Concept
Voidable and Unenforceable Contracts
Incapacity to contract
Voidable and Unenforceable Contracts
Two labels recur in the capacity cases, and the Restatement defines each by a different feature. A voidable contract is one in which one or more parties have the power, by a manifestation of election to do so, to avoid the legal relations the contract created, or by ratification to extinguish that power of avoidance.1 An unenforceable contract is one whose breach supports neither damages nor specific performance, yet which the law recognizes in some other way as creating a duty of performance, even though no one has ratified it.2
One definition rests on a power and the other on closed remedies, so the labels are not synonyms. Voidable answers the question who controls the bargain: one party may undo it or confirm it, and the counterparty holds no comparable option. Unenforceable answers the question what a court will do for the party who sues: the usual remedies are closed, though the duty is still recognized in some other way. A student who runs the two together misstates both rules.
Most of the capacity doctrines that follow use the first label. Infancy and mental impairment give the protected person a power to avoid. Guardianship by adjudication is harsher, because a person whose property is under guardianship by reason of an adjudication of mental illness or defect has no capacity to incur contractual duties at all.3 The guardianship section develops that contrast. This section fixes the two definitions so that the later results can be stated precisely.
Voidable Contracts
A voidable contract exists from the moment of assent and binds both sides until the holder of the power acts, because the power operates on legal relations the contract created.4 Infancy shows the point. An infant has the power to form a contract, the contract is enforceable by the infant against the other party, and the infant may avoid it at the infant's option.5
The power of avoidance belongs to the protected party and to those who step into that party's place. For an infant it resides in the infant or, after death, in the infant's heirs, administrators, or executors, and occasional decisions let a parent or guardian disaffirm when the infant is not emancipated.6 For a person with a mental impairment, the power of avoidance and ratification belongs to that person, to a guardian if one has been appointed, and after death to the heirs or personal representative.7 The competent party holds no comparable power, so an adult who dealt with a minor or an impaired person cannot invoke the other's condition to escape the deal.8
The one-sided design follows from the purpose of capacity rules, which protect a person against improvident commitments while leaving that person free to keep a good bargain.9 A party with a defense may avoid the contract, and may just as well choose to enforce it against the other side.10 A rule that let the competent party avoid would turn a shield into a weapon, and a rule that made the contract void would erase even the deals the protected party wants. The one-sided power does cost the protected party something: adults often refuse to contract with a minor, because a minor cannot give legal assurance that the contract will not be avoided.11
The merchant made the common mistake of treating a minor's contract as invalid for everyone. The contract binds the adult from the start, and the minor decides whether it binds the minor. That asymmetry is what the label voidable captures.
Ratification is the other half of the definition. When the holder confirms the contract, the power of avoidance ends and an ordinary binding contract remains.12 A person who recovers from incompetence may ratify by words or by conduct, and the ratification is irrevocable.13 Silence can do the same work: a former infant who fails to disaffirm within the appropriate time after reaching majority ratifies by default, and the contract binds from then on.14 The later sections on infancy and mental illness apply these ideas, including what counts as disaffirmance, how long a reasonable time lasts, and which conduct amounts to ratification.
Because a voidable contract has legal effect until someone avoids it, it can pass rights to strangers. If property transferred to or by an infant has been resold to a good-faith purchaser for value, that purchaser takes good title, and avoidance can no longer defeat it. This is one of the few situations in which a transferor with voidable title can transfer better title than the transferor held, and for goods UCC § 2–403 says the same.15 Negotiable instruments follow a parallel logic. A holder in due course, meaning a good-faith taker who gave value for the instrument, defeats the maker's personal defenses but not real ones. For incapacity other than infancy, the question is whether the governing law makes the obligation entirely null and void (a real defense) or merely voidable at the obligor's election (a personal defense).16
Unenforceable Contracts
An unenforceable contract is one whose breach supports neither damages, which compensate the promisee in money, nor specific performance, which orders the promisor to perform, but which is recognized in some other way as creating a duty of performance, though there has been no ratification.18 The second clause keeps the label from meaning that nothing happened. The promise is not erased, and the law still treats it as creating a duty, even though a court will use neither principal breach remedy to compel or compensate performance.
The statute of frauds illustrates the pattern. It operates as a defense: where it applies, the defendant must raise it in the answer, and only then must the plaintiff prove that the statute is satisfied for the contract at issue.19 A plaintiff who relies on an oral promise within the statute's reach and cannot satisfy it recovers neither damages nor specific performance, yet the law may still recognize some duty arising from the promise. That result fits the definition clause for clause: the remedies are closed, and the duty is not wholly extinguished. The statute receives its own treatment elsewhere, and what matters here is the label its effect carries.
The capacity cases sit on the other side of the line. A voidable contract has legal effect from assent, and its relations stay in force until the holder manifests an election to avoid them or ratifies and extinguishes the power.20 Its defect is a power held by one party, and everything depends on whether that party uses it. An unenforceable contract has a different defect, a closed remedy, and the definition mentions no election and no holder of any power.21
Two wrong questions lead to wrong labels. Ask who may undo the bargain in a statute of frauds problem, and you find no holder of an avoidance power, which tempts you to call the contract fully valid. Ask whether a remedy is available in a minor's contract, and you find one, which tempts you to call the contract enforceable without qualification and to forget the minor's power to avoid. Sorting takes the questions one at a time.
Both buyers walk away from a bargain, yet the legal pictures differ at the root. The land buyer escapes because the plaintiff's remedies are closed. The car buyer escapes only by exercising a personal power the seller lacks. The distinction carries into the sections ahead, because the infancy and mental-illness rules turn on who may avoid and what conduct ends that power.