Concept
Lapse of Time
Termination of the power of acceptance and irrevocable offers
Lapse of Time
An offeree's power of acceptance can die without anyone lifting a finger. Lapse of time is one of the recognized ways the power terminates, and it stands apart from the other events in this chapter because it needs no act by either party.1 A rejection or counteroffer comes from the offeree. A revocation comes from the offeror, and once it takes effect the offeree cannot revive the offer by a later attempt to accept.2 Lapse arrives on its own when the offer's period runs out, so the offeree who waits too long loses the power without the offeror doing anything at all.
An offer does not last forever, and the law sets its clock in two ways. If the offeror states a time, that time governs. If the offeror states none, the power lasts for a reasonable time.3 Either way, the offeree gets a definite window to decide, and the offeror gets a point after which the offer can be treated as gone. A lapse problem therefore comes down to two questions: when did the period end, and was the power still alive when the offeree acted?
Stated Deadlines
The offeror created the power of acceptance and may decide how long it lasts.4 Under Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 41(1), the power ends at the time the offer specifies, and only when the offer names no time does the law substitute a reasonable one.5 A deadline is accordingly the first thing to look for in a lapse problem.
The stated time works as a firm edge because the offeror alone knows how long the proposal can safely stay outstanding. The offeror may be waiting on financing or courting another buyer. Once the deadline passes, the offeror may sell elsewhere or simply stop thinking about the deal. If an acceptance a day late could still bind, the deadline would give the offeror nothing to rely on.
A deadline can fail to say what it means. “Within five days” does not tell the reader whether the five days run from the date of the writing or from receipt, or at what hour the last day closes.6 An offer that names a date and an hour leaves nothing to dispute. An offeror who writes more loosely invites a dispute over when the power ended.
On an exam, an ambiguous period is an issue to argue. State both readings, apply each to the dates given, and say whether the outcome changes.
A deadline need not be a date. An offer may provide that the power ends when a certain event occurs. If the event happens before the acceptance, the power lapses even though the offeree has not been told. Offers of realty or unique goods that are “subject to prior sale” work this way.7
An acceptance that arrives after the deadline accepts nothing, because the power it would exercise has already ended. What it does accomplish depends on its content and the circumstances. It may be a futile act of no legal consequence, or it may be a new offer from the former offeree that gives the original offeror a power of acceptance.8 Authority divides on whether the original offeror's conduct can turn a late acceptance into a contract. Under the first view, the late acceptance is only an offer, which the original offeror may accept or let drop. A second view looks to whether the original offeror's intent to enter the contract is objectively manifested. A third, intermediate view applies when the acceptance is late but was sent in what could plausibly be argued to be a reasonable time. The original offeror then has a burden to reply within a reasonable time, and silence forms a contract. The theory is that the late acceptance is an offer, and the offeror accepts it by remaining silent when it would be reasonable to reply, because it is not clear to the offeree that the acceptance was late.9 Where the delay in transmission is apparent from the circumstances, the UN Convention on Sales requires the offeror to tell the offeree that the acceptance is too late. If the offeror does not, the parties are bound.10
The intermediate view turns on an acceptance that is plausibly timely, and a plainly stated date and hour leaves little room for that argument. The late acceptance in the warehouse hypothetical stays a new offer that the seller owes nothing to.
Reasonable Time
When an offer states no time, the power of acceptance ends at the end of a reasonable time.12 What counts as reasonable is a question of fact that depends on all the circumstances existing when the offer and the attempted acceptance are made.13 The factfinder asks how long a reasonable person in the offeree's position would believe the offer would stay open, or, put practically, how much time the offeree would need to receive, consider, and reply to it.14 The offeror who names no time takes a risk, because what is reasonable may stay unclear until litigation settles it.15
No fixed number of days controls. In stock or bond trading, a reasonable time may be only seconds; for an offer to build a nuclear power plant, it may be many months.16 The faster the subject matter can change in value, the less time a reasonable person would expect the offer to stay open. A common exam error is to announce a set period, such as a week, and apply it mechanically to the dates in the problem.
Courts weigh a recurring group of circumstances:
- whether the transaction is speculative;
- the offeror's manifest purpose;
- the nature of the subject matter and the identity and circumstances of the parties; and
- under the Restatement (Second), whether the offeree is acting in good faith.17
These factors do not combine by formula. In most problems the stability of the subject matter does the work, because it shows whether delay shifts risk onto the offeror.
The means of communication points the same way. A mailed offer has transit time built into it and probably concerns something without a volatile market, so on otherwise bare facts a twelve-day period for acceptance is not unreasonable.18
The offeror's purpose can also shorten the clock where no market price is moving. In Loring v. City of Boston, the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts denied recovery on a reward offer. A reward exists to excite the vigilance of the public and perhaps to alarm offenders, so it must be notorious to work. Three years and eight months was not a reasonable time. By then the offer had to be presumed forgotten by most officers and citizens, and it could not fairly have been understood as a motive for the plaintiffs' efforts.19
Offers made in direct conversation follow a convention that fixes the reasonable time in advance. An offer made face to face, by telephone, or in any other direct negotiation is deemed, absent a contrary manifestation of intention, to lapse when the conversation ends.20 In Akers v. J.B. Sedberry, Inc., an employee offered orally to resign while in a conference with his employer's president. The president ignored the offer, and the conference continued. A few days later the president wired that the offer was accepted and that the employee was to end his association with the firm. The court affirmed a decree for the employee, reciting the ordinary rule that a face-to-face offer continues only to the close of the conversation and cannot be accepted thereafter.21
The convention follows from how direct negotiation works. People who talk in each other's presence expect an answer before they part, and an offeree who wants time can ask for it. Suppose Sallie makes a $500,000 offer to Bonzo and three others at a face-to-face meeting, and Bonzo waits two weeks to accept. A reasonable time has almost certainly passed.22
The convention is a presumption, and other evidence can displace it. Stated as an absolute rule it is too rigid, and special circumstances may show a reasonable person that the offeror meant the offer to survive the conversation.23 The question remains how long a reasonable person in the offeree's position would think the offer stayed open.24
Offers that arrive by mail have a rule of their own. Under § 41(3), unless the language or the circumstances indicate otherwise, and subject to the rule stated in § 49, an offer sent by mail is seasonably accepted if an acceptance is mailed at any time before midnight on the day the offer is received.25 The rule gives the offeree a bright line where the general standard gives none. An offeree who opens a letter in the evening need not guess whether answering that night, the next morning, or a week later is reasonable. A reply posted by midnight on the day of receipt is safe, and the offeror who chose a slow medium has no ground to object.
The midnight rule marks a point at which acceptance is certainly timely. A later mailing may still be timely under the general standard, as the twelve-day acceptance of the lot offer showed, and contrary language or circumstances override the rule.