Concept
Applying Section 83
Promise to pay a debt discharged in bankruptcy
Applying Section 83
Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 83 binds a debtor to an express promise to pay all or part of an indebtedness that bankruptcy proceedings, begun before the promise was made, discharged or could discharge.1 A problem on the subject seldom says which words of that rule are in dispute, so test them in a fixed order and stop at the first failure. The order below takes the common-law elements first, which eliminates weak claims early, and then the Bankruptcy Code and state-law layers that sit on top. The discharge protects the debtor from being compelled to pay a debt honestly due, and a new promise removes that impediment.2 Each step screens for the same thing: a clear promise by the debtor, made on terms the statutes allow.
Steps one through three decide whether the common-law exception applies and how large it is. Steps four and five ask whether a statute lets a promise that satisfies § 83 operate. The two kinds of failure carry different consequences. When no proceeding had begun or no express promise was made, the exception is unavailable, and the promise needs some other basis for enforcement. When a federal or state condition is missing, the promise has every element of § 83 and still cannot be enforced on that rule alone. An answer that stops after step three has finished the common-law stage and skipped the layers that control in practice.
Step two draws the most wrong answers, because a debtor who pays a little or admits the debt looks as if she has accepted liability. Regret, an acknowledgment that the debt exists, or a token payment shows that she remembers the debt; none of them commits her to pay it. The question is whether her words bound her. If they did, she need not have understood the legal effect of the earlier transaction; it is enough that she knew, or had reason to know, its essential facts.8
The harder exam question arises when the creditor's only evidence is a small payment.
Both debtors held the same discharge, and both showed that they remembered the debt. What separates them is words that bind. That is why step two deserves the most care, and why the later steps matter only after it is passed.