reward reached anyone who learned of it, the power of acceptance belongs to the person who finds and returns Barfy. Reward situations do not typically raise the concerns about quantity and number of offerees that trouble ordinary advertisements.28
The same reasoning governs a proposal sent to several recipients. When Charley's owner sends a letter that was also sent to others, the question is whether a recipient was justified in understanding that his assent was invited and would conclude the bargain.29 A recipient with no reason to know the letter went to others, whose letter was worded to create a power of acceptance, may well be justified, and the owner may then be found to have contracted with each recipient who accepted. Only one contract can be performed, but the owner answers in damages for the others.30 The converse follows: a recipient who knows the letter went to others has far less reason to think his assent alone will conclude anything.
An instruction that confines acceptance to one person changes the analysis, because an offer to a group may be read as open only to the first person to reply.31
Reward offers raise a further question: must the claimant have known of the offer? In Broadnax v. Ledbetter, a sheriff offered $500 for the capture and return of an escaped convict, and a bounty hunter captured the convict and sued for the reward. The Texas Supreme Court, answering a certified question, held that a reward offer may be accepted by anyone who performs the service called for when the acceptor knows that the offer has been made and acts in performance of it, but not otherwise.32 Authorities divide on timing. The older view requires that the whole consideration the offer requests be given after the offeree knows of the offer; the more modern view holds it enough that the offeree completes performance with knowledge, because the offer then induces the completion, which is the parties' common understanding. The question arises only for unilateral contracts, those accepted by performance.33
A reward for information raises a second question: can more than one informant collect? That too is a question of interpretation.34 An offer that pays for information leading to a conviction calls for one performance, and a reasonable reading limits it to the first person whose information produces that result.
Students tend to err in two directions on these problems. Some conclude that a message sent to several people can never be an offer, which overlooks mechanisms such as first to arrive that confine acceptance to one person. Others read 'anyone' in a reward literally and pay every claimant, which overlooks that the offeror's manifested intention, read in context, may limit the offer to the first to perform.
The Offeree's Continuing Power
Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 35(1) states what an offer leaves with the person who receives it: a continuing power to complete the manifestation of mutual assent by acceptance.38 Lawyers use 'power' for any capacity to produce a legal effect. An administrative agency has the power to engage in rulemaking, and a constitution may reserve a political power to a specified authority such as a state government.39 The offeree's power is the private-law counterpart: an offer empowers the offeree to create a contract by accepting it.40 The earlier subsections asked who holds that power. This one asks what the holder has and for how long.
The word 'continuing' matters, because the power persists for as long as the offer stays open, and the offeree chooses when within that period to use it. Holding the power puts the offeree under no obligation. Disputes over whether a contract was formed at all arise most often when dealings are oral, spread across letters, or partly written, and the rules of offer and acceptance supply the framework for resolving them.41 The offeree's power is the hinge of that framework: if the offeree used it while it lasted, a contract exists, and if not, none does. An offer hands the offeree the decision whether a contract will come into being.42 The offeree may accept, answer with a different proposal, refuse, or say nothing, and the offeror cannot compel an answer.
Offers often leave the duration unstated. Kay's email to Doug prescribes no method or time of acceptance, and a communication need not specify either to qualify as an offer.43 When the offer prescribes neither, a reasonableness standard applies; an offeror who wants a tighter schedule can prescribe both, and an acceptance must follow them to be valid.44
The power does not last forever. A contract cannot be created by acceptance of an offer after the power of acceptance has been terminated in one of the ways § 36 lists.45 The reasoning follows from what an acceptance does: it completes a pair of manifestations, and an acceptance aimed at an offer that is no longer open has nothing to complete. A rule that let a stale offer be accepted at any later time would hold the offeror to terms the offeror may no longer want and would give the offeree a free chance to wait and see whether the market moved.
Section 36 lists the events that end the power: rejection or counteroffer by the offeree, lapse of time, revocation by the offeror, and death or incapacity of the offeror or the offeree, with the non-occurrence of a condition of acceptance under the offer's own terms as a further ending.46 This subsection names them only to mark the outer edge of the power. How each operates, including the position of an offeree who has paid to keep the power safe from revocation, belongs to the reading on termination.
Exam stems usually test the power by having the offeree change position, so ask whether the power was still alive at the moment of the 'yes.' Sallie made a formal offer to sell her home to Bonzo for $500,000, and Bonzo answered, 'no way.' A reasonable person would understand those words as a rejection, so Bonzo's power of acceptance terminated, and any later declaration of acceptance would not conclude a contract unless Sallie chose to reinstate her offer.47 Had Bonzo said yes within a reasonable time, before any rejection, revocation, or other terminating event, the same words would have concluded the sale. An effective acceptance therefore needs an offeree the offeror empowered, as the earlier subsections showed, and needs that offeree to act while the power survives.