Concept
Failed Conditions of Acceptance
Termination of the power of acceptance and irrevocable offers
Failed Conditions of Acceptance
An offeree's power of acceptance also ends when a condition of acceptance written into the offer does not occur.1 A condition of acceptance is a term that makes the power depend on a stated event. If the event does not happen, the power is gone, and nothing remains to accept.
This ending asks less of everyone than the others do. When Bonzo answered Sallie's $500,000 offer with "no way," his words, which a reasonable person would hear as a rejection, ended his power of acceptance, and a later "acceptance" would conclude no contract unless Sallie reinstated her offer.2 A rejection takes an act by the offeree. A failed condition takes no act by anyone. The event named in the offer does not occur, the offeror need not say a word, and the offeree need not do anything.
Notice is unnecessary because the condition travels with the offer. The offeree received the term along with the proposal, so the offeree already knew the offer would live only if the event happened. The offeror gains from this too. When a willingness to deal depends on facts outside the offeror's control, the offer can say so instead of promising to stay open whatever happens.
The question in these cases is whether the offeror made the event a term of the offer or only explained why the offer was being made.
The two offers rest on the same event, so the difference lies entirely in the offer's words. Priya's words tied the offer to the approval, while Marcus's words said only why he was selling. Because the power ends when a condition under the terms of the offer fails, a reason the offeror merely mentioned does not end it. An offeror who wants a condition can write one in.
Some conditions work silently, and the best known is the offer made "subject to prior sale." If the event occurs before the acceptance, the power of acceptance lapses even though the offeree is never told that it occurred.3 Offers for real estate and for unique goods commonly carry this language.4 A one-of-a-kind item can be sold only once, and the words tell every offeree that a completed sale to someone else ends the offer. Without that language, a sale to another buyer is only definite action inconsistent with the offer, and it ends the offeree's power when the offeree acquires reliable information of it, not before.5
On an exam, look first in the offer for words that make acceptance depend on an event, such as a prerequisite, a contingency, or a prior-sale reservation. If those words are there and the event failed before the acceptance, the power is gone without any message from the offeror. If the offeror only mentioned a reason, the offer is unaffected. The common errors run in both directions. Some students demand notice to the offeree for a failed condition, which the rule does not require. Others treat any mentioned motive as a condition, which the rule does not allow.