Concept
The Common-Law Revocation Rule
Offer made irrevocable by statute
Statutory Firm Offers
The Common-Law Revocation Rule
At common law the offeror controls an offer until someone accepts it, and may withdraw it at any time before acceptance.1 A direct revocation, which is the offeror's manifestation of intent not to enter into the contract, takes effect on receipt.2 An offeree who has not accepted by the time it arrives has nothing left to accept.
A promise to keep the offer open does not change this by itself. On January 17 a seller writes a buyer offering to sell a piano for $400 and promising to hold the offer open until January 31. The buyer pays nothing for the promise. On January 20 the seller phones to say the piano is no longer for sale, and on January 22 the buyer answers, "I accept." The acceptance fails. The phone call revoked the offer when the buyer received it, and the promise to hold the offer open was gratuitous. Without consideration for it, a promise not to revoke does not make an offer irrevocable.3
The buyer could have bought those eleven days. Suppose the buyer had paid $10 for the promise. The exchange would make the promise enforceable as an option contract, because enforcing a promise not to revoke requires consideration or some other basis for enforcement.4 The January 20 call would then revoke nothing, and the reason is the difference between the right to revoke and the power to revoke. If the law took away only the right, the revocation would be wrongful but still effective. The buyer could not accept and would hold only a claim for money damages for breach of the promise not to revoke. An option contract takes away the power as well. The attempted revocation is void, the buyer's acceptance forms a contract, and the remedies for breach of that contract can include specific performance.5 Specific performance means an order requiring the defendant to exchange performances as originally agreed. It is the simplest way to protect the buyer's expectation, but it is often unavailable, as when the defendant is simply unable to perform what she promised.6
A deadline does not turn a gratuitous promise into an option either. When an offeror wrote that an offer was "left over until Friday," the court treated the undertaking as a promise without consideration. The deadline therefore made the offer expire automatically on the date named, and it did nothing more.7 Where the offeror names no time, the offer stays open for a reasonable time. That period asks how long a reasonable person would believe the offer would stay open, given all the circumstances.8 Both rules mark when an offer dies of its own accord, and neither stops the offeror from ending it sooner by revocation.
Requiring payment fits how options work in commercial life. An option is a valuable right in itself. If the property rises in value, the holder exercises the option and eliminates the offeror's interest; if it falls, the holder lets the option lapse and the loss falls on the offeror.9 Because the option shifts that risk, the owner of marketable investment property is unlikely to grant one without demanding a premium. Offers are therefore presumed revocable unless a fee is paid to the offeror.10
The offerees in Normile v. Miller believed they held an option, meaning an offer they could delay accepting without losing the power of acceptance, even if the seller tried to revoke her counteroffer in the meantime. They were wrong, in part because the court found that she had never expressly promised not to revoke.11 The two cases fail at different points. In the "left over until Friday" case a promise existed but no consideration supported it, while in Normile the court found no express promise at all. An offeree who wants to hold an offeror to an offer must be able to point to both a promise not to revoke and a reason to enforce it.
The common law's starting point is not universal. Under most of the world's legal systems, offers are irrevocable for the stated period or a reasonable one, and an offeror avoids that result only by expressly reserving the right to revoke. The common law begins from the opposite premise that all offers are revocable. When the offeror revokes before acceptance, the offeree must establish some reason why this particular offer should be treated as irrevocable.12
The offeree has three ways to carry that burden.13 The first is the option contract just described, in which the offeree gave consideration for the promise to hold the offer open. The second is a statute that makes the offer irrevocable.14 The third is reliance. An offer that the offeror should reasonably expect to induce action or forbearance of a substantial character before acceptance, and that does induce it, is binding as an option contract to the extent necessary to avoid injustice.15 The sections that follow take up the statutory route.