Concept
Contracting With Oneself
Incapacity to contract
Contracting With Oneself
The capacity rules ask whether a particular person can bind himself. This last limit asks whether the deal has a second person in it at all. A contract needs at least two parties, a promisor and a promisee, though it may have any greater number.1 The promisor makes the promise and takes on the duty. The promisee receives the promise and may demand performance. The law counts the inability to contract with oneself beside infancy and mental infirmity as a limit on who may form a contract.2
Two is a floor, not a ceiling. The floor follows from what a promise does: it creates a duty that runs to someone. When one individual holds both positions, nobody else has a claim, so there is no one to sue and no one wronged by nonperformance. Above two, nothing changes. An agreement among three neighbors or thirty investors works as long as the parties never number fewer than two.
Courts of equity have long enforced contracts between an individual and a group of individuals that includes him. A member of an unincorporated club may contract with the club, and a partner may contract with the partnership. In each case the member is both a promisor and a promisee in the relationship.3 The member's dual role looks like Wen's, but the other side of the deal is different. It is a group of individuals, and the group includes people besides the member. The exception covers those individual-and-group arrangements. It does not give one person a general power to contract alone.
The two scenes differ in who sits opposite the promisor. Wen's paper has no one there. Imani's agreement has a club made up of people other than herself. On an exam, a stem that shows one person on both sides of a promise, with no one else involved, calls for the conclusion that no contract exists. A stem that shows a member dealing with an unincorporated club, or a partner dealing with the partnership, calls for the equitable exception.