Concept
Death or Incapacity
Termination of the power of acceptance and irrevocable offers
Death or Incapacity
Death or incapacity ends an offeree's power of acceptance, whichever party suffers it. Under Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 48, the power terminates when the offeree or the offeror dies or is deprived of legal capacity to enter into the proposed contract.1 The Restatement lists the same event among the ways an offeree's power can end: death or incapacity of the offeror or offeree.2
Compare the offeree's own rejection. Sallie offers to sell her home to Bonzo for $500,000, and Bonzo, unimpressed, answers “no way.” A reasonable person would take those words as a rejection, so Bonzo's power of acceptance ends, and any later attempt to accept concludes no contract unless Sallie reinstates her offer.3 A rejection requires that someone say or do something. Death and incapacity require nothing of either party. They come from outside the bargaining, they end the power when they occur, and they can strike the offeror or the offeree alike.
The court in Dickinson v. Dodds treated the offeror's-death half of the rule as settled. It called it admitted law that an offer cannot be accepted after the man who made it has died, and it used that premise to decide the case. Dodds had offered to sell property, and the offeree learned that Dodds had sold it to someone else. Selling the property, the court reasoned, “has very much the same effect as the death of the owner,” because it makes performance of the offer impossible, so once the offeree knows of the sale it is too late to accept.4
Section 48 states the generally accepted rule, but Corbin saw no “compelling necessity for its existence.” If a man contracts to pay debts and then dies, he observed, “the law has no difficulty in creating legal relations with the dead man's personal representative,” and there would be no greater difficulty in declaring the power of acceptance to survive against the offeror's representative.5 The rule is also blunt about knowledge. It ends the power on the death or incapacity itself and says nothing about whether the other party has heard of it, so an offeree who accepts in ignorance accepts too late.6 Other parts of formation law do protect an offeree who cannot see that circumstances have changed. Where an acceptance is late because of a transmission delay that is apparent from the circumstances, the UN Convention on Sales requires the offeror to tell the offeree that the acceptance is too late, or the parties are bound.7 The death rule has no comparable step.
Timing marks the limit of the rule, because death or incapacity can end only a power that has not yet been exercised. If the offeror becomes mentally incompetent between the time of making the offer and the time of acceptance, the offer lapses. A mental disability that arises after acceptance, by contrast, does not affect formation of the contract.8 Death follows the same line. An acceptance delivered before the offeror dies has already formed a contract, and the death does not reopen formation. It may still affect obligations under the contract, depending on how pivotal the person's role in the enterprise, but that question is taken up later in the book.9
One exception to the rule is the option contract, which this chapter takes up with the irrevocable offers. The offeror's death or incapacity does not terminate the power of acceptance under an option contract.10 The Restatement says so directly. The power under an option is not ended by rejection, counter-offer, revocation, or the offeror's death or incapacity, unless the requirements are met for the discharge of a contractual duty.11