Concept
Offers That Do Not Specify
Acceptance: bilateral versus unilateral contracts and acceptance by promise or performance
Offers That Do Not Specify
Most offers say nothing about how the offeree should answer, and the law fills the silence. Unless the language or the circumstances indicate otherwise, an offer invites acceptance in any manner and by any medium reasonable in the circumstances.1 That sentence settles two questions. Manner asks what kind of response counts: a promise to do what the offer requests, or the doing of it. Medium asks what channel carries the response: a letter, a telephone call, an e-mail.
The Restatement (Second) and the UCC sort offers into three categories rather than two. Offers that unambiguously require a return promise are offers for bilateral contracts, and a contract results when the offeree makes the promise. Offers that unambiguously require performance, with no return promise sought, are offers for unilateral contracts, and only performance accepts them; most reward offers belong here.2 Every other offer, the kind that does not specify, falls under a default rule. The first subsection develops that default, and the second shows what an offeror must do to escape it.
Default Rule: Either Mode
The offeree of a silent or doubtful offer may answer by any reasonable manner and medium, and may answer with a promise or with the performance itself. The Restatement (Second) puts the point directly: in case of doubt, an offer is read as inviting the offeree to accept either by promising to perform what the offer requests or by rendering the performance, as the offeree chooses.3
The rule replaces an older presumption. When an offer was ambiguous on the point, it was presumed to require acceptance by a promise. The modern rule rests instead on the view that in the vast majority of cases the offeror is indifferent about the manner of acceptance, so the offeree is free to proceed by performance or by promise.4
The burden of an unclear offer therefore falls on the offeror. The test is objective: would a reasonable person believe the offeror required a particular method of acceptance, or only suggested one? Answering that question requires looking at all the circumstances. In sales of goods, any reasonable manner or medium satisfies the offer unless the offeror unambiguously indicates otherwise, and other kinds of cases generally follow the same rule. It places on the offeror the burden of proving that a reasonable person would read the offer as prescribing a manner or medium.5
The medium of reply shows the rule at work. Suppose the parties negotiate by e-mail and fax, the offer says nothing about how to respond, and the offeree accepts by regular mail. One court found the mailed acceptance reasonable, largely because the offer prescribed no method. Decisions will not always come out that way, because what is reasonable depends on the circumstances of each case.6
This flexibility is recent. When Article 2 was promulgated in the 1950s, its flexible treatment of manner and medium contrasted with a more rigid approach in common-law cases, but modern cases now adopt the Article 2 principles in common-law cases as well.7 Article 2 states the default for sales of goods in nearly the Restatement's words, and it requires that the language or circumstances unambiguously indicate otherwise before the default gives way.8 Sales law is part of contract law generally, and the general law of offer and acceptance applies to sales unless the Code displaces it.9
Doubt about manner often takes the form of an offer that points both ways. An uncle writes his niece that he will leave her his house 'if she comes and takes care of him until his death,' which suggests performance, and then adds 'please let me hear from you by the end of the month,' which suggests a promise. A reasonable person cannot tell which the uncle wants, so the Restatement (Second) lets the niece accept either by promising or by performing.10
Whichever mode the offeree chooses, the usual result is a bilateral contract. When words are used to accept, the acceptance invariably constitutes a promise of future performance.11 If the owner of Bleakacre offers to sell the farm for $2 million and the offeree replies by expressing acceptance, both parties have promised future performance: the owner to convey the farm, the offeree to pay the price.12 Where the offer invites either mode, beginning the invited performance accepts as well, and it communicates an implied promise to complete the performance. The part-performance sections develop that point.13
How plainly Marsha would have to write to rule out either of those responses is the subject of the next subsection. On an exam, the first question about any reply is whether the offer said anything about how to give one.
When the Offeror Insists
The default yields only when the offeror's language or the circumstances make a different choice clear. The UCC phrases the exception strictly: the offer is construed as inviting any reasonable manner and medium unless the language or circumstances unambiguously indicate otherwise.15 The Restatement (Second) words the exception more loosely, but despite the variation in language it takes the same basic approach.16 Under either formulation, an offeror who claims an exclusive mode must prove that a reasonable person would read the offer as prescribing it.17
A prescription differs from a suggestion, and the difference lies in what a reasonable reader would take the offer to mean. An offeror who writes 'I would appreciate a reply by e-mail' has suggested a method, and a telephone call answers as well. An offeror who writes 'Accept only by an e-mail received before 6:00 p.m. on June 1' has prescribed one, and where no ambiguity remains, the offeree can accept only by following that prescription.18
Unambiguous indications are unusual, and the Restatement (Second)'s illustrations show how unusual. A unilateral-sounding verb such as 'deliver' does not prevent acceptance by promise, and the word 'promise' does not prevent acceptance by performance. Words like these describe what the contract will call for and say little about what the offeree must do to form it. Some offers do rise to the level of an unambiguous prescription. Where a buyer's order stated that 'seller shall mail to purchaser a signed duplicate copy hereof,' the court held that the offer unambiguously made a promise by writing the only acceptance.19
Express language like Marsha's does the work most easily. Payment is both the act of acceptance and the offeree's complete performance, so only the offeror has a promise outstanding and the contract is unilateral.20
The circumstances can close the door without any such words. A return promise may be worthless to the offeror, or the circumstances may make it unreasonable to expect a firm commitment to complete the requested act. An offer that says 'I will pay $100 for the return of my dog, Barfy' is the standard example: the owner wants the dog back, and a promise to look for the dog is worth little.21 Offers of this kind share more than the requested act. The offeree's performance is speculative, and when it is far from certain that the offeree can perform even if willing, the offeror is unlikely to be interested in a mere promise.22 Most reward offers fall into this performance-only category.23
The Carbolic Smoke Ball Company's advertisement is the classic reward offer. It announced a £100 reward 'to any person who contracts' influenza, colds, or any disease caused by taking cold 'after having used the ball three times daily for two weeks according to the printed directions,' and it added that £1000 was on deposit with the Alliance Bank to show the company's sincerity.24 The advertisement asks for the use of the ball and for nothing else. It asks no reader for a promise.