Concept
Accepting in the Invited Manner
Acceptance: bilateral versus unilateral contracts and acceptance by promise or performance
Accepting in the Invited Manner
An offer gives the offeree power to form a contract by a single act of choice, and the offeror can live with that power only if the act is recognizable when it happens. Acceptance doctrine therefore measures the reply against the offer: the response must be the kind the offeror asked for. The same reply can accept one offer and fail against another. Three questions organize this section. What manner of response did the offer invite? When has the offeree completed an acceptance by promise? And when has the offeree completed an acceptance by performance?
Matching the Offer's Mode
Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 50(1) defines acceptance as a manifestation of assent to the terms of the offer, made by the offeree in a manner invited or required by the offer.1 Two requirements sit inside that definition. Assent must be manifested, so a private decision to go along forms no contract. And the manifestation must take the form the offer asks for, which ties acceptance back to the question the earlier sections of this chapter answered: what did the offeror request in return?
The matching requirement protects an offeror who cannot plan around an exposure it cannot see. Suppose an offeror asks for a letter of commitment and a truck pulls up to the loading dock. The offeror has no way to tell whether to hold the goods, resell them, or keep waiting for the mail. Holding the offeree to the requested form lets the offeror look for one thing and know, from its presence or absence, whether a bargain exists.
Section 53(1) applies the idea to the response most often disputed: an offer can be accepted by the rendering of a performance only if the offer invites such an acceptance.2 Performance is the ambiguous response because words of assent are plainly an answer, while conduct may be an answer or may be ordinary activity that tells the offeror nothing. When an offer unambiguously requires a promise, an offeree who begins to perform without sending a promissory acceptance forms no contract, unless the offeror learns of the beginning and acquiesces in that informal manner of accepting.3
White v. Corlies & Tifft shows the problem on real facts. The defendants wrote a builder: 'Upon an agreement to finish the fitting up of offices 57 Broadway in two weeks from date, you can begin at once.' The builder sent no reply. On receiving the note he bought lumber and began work, and the next day the defendants countermanded the note. The court held that the builder's act was no acceptance because it was 'no indication to the other party of an acceptance.'4 The note's words 'upon an agreement' asked for a promise, and silent preparation is not one. The court's reasoning implies that conduct which did signal assent, such as starting work at the offeror's premises, might have come out differently.5
Courts once presumed that an offer ambiguous about the mode of reply required a promise. Modern doctrine has replaced that presumption with the recognition that in most cases the offeror is indifferent as to the manner of acceptance, so the offeree may proceed by performance or by promise.6 Section 32 states the result: in case of doubt, an offer invites acceptance either by promising to perform what it requests or by rendering the performance, as the offeree chooses.7 Section 62(1) then treats the tender or beginning of the invited performance as an acceptance by performance when the offer invites that choice.8 White therefore remains a clean illustration for an offer that plainly calls for a promise. Where the offer is indifferent between the two modes, a beginning accomplishes more, and the next two subsections explain how.
Acceptance by Promise
When the offer invites a promise as the response, Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 50(3) says when the offeree has given it: acceptance by a promise requires that the offeree complete every act essential to the making of the promise.10 Making a promise has a finish line. The offeree decides, expresses the decision, and then, if the offer or the medium requires it, signs, sends, or hands over whatever carries the expression to the offeror. Until the last of those acts is done, the offeree has an intention to promise but no promise, and the offeror holds no acceptance.
What counts as essential depends on the offer and the medium it calls for. An offer that asks for a spoken answer needs words actually addressed to the offeror, and an offer that asks for a signed writing needs the signature and the sending. The return promise must also manifest an intent to be bound, so a noncommittal reply that leaves the offeree free to walk away completes nothing.11 An acceptance generally must be communicated to the offeror. The one important exception, the dispatched acceptance or mailbox rule, makes a properly addressed acceptance effective as soon as it leaves the offeree's possession, provided it conforms to any method the offer prescribed.12 That exception answers a different question, when a sent acceptance takes effect. The question here comes first: has the offeree done the acts that make a promise at all?
