Concept
What Counts as Mistake
Unilateral mistake
Unilateral Mistake and Avoidance
What Counts as Mistake
In everyday speech, a mistake can be almost any choice that went badly: buying an ugly chair, backing a startup that flopped, sitting through a tedious movie.1 Contract law uses the word far more narrowly. The Restatement (Second) of Contracts defines a mistake as “a belief that is not in accord with the facts.”2 The belief need not have been put into words. A party who merely takes something for granted, without ever considering an alternative, holds a belief about it for this purpose.3
Everything the doctrine later does depends on a gap between what a party assumed and what was true, and the facts that count are those that existed when the contract was made.4 A buyer who agrees on Tuesday to purchase a commodity at a fixed price may feel foolish when the market drops on Thursday. But on Tuesday there was no existing fact for either party to misjudge. The buyer made a prediction, and the prediction failed.5 Later events may support other defenses, such as impracticability or frustration of purpose, but they are not properly treated under the law of mistake.6
The limit protects what contracts are for. Parties often use them to divide the risks of an uncertain future. When they deliberately and expressly allocate those risks, or enter a customary contract that has that effect, little room remains for judicial relief from the resulting losses.7 If every disappointed prediction counted as a mistake, every bad bargain would become a defense. Contracts are made to be performed, and relief on the ground of mistake is the exception.8
A horse sale shows where the line falls. Two people agree on a $40,000 price, both thinking the horse is sound and can win races. If the horse has a broken bone in its leg, they share a mistake of fact. If the bones are fine but the horse has run its last good race and never wins again, there is no mistake of fact. The error was one of judgment about the horse's capabilities, or a prediction of what it would do.9 The same split appears in a hauling job. A mover who prices the work believing a pile of dirt holds 800 cubic yards, when it holds 1,000, holds a belief contrary to a present fact. That is a mistake, though not yet a ground for relief. A mover who counts the pile correctly but expects diesel prices to stay flat, and watches them climb the next month, has made a prediction that failed.
Sometimes the classification is itself the dispute. In the ALCOA litigation, ALCOA called the mistaken assumption that the index was suitable a factual assumption, and Essex called it a prediction. The court treated this as a dispute of facts, not law. Separating fact from opinion, prediction, and desire, it said, is principally a question of common sense, and a jury or other fact finder can answer it.10 The same opinion explains why the purchaser lost in Taussig. That decision rested on two legs: the absence of a mistake of “fact” and the assumption of the risk of future uncertainties. The parties had bottomed a short-term, outright sale of a business on a naked prediction, with no conditions or limitations, so the disappointed purchaser could point to no fact that existed when the contract was made.11
The definition also keeps the erroneous belief apart from what the party does because of it. A party who signs a deal that turns out badly often says the contract itself was the mistake. The Restatement withholds the word from that improvident act, including the making of a contract, and applies it only to the erroneous belief behind the act.12 Otherwise anyone who regretted a deal could claim a mistake. The word is likewise not meant for a misunderstanding, in which the two parties attach different meanings to their language.13
A belief about the law can also be a mistake. Early common law cases assumed that everyone should know the law, and they refused relief even when one or both parties misunderstood a law relevant to the transaction, such as the permitted uses of a parcel of land. That assumption may have suited an age of simpler laws. Modern cases treat a mistaken understanding of the law as analogous to a mistake of fact, so it can support relief if the other requirements are met.14
Proving a mistake is therefore only the first step toward avoiding or reforming a contract.15 A mistake may make a contract voidable, but it does not do so automatically.16 The law of mistake grew up in courts of equity and is still applied as a matter of equity, so fault, good faith, unconscionability, and general fairness all bear on the result.17 The ALCOA court made the same point. Concluding that the parties contracted on a mistake of fact did not by itself justify relief. Relief could follow only if the mistake was mutual, related to a basic assumption underlying the contract, and caused a severe imbalance in the agreed exchange.18 The sections that follow take up the full test and the added showing required when only one party is mistaken.