Concept
Applying the Checklist
Termination of the power of acceptance and irrevocable offers
Applying the Checklist
An offeree's power of acceptance ends in one of five ways: rejection or counteroffer by the offeree1, lapse of time2, revocation by the offeror3, death or incapacity of the offeror or offeree4, or the non-occurrence of a condition of acceptance written into the offer.5 Reciting the list is the easy half of an exam answer. The harder half is seeing that each event works through its own trigger, and that an acceptance succeeds only if the power was still alive when the acceptance took effect. Every problem in this chapter therefore reduces to one question, asked in time order: by the moment the offeree acted, had the trigger for any terminating event occurred?
Messages drive most of the triggers, and the law treats them unevenly. An acceptance sent by an authorized or otherwise reasonable medium takes effect on dispatch, while a direct revocation takes effect only when the offeree receives it.6 The reason is who carries the risk. The offeror chose, or at least did not forbid, the means of communication, and the offeror could have required that an acceptance be received to be effective. An offeror who did neither bears the risk that an acceptance will be delayed or lost, and nothing places that risk on the offeree.7 A revocation that has not arrived therefore cannot end a power the offeree has already used.
The triggers differ enough to keep side by side. Matching each event to its trigger tells you what, if anything, must have reached the offeree:
- A rejection or counteroffer ends the power. A mailed one does so only when the offeror receives it, and an acceptance mailed after it is only a counteroffer unless the acceptance reaches the offeror first.8
- Lapse needs no message. The power ends at the time the offer specifies or, if it specifies none, at the end of a reasonable time.9 What is reasonable turns on the circumstances: an offer made in person traditionally lapses when the conversation ends, though special circumstances may show that the offeror meant to keep it open longer.10
- A direct revocation ends the power when the offeree receives from the offeror a manifestation of an intention not to enter the proposed contract.11
- An indirect revocation ends the power when the offeror takes definite action inconsistent with entering the contract and the offeree acquires reliable information of it. Unlike a direct revocation, the rule does not require that the information come from the offeror.12
- When an offer was made by advertisement or other general notification, the power ends when a notice of termination receives publicity equal to that given the offer and no better means of notification is reasonably available.13
- Death or incapacity of either party ends the power when it occurs; the rule says nothing about notice to the other side.14
- A failed condition ends the power when the event the offer made a condition does not occur, with no act or notice from the offeror required.15
Exam writers like to give one offeree two offers and let her accept both, with one acceptance binding and the other failing. Often a single fact about what the offeree held when she acted explains the difference.
Start with Shore. The moment of acceptance is Friday. Tenant did not reject or counter, the week had not run, no one died, and the offer stated no condition. Shore sent no message, so the only live question is indirect revocation. His lease to another renter was definite action inconsistent with renting the same house to Tenant for the same summer, and Tenant acquired reliable information of it on Thursday, before she acted.16 That the news came from an agent and not from Shore does not matter, because the rule asks only that the offeree acquire reliable information. Tenant's power ended on Thursday, so her Friday letter finds nothing to accept. It forms no contract unless Shore chooses to take it up as a new offer.
Cliff's offer comes out the other way because his revocation is direct, and step three asks when Tenant received it. She received it on May 18, a day after her acceptance became operative. A revocation is ineffective until received, and an acceptance sent by an authorized means is effective on dispatch, so the power was alive on May 17 and a contract formed that day.17 Cliff decided to withdraw first, but a decision that has not reached the offeree ends nothing, and the cost of a slow mail service falls on the party who chose to use it. Both offerors had changed their minds before Tenant answered, and neither had told her directly. What separates the results is what Tenant held when she acted: reliable information of Shore's lease in one case, and only a letter still in transit in the other. An answer that dates each withdrawal from the offeror's own act would treat the two scenes alike and get one of them wrong.
Shore's one-week deadline does not rescue Tenant at step four. A reply date fixes when the power lapses, and lapse is only one of the ways the power ends. The week limits the power without shielding it from revocation. None of the routes to irrevocability is present either: Shore made no promise to hold the offer open, and Tenant gave nothing for one, so there is no option contract; no signed writing recites a consideration for keeping the offer open; Tenant took no substantial action in reliance before she accepted; and she began no invited performance.18 Shore kept his common-law power to withdraw. An option would have changed step four completely. Had Tenant paid for Shore's promise to hold the offer open, his lease to the other renter would not have ended her power of acceptance, and her Friday acceptance would have formed a contract.19
An exam answer should show its work in the order the steps run: the offer and the date of acceptance, then only the events the facts raise, then the trigger for each, then the exceptions. A mailed rejection sends the analysis to the race between rejection and acceptance. The offeror's death sends it to the moment of death. A sale to someone else sends it to what the offeree had learned. The events the facts do not raise deserve a clause, not a paragraph. The exceptions deserve at least a sentence whenever the offer was supposedly held open, because a stated reply date and a promise supported by consideration are different things.