The requirement serves both sides. An offeree can be held only to a promise already made, so requiring every essential act ensures the offeree has gone far enough to be bound and stays free to change course until then. For the offeror, acceptance ends the power to revoke and fixes the offeror's own obligation, so it must occur at a moment the offeror can identify. If a signed form sitting in a drawer counted, the offeror could revoke or resell in complete ignorance of a contract already formed.
The signature is the same in both scenes, and only the delivery differs. That one fact separates a bilateral contract from an offer still open to revocation. On an exam, the signed paper is the usual trap, and the first question to ask is where the paper is. When the offer invites performance instead of a promise, the test shifts to whether part of the requested act has been performed or tendered, which the next subsection takes up.
Acceptance by Performance
Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 50(2) sets the floor for the second mode of acceptance: acceptance by performance requires that at least part of what the offer requests be performed or tendered, and it includes acceptance by a performance which operates as a return promise.14 Acceptance by promise asks whether the offeree has completed every act that makes a promise. Performance has a different finish line. The question becomes whether the offeree has done at least part of the very act the offer requested, or has tendered it, meaning the offeree has offered to perform with present intention and ability to do so.15 Two phrases carry the doctrine: at least part fixes how much must happen, and what the offer requests fixes which act counts.
A part can be enough because requested acts take time. An arborist asked to cut down and remove a dead tree finishes only after hours of work, and if conduct counted only when the last cut was made, the offeree would work the whole job with nothing yet binding the offeror. The floor of at least part also protects the offeror, because it demands something visible that belongs to the bargain, so a private decision to go ahead cannot pass as an acceptance. A tender does the same work for the offeree who arrives willing and able to perform and offers to begin.
The part must be part of the requested act, and that limit follows from the role performance plays in the exchange. In the unilateral contract, the offeree accepts by rendering the very performance the contract requires, so the same act completes the offeree's duties and leaves the offeror alone with an outstanding promise.16 Classical contract law saw that rendering as doing double duty: it is both the consideration for the offeror's promise and the acceptance of the offer.17 An act can fill both roles only if it is the price the offeror sought. A different act, however useful, was never offered as the price and shows nothing about whether the offeree was answering this offer. This is the matching requirement applied to conduct, since a performance accepts only if the offer invites that performance.18
The trap on an exam is to treat good-faith effort aimed at the offeror's wishes as enough. Compare the act with what the offer requested first, and ask about motive or benefit afterward, if at all.
The second half of § 50(2) says that acceptance by performance includes a performance which operates as a return promise, and that clause explains how conduct can bind the offeree as well as the offeror. Where an offer invites the offeree to choose between promising and performing, § 62(1) makes the tender or beginning of the invited performance an acceptance by performance, and § 62(2) adds that such an acceptance operates as a promise to render complete performance.19 Consider Pauline, who leaves a voice mail offering Jamal, a painting contractor, $8,000 to paint her house by next week. Jamal does not respond, but the next day he sends employees to start painting, and a reasonable person would almost certainly read that conduct as saying, 'I accept your offer.'20 Jamal has said nothing, yet the beginning carries an implied promise to complete, and a bilateral contract binds both sides from the moment he began.21 Whether the offeror must also learn of the beginning is a separate question, taken up in the section on notice of acceptance.
That result depends on the offer having invited a choice. When an offer invites performance and does not invite a promissory acceptance, the offeree who begins has not promised to finish, and on the classical view is free to stop without liability.22 Section 45(1) protects that offeree differently, by creating an option contract when the offeree tenders or begins the invited performance.23 The later section on part performance develops both rules, along with the question of how a real beginning differs from getting ready to begin. Section 50(2) states the minimum for acceptance by performance, and what that minimum accomplishes depends on whether the offer invited a promise as well as a performance.