Concept
The Past Consideration Problem
Promise to pay a debt discharged in bankruptcy
Promises to Pay Discharged Debts
The Past Consideration Problem
An American court enforces a promise when the promisor made it in exchange for something: a return promise, an act, or a forbearance.1 That bargained-for something is consideration. Without it, or a substitute such as promissory estoppel, a promise is generally unenforceable.2 The requirement carries a timing rule inside it, because the promisee's act or promise must be given in exchange for the promisor's promise.
The timing rule causes trouble when the promisee acts first. An act done or a promise given by the promisee before the promisor makes the promise sought to be enforced is past consideration, and it does not support the new promise because the promisee did not give it in exchange for that promise.3 The sequence explains why. The promisee acted with no promise in view, so no promise induced the act, and the promisor's later words were not the price of anything. What remains is a promise to reward a kindness, and a promise without consideration is generally not enforced.4
Mills v. Wyman shows the problem at its plainest. The plaintiff cared for the defendant's adult son, who was ill and destitute. After the son died, the defendant promised to reimburse the plaintiff and then refused to pay. The court held for the defendant, because the care came first and the promise was not its price. Read together with Webb v. McGowin, the case teaches that moral obligation can support a promise without traditional consideration only when the promisor has been personally benefited or enriched by the promisee's sacrifice, so that the promisee has a just and reasonable claim for compensation.5 The benefit in Mills went to the son, and the father received nothing himself. A later unit returns to that benefit-based exception.
The law does not apply the past-consideration rule to every earlier obligation. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 83 makes an express promise to pay all or part of a debt of the promisor, discharged or dischargeable in bankruptcy proceedings begun before the promise is made, binding.6 The standard statement of the past-consideration rule carries the same exception: a new promise to pay a debt barred by limitations or discharged in bankruptcy is enforceable even though the earlier benefit was not given in exchange for it.7
The difference between the two promises is the earlier debt. When a debt is discharged, creditors are forbidden to collect the balance, yet the doctrine of moral obligation validates a later promise by the debtor to pay it.8 A debtor's later promise can also be paired with something new. In Levine v. Blumenthal the question was whether the debtor gave additional consideration adequate to support an ordinary contract, meaning something the debtor was not already legally bound to do or give. Paying part of the debt before maturity, or at a place other than the one the debtor was bound to pay, qualifies.9 A promise supported that way is an ordinary bargain and needs no exception.
The exceptions go by the name “moral obligation,” and the name misleads. In most situations a promise without consideration is not binding even though the promisor had a moral obligation to perform it. To say that a person has a moral obligation usually means that the person has a moral responsibility and no legal one.10 The doctrine stays narrow because nearly every promise to reward a past kindness springs from some sense of duty or gratitude, and a general rule enforcing such promises would leave the consideration requirement with nothing to do. The law instead recognizes three widely accepted situations: a promise to pay a debt barred by the statute of limitations, a promise to pay a debt discharged in bankruptcy, and a promise to pay an avoidable debt.11 In each, a debtor promises to honor an earlier obligation that the law would no longer enforce or that the debtor could avoid. The rest of this section follows the bankruptcy exception, with the other two appearing beside it for comparison.