Concept
Working a Modification Problem
Statute of Frauds and oral modification
Working a Modification Problem
An oral change to a written contract is easiest to handle as a sequence, because each rule in this chapter answers a different question and each question assumes the one before it. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 149(1) comes first. It treats a contract that modifies but does not rescind a prior contract as containing the originally agreed terms as modified, and it adds that the statute may apply independently of those terms when the modification transfers property.1 Two other rules attach to it at either end. Section 149(2) says what remains when the change fails the statute, and § 150 covers an oral release of a duty or condition under an enforceable contract.2 The tempting error is to grab whichever rule looks closest. The better course is to run the steps below in order.
Each step settles a premise that the next one uses. Coverage comes first because § 150 applies only to an enforceable contract, and because a sale of goods moves the analysis to the Code. The modification-or-rescission question precedes the as-modified test because a rescission leaves no continuing contract to assemble. The writing question precedes the reliance questions because the reliance rules relax a requirement of form, and a change that satisfies the form, or that falls outside the statute once modified, never needs relaxing.
Step three is where problems most often go wrong. An oral contract that began outside the statute may still need a writing for its change. The contract as modified may have crossed into a covered class, as when a six-month project is stretched to eighteen months or a goods price rises from $400 to $600. Or the modifying promise may itself transfer an interest in land.6 A student who reasons that the original oral contract needed no writing, and so its adjustment needs none, has applied only the first sentence of § 149(1). The sequence also tests form alone. Whether the change is supported by consideration is a separate question, and a change can clear every step here and still fail on that ground.
The last two steps express one idea about fairness through different doors. Under § 149(2), the prior contract stays unmodified only where there has been no material change of position in reliance on the failed change. Section 150 enforces an oral release of a duty or condition when reinstating the original terms would be unjust in view of such reliance.7 For a sale of goods, UCC §§ 2-209(4) and (5) supply the same protection: an oral modification that fails for want of a writing can still be enforced where material reliance has occurred and would make a retraction unjust.8 Which door applies depends on the subject matter and on what the oral words did, so an exam answer should state the characterization in step six expressly.
A sale of goods shows the whole sequence at full length.
Retraction is the only question left, and it turns on what the other party did after hearing the oral extension and before receiving notice that the original date would be required. A seller that has reorganized its performance in reliance on a buyer's oral agreement to accept late delivery has changed position in a way that cannot be undone. Retraction would then be unjust, and the buyer cannot insist on the original date.9
Both oral extensions fail as modifications, both survive as waivers until retracted, and both travel through steps one to four identically. They separate only at the end, on whether the other party changed position before the retraction arrived. Outside Article 2, the same reliance would carry § 150. An oral release of a delivery duty or closing condition under a covered contract is enforceable when reinstating the original terms would be unjust in view of a material change of position in reliance on it, and the original terms govern when no such reliance exists.10