Concept
The Section 153 Test
Unilateral mistake
The Section 153 Test
Section 153 of the Restatement (Second) of Contracts lets a party avoid a contract for its own mistake only when five things are true. The party held an erroneous belief when the contract was made; the belief concerned a basic assumption on which the party made the contract; the mistake has a material effect on the agreed exchange of performances that is adverse to the party; the party does not bear the risk of the mistake under § 154; and either enforcement would be unconscionable, or the other party had reason to know of the mistake or caused it by fault.1 When all five hold, the contract is voidable by the mistaken party.2
The first two requirements, basic assumption and material adverse effect, mirror the elements of mutual mistake, and this unit takes them in turn.3 Risk allocation and the added unilateral showing follow in the sections ahead.
Basic Assumption
The first element asks whether the mistake concerns “a basic assumption on which he made the contract.”4 The Restatement uses “mistake” to mean an erroneous belief, and the belief need not have been articulated: a party may hold a belief about a fact merely by assuming it, without ever considering the alternatives.5 The word does not describe an improvident act, such as making a bad contract, that results from the belief.6 Because that definition reaches unspoken beliefs, the word “basic” does the screening. A party who signs a contract carries many background beliefs, some of which prove false without touching the reason for the deal, and only a false belief on which the party made the contract qualifies.
Older decisions asked a different question: whether the mistake related to the subject matter of the contract. In Sherwood v. Walker, the analysis used to decide the fate of a cow named Rose required a mistake as to the subject matter, and a test framed that way invites an argument over how to describe the thing sold. Later cases, among them Lenawee County Board of Health v. Messerly, rejected that analysis. Most modern courts ask whether the mistake goes to a basic assumption, a more inclusive and more relevant inquiry.7 If both parties assumed that the cow being sold was barren, and that fact had a major effect on her potential use and value, the mistake went to a basic assumption on which the contract was made, whatever one calls the subject matter.8
In a mutual-mistake case the assumption is a joint premise. The false fact must be so fundamental to the shared intent and purpose of both parties that it is reasonable to conclude they would not have made the contract at all, or on its terms, had they known the truth.9 In a unilateral case only the mistaken party held the assumption. It belongs to that party's own reasons for contracting, and the other party may never have heard of it, which makes the inquiry more subjective than its mutual counterpart.10 The subjectivity is bearable because the Restatement's equitable balancing protects the nonmistaken party's reliance on the mistaken party's manifestation of assent.11 The element can afford to be generous because later parts of the test do the protecting.
The price calculation behind a bid is the standard example. A mathematical miscalculation is the typical unilateral mistake: an offeror quotes a price, the offeree accepts, and the offeror then discovers an arithmetic error in the calculation.12 Bill quotes Reliabuild a price for earthmoving, and Reliabuild accepts without asking how he reached it. Bill's calculation lay solely within his realm and forms his individual basic assumption. Reliabuild was, in a sense, also wrong about the correct price, but that does not make the mistake mutual. Reliabuild took no part in determining Bill's price and simply reacted to the end result of his calculations.13
A mistake about price can therefore concern a basic assumption. A price error that does not win avoidance may fail at a later element, and risk allocation is one place it can fail: § 153 withholds avoidance from a party who bears the risk of the mistake, and a party bears it when the agreement allocates it to him.14 Where a price error derived from a mistake about the nature or quantity of what was sold, courts have allowed a remedy, finding no contractual allocation of that sort of risk.15
Satisfying this element is only the first step, as Manny's case shows. Manny ordered a portrait from Leonardo while mistaken about which artist he was engaging. A mistake as to the identity of the other party is treated as a factual error, and this one related to Manny's basic assumption in entering the contract.16 Yet he is likely to lose on risk allocation and the equities. He had ready access to information and advice and should have proceeded more carefully, nothing suggests that Leonardo had reason to suspect the error and exploited it, and Leonardo has a legitimate reliance interest worth protecting.17
Material Adverse Effect
Materiality is the second element § 153 borrows from mutual mistake: the mistake must have “a material effect on the agreed exchange of performances,” and the effect must be adverse to the mistaken party.19 A false belief on which a deal rests might seem certain to disturb the exchange, and the two elements often travel together, yet they ask different questions. Basic assumption examines how the false fact relates to the contract's underlying purpose. Materiality examines what the mistake did to the balance of the exchange, meaning whether it substantially deprived the adversely affected party of the value it expected.20 Comment c to the Restatement's mutual-mistake section asks whether the error creates an overall imbalance, making the exchange less desirable to the adversely affected party and more advantageous to the other. The court therefore weighs both sides of the bargain, and the element carries a component of equitable balancing.21
In a unilateral case the basic assumption is the mistaken party's own, so the first element screens loosely, and a party's statement that it would not have signed had it known the truth cannot carry the case. Showing that this party would not have entered the contract most likely does not, in itself, establish materiality; the party must show that the contract as made is severely imbalanced, so that enforcement would be unfair.22 The requirement also serves the other side. That party relied on the deal and loses it if the contract is avoided, and avoidance is easier to justify when the mistaken party's loss is matched by the other party's gain, as the windfall in the aluminum litigation below illustrates.
A lakefront lot shows how the two elements can part company. A buyer pays $500,000 for a lot, and the parties share the assumption that it can be built on; in fact it is unsuitable for building. Sometimes the effect on the exchange is plain. Suppose instead that the lakefront location is so desirable that the land can still be resold to a campground operator for $500,000. The mistake still formed the basis of the bargain, but it may not have materially affected the exchange, because it did not touch the property's market value. The effect is not clearly immaterial either, since the buyer lost the use the parties contemplated. The considerations that decide materiality differ from those that decide basic assumption, and they can point to a different result.23 The illustration involves a shared mistake, but § 153 uses the same two elements for a unilateral one.
Resale value works as a benchmark in both directions. Manny received the painting he paid for, yet the mistake may still have a material effect on the exchange. The portrait was not the one he bargained for, and a hack-painted portrait of the nouveau riche has little market, so he has scant chance of recouping the price by selling it.24 Where property can be resold at the price paid, as with the campground lot, the mistaken buyer loses less; Manny's portrait offers no such exit.
In price cases materiality has a concrete measure: how large the error is against the contract, and what performance now yields. A contractor whose calculation error puts its bid 25 percent below every other bid likely has a material effect on the transaction.25 Its difficulties come at the next stages, where it must prove it did not assume the risk and must prove either unconscionability, reason to know, or fault.26 Bill, the earthmoving bidder, undercharges so badly that his expected profit becomes an unbearable loss, and the effect on the exchange is material.27 The inquiry runs in three steps.
Aluminum Company of America v. Essex Group applied the same measure over the life of a long-term contract. Some prediction of the future was inescapable, and on the court's prediction ALCOA would lose more than $60 million out of pocket over the contract's life, with the whole loss matched by an equal windfall profit to Essex. That proof clearly established a material effect on the agreed exchange, and the court added that it would not hesitate to hold enforcement unconscionable if that question were before it.28 ALCOA had also suffered increasingly large out-of-pocket losses in the preceding three years. The court acknowledged that a net profit of $9 million, were the contract to expire that day, would raise doubts about materiality. It would still find the mistake material, because that profit would leave ALCOA dramatically short of the minimum return of one cent per pound the parties had contemplated.29 A profit that survives the mistake is thus measured against the return the parties expected.
Size also bears on the remedy a court may consider. A buyer and seller agree on $6 per square foot and sign a $600,000 contract, both believing the lot holds 100,000 square feet when it holds 97,000. The error is worth about three percent of the price. It may fall short of the materiality needed to rescind, yet a mistake that is not material enough to avoid a contract may still support reforming it where there is a fair and equitable way to do so, here an $18,000 abatement of the price.30 The adjustment corrects the price and leaves the deal standing.