Concept
Avoidance and Equitable Discretion
Mutual mistake
Avoidance and Equitable Discretion
Proving a mutual mistake does not end the case, because the remedy has limits of its own. When both parties share a mistake about a basic assumption and the mistake materially affects the agreed exchange, Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 152(1) makes the contract voidable by the adversely affected party, unless that party bears the risk of the mistake under § 154.1 Once those elements are met, three questions remain: who controls the choice, what each side gets back if the contract is avoided, and whether the court will grant the remedy at all.
Only the Adversely Affected Party May Avoid
The word voidable answers the first question. The contract stands until the adversely affected party acts, so only that party may raise the defense, and a party who finds that the deal has turned out well may simply enforce it.2 If the party does avoid, each side holds a restitution claim for any benefit it conferred on the other.3 The defense disappears altogether when the adversely affected party bears the risk of the mistake, as when the parties allocated that risk to it by agreement.4
Restitution Returns Benefits, Not Reliance Costs
Avoidance ends the contract but leaves benefits in the wrong hands, and restitution moves them back. The classic statement of the rescission rule builds this in: a contract made under a mutual mistake as to an essential fact that induced it may be rescinded on discovery of the mistake if the parties can be placed in their former position with reference to its subject matter.5 Restoring each side to where it started keeps either from pocketing a windfall that a shared misunderstanding created. The measure is not mechanical. If the party who conferred a benefit was more to blame for the mistake, a court may confine the value of consumed goods or services to the actual economic benefit the other party ultimately enjoyed.6
Renner v. Kehl shows where restitution stops. The purchasers there had rescinded for mutual mistake and sought, along with their down payment, the $229,649.84 they had spent developing the land. The court held that, absent fraud or misrepresentation, a party who rescinds may not recover consequential damages.7 Rescission for mutual mistake implies that neither party was at fault. Charging the sellers with the development costs would therefore have shifted the entire risk of the mistake onto them, which is incompatible with equitable rescission.8
The purchasers still recovered something beyond the down payment. They were entitled to the down payment, plus the amount by which their efforts increased the value of the sellers' property, minus the fair rental value of the land during their occupancy.9 That measure follows from what restitution is for. It reverses an enrichment, so only spending that left the sellers' land worth more counts, and the purchasers' own use of the land is a benefit they must pay for. Spending that improved nothing did nothing for the sellers, and it stays with the purchasers as a loss sunk into a project both sides believed sound.
Rescission Is a Matter of Equitable Discretion
Whether rescission is available at all is a separate question, and the answer rests partly with the court's discretion. Lenawee County Board of Health v. Messerly states the principle: rescission is an equitable remedy granted only in the sound discretion of the court, and a court need not grant it in every case in which the mutual mistake relates to a basic assumption and materially affects the agreed performance of the parties.10 Where two equally innocent parties share a mistake, the court must decide, in the exercise of its equitable powers, which blameless party should assume the loss from the misapprehension they shared.11 A claimant who proves every element can therefore still lose the remedy.
The two decisions mark different limits. Renner limits what rescission returns, and Lenawee limits whether the court will order rescission at all. A student who treats proof of the elements as the end of the analysis misses both limits, because the last step asks which innocent party carries the loss and how much of it rescission can move.
Reformation Is the Alternative Remedy
Rescission is not the only equitable response to a mutual mistake. Reformation conforms the agreement to the parties' true intentions and, unlike rescission, does not terminate the contract.12 Its purpose is to rectify an inaccuracy in the written terms so that they match the parties' original understanding, and the prime illustration is a mutual mistake of material fact about the description or quantity of the subject matter.13 In Donohue v. Picinich the buyers believed they were purchasing land that included a pond, which in fact lay on an adjoining lot, while the seller's attorney had mistakenly drafted the contract to cover that whole lot. The court reformed the contract so the buyers received the pond and the seller kept the rest of the lot, a result that neither avoidance nor enforcement as written would have produced.14
A court may also reform where the mistaken term is an adjustable one and avoidance would be disruptive. In Aluminum Co. of America v. Essex Group, Inc., the parties adopted a pricing formula believing it would accurately predict Alcoa's costs, and the price it produced fell far short of Alcoa's cost of performance. The court refused to let Alcoa avoid the whole contract, because that would have deprived Essex of its bargain and handed Alcoa a full release as a windfall. It adjusted the price term instead, giving Alcoa a profit in line with the parties' reasonable expectations.15
Conduct After Discovery Can Defeat Avoidance
Equity also expects a party who wants out to act consistently with that choice. Ratification of the transaction after learning of the mistake is a recognized defense, and so is undue delay in manifesting an intent to avoid.16 A party who keeps using the property as an owner after discovering the truth has treated the contract as valid. A party who waits holds an option to walk away if matters worsen while the other side goes on relying on the deal. The avoiding party's duty to offer to restore what it received follows essentially the same principles as in avoidance for misrepresentation.17
The payee's conduct can matter as well. A detrimental change of position in reliance on a mistaken payment may estop a claim to restitution, but merely spending the money does not qualify unless the payee shows the expenditure would not have been made from other funds.18 A payee who used a mistaken overpayment to pay off her mortgage had not detrimentally changed position, because her net worth rose as a result.19