Concept
Why Undue Influence Exists
Undue influence
Undue Influence
Why Undue Influence Exists
A court asked to enforce a contract looks first at what the parties outwardly manifested, and that objective test has an obvious weakness: a manifestation of assent can be extracted by improper means. Misrepresentation, duress, undue influence, and unconscionability exist to repair that weakness. Each lets a court go behind a party's manifestation of assent when the other party's improper conduct in forming the contract induced it.1 In essence, they are safety valves for the objective test, which keep it from becoming a tool of oppression, deceit, or advantage-taking.2 They do not depend on negotiation. They apply whether or not the parties bargained, and they commonly reach standard contracts that one side imposed with no chance for the other to bargain over terms.3
The reason these doctrines carry weight lies in the assumption that makes contracts worth enforcing: each side expects to gain. A seller accepts $200,000 for Blackacre because the money is worth more to her than the land, and the buyer pays it because the land is worth more to him than the money.4 That assumption collapses if the buyer's apparent preference was voiced at gunpoint, or if the seller lied about planned developments nearby.5 The assumption fails in those cases not because someone's judgment was unsound but because the other party's wrongful conduct distorted it.6 A buyer who merely misjudged the land's value is in a different position, since nobody bent his judgment. Undue influence is the version of the distortion that works through persuasion rather than threat or lie.
One view, more contested than the rest of this account, adds that a defense must describe comparatively unusual circumstances. If the facts that establish a defense were common, few claims for breach of contract would succeed, and the cause of action would lose its point.7 That helps explain why undue influence is a narrow doctrine, and the hypothetical below shows the line it draws.
The doctrine's history explains why it targets abuse of dominance and trust. Courts of equity originated undue influence as a ground for setting aside a transaction that a dominant party had imposed on a subservient party.8 The typical case involved no unlawful threat, but one party held a particularly strong influence over the other and abused it to obtain a disadvantageous contract.9 In practice, equity generally acted only when the influence arose between family members or within a confidential or fiduciary relationship, such as lawyer and client or trustee and beneficiary.10 In the nineteenth century, equity also used the concept to grant relief on grounds akin to duress that did not fit the rigid Blackstonian definition of duress the common law employed.11
That second function later became unnecessary. In the twentieth century, the expanded concept of duress and the wide recognition of unconscionability gave courts enough tools to regulate bargaining generally, so undue influence could stay confined to relationships of dependence and trust, as Restatement (Second) § 177 reflects.12 In most states the doctrine kept that specific character.13 Its gist today is unfair persuasion rather than coercion, and the victim's state of mind is often euphoria rather than fear.14 The emphasis falls on the unfairness of the advantage the influencer gained, not on the victim's want of consent.15 Older precedents decided under the broader approach are still quoted often enough to confuse the profession.16 The focus on trust also separates undue influence from its nearest neighbor: duress gives relief to someone whose assent an unlawful threat induced, while undue influence concerns abuse of trust.17
Where the relationship is fiduciary, the doctrine protects the dependent party with unusual strictness. If a contract between fiduciary and beneficiary produces an unfair result for the beneficiary, a court will set it aside on grounds of undue influence, and the beneficiary need not show further wrongdoing such as conscious advantage-taking. Entering the unfair bargain is the only misconduct required.18 A lawyer who buys a farm from an estate she represents has a bet she cannot win: if the farm falls in value she bears the loss, and if it rises the sale is apt to be set aside, and good motives are no defense.19
The remedy is avoidance, which puts the decision in the victim's hands rather than the influencer's. Under § 177(2), when a party's manifestation of assent is induced by the other party's undue influence, the contract is voidable by the victim.20 A voidable contract is one in which a party holds the power to elect to avoid the legal relations the contract created, or by ratification to extinguish that power. The same power sometimes belongs to minors and to people induced to contract by undue influence, fraud, mistake, or duress.21 The influencer cannot invoke her own overreaching to escape the deal.
Section 177(1) supplies the definition the rest of this chapter takes apart: undue influence is unfair persuasion of a party who is under the persuader's domination, or who, because of the relationship between them, is justified in assuming that the persuader will not act inconsistently with his welfare.22 The chapter next examines each element of that definition, then how a challenger proves it, what happens when the influence comes from someone outside the contract, and how undue influence differs from duress, incapacity, fraud, and unconscionability